ckeditor / github-writer

GitHub Writer - WYSIWYG Rich-Text Editor for GitHub, powered by CKEditor.
https://ckeditor.com/
Other
379 stars 63 forks source link

The Mermaid diagram preview is broken when editing the existing issue #379

Open dufipl opened 2 years ago

dufipl commented 2 years ago

📝 Provide detailed reproduction steps (if any)

  1. Build GH Writer on ghw/epic/367-version-3510-bump branch
  2. Edit the existing issue with the Mermaid diagram with this source code:
    flowchart TB
    A --> B
    B --> C
    D --> D

✔️ Expected result

Zrzut ekranu 2022-10-6 o 11 41 42

❌ Actual result

Zrzut ekranu 2022-10-6 o 11 41 51

On the released version (from the Chrome store) it looks better but still not too good:

Zrzut ekranu 2022-10-6 o 11 42 19

If you'd like to see this fixed sooner, add a 👍 reaction to this post.

dufipl commented 2 years ago

It is a regression from the released version. When preview mode is chosen on the mermaid toolbar the result is even worse:

Zrzut ekranu 2022-11-4 o 14 13 45

The issue persists on the ghw/411-version-3530-bump branch

mlewand commented 2 years ago

Intersting, I would assume that this could be in the mermaid plugin itself that it got broken by some upstream changes along the way. Requires further investigation.

mmotyczynska commented 1 year ago

I checked this and the reason for not displaying the diagram properly on edit is that the dom element, where the diagram should be rendered, is not visible at the time of rendering. This is because we load editor before the edit button is clicked, i.e. when the user clicks the three-dots button:

At this time the element where we want to render the diagram is not visible as the editor itself is also not visible until (and if) the user clicks edit button.

There are at least two solutions for this issue:

  1. Create the editor when the edit button is clicked (github-writer repository), not earlier.
    1. The UX of this is poor as the user can see how the original editor is switched to CKE5.
  2. Update mermaid package so it does not render the diagram until the dom element is visible.

I recommend the second one. So to fix the original issue I will change the ckeditor5-mermaid package and after releasing the new version I will update it in this project.

mmotyczynska commented 1 year ago

It is a regression from the released version. When preview mode is chosen on the mermaid toolbar the result is even worse:

Regarding this even worse issue, it is caused by the new version of mermaid package (starting from 9.1.7). However, it will be also fixed with the solution I described above.