search

clamsproject / mmif

MultiMedia Interchange Format
Apache License 2.0
4 stars 1 forks source link

`frameType` values in `TimeFrame` #207

Closed keighrim closed 11 months ago

keighrim commented 1 year ago

Currently a set of values are specified in the vocab as https://github.com/clamsproject/mmif/blob/79c621f5c3dabb499a0878f30a59ca25b56bbb5d/vocabulary/clams.vocabulary.yaml#L140

But we already have apps that generate frameType=bars, frameType=tone, frameType=chyron, and possibly many more to come. Should we relax the prose in the type definition and explicitly say the value can be anything?

** regarding chyron, I raised a question about its appropriateness, compared to non-proper noun-based lower-third. In addition to that question, we might also want to think about how to handle synonyms and their normalization (to one representative value).

marcverhagen commented 1 year ago

We could add the newly introduced values, but also make clear that it is not an exhaustive list:

properties:
  frameType:
    type: String
    description: The type of TimeFrame. Possible values include, but are not limited to, bars-and-tones, speech, noise, music, other, bars, tone, chyron and credits.
keighrim commented 11 months ago

closed via 210