Closed ghost closed 8 years ago
It is essential to know what is game patch the "World of Warcraft bestiary" relates to?
Verdan the Everliving has Health=3872 and this value matches to TBC and WotLK DBs (HGC-DB and YTDB, specifically). But there is possibility that his Classic health was higher (4167 in old SDB and current ClassicDB). It is common case, there are many creatures with slightly reduced health in later patches.
On the other hand, melee damage 277-369 from L21 Elite creature seems something extreme and interesting. Related wowhead comments:
"He hits VERY hard, much harder than any other boss inside Wailing Caverns. He doesn't have an overwhelming amount of hit points though"
"This boss hits hard and has a vast amount of hitpoints"
"Hits for around 144 on a lvl 21 tank with 40% physical reduction and had demo shout up".
"...the tank was dead while i was casting to heal. Our tank died like after 3 hits."
So 277-369 might be true. But also maybe it might be not so much, 116-208 (TBC HGC-DB). Anyway, current ClassicDB 101-130 is too low, without doubt.
In place of Cala I would accept this patch in its "guaranteed aspects" - when it makes creatures stronger, because Blizzard only nerfed things in course of time. Position changes are also likely to be true, even if taken from post-Classic patches, but only up to WotLK, not from Cataclysm and later - you could be more specific about the source of these observations.
Interesting points regarding the validity of stats and the possible causes for deviation(e.g. if there is a reduction in a certain patch). Perhaps we could try to document this on the forums or somewhere it's easily accessible?
Very good place to document various subjects is https://github.com/cmangos/issues/wiki
But it requires certain amount of energy and intent to document something (with some degree of quality).
I would go out on a limb and say that GitHub's wiki format doesn't really encourage discussions. If it worked like Wikipedia where we could attach a "talk" section to the various topics as well then I would agree.
edit: accidentally managed to press "close and comment".
You are right, but on the other hand forums are bad place for document something.
Fixes pushed in recent commits (from this issue and backports from UDB). The creature stats update will come later. I let the issue open in the meantime.
Your will, my hands.
I was thinking of doing it myself but if you like to go to the coal mine, feel free to do it. :wink:
TABLE: creature
TABLE: creature_template
NOTE: