classicdb / database

Classic DB is a content database for CMaNGOS Classic: world, NPCs, objects, quests and so on.
https://github.com/cmangos/mangos-classic
Other
87 stars 59 forks source link

Quality control against Joana's 1 - 60 leveling guide [Video 1/54 (1 - 6 Durotar)] #896

Open Phatcat opened 8 years ago

Phatcat commented 8 years ago

https://youtu.be/SwLjJH8LXfc?list=PL49Ga_-r7iKkxrbckm9CkUhWzxqrOnw-n

1:20 Kaltunk (NPC) is supposed to do /talk animation when you interact with him initially (but nothing when you accept the quest) - currently he does nothing at all.

1:35 Gornek (NPC) is supposed to do /question animation when you select the quest from the gossip menu - currently he dosn't.

5:35 Gormek (NPC) is supposed to do /laugh animation (with sound!) when you select your quest reward from the quest you accepted in the bug above; he should NOT do /talk animation as he currently does on cmangos when you select the quest to turn in in his gossip menu. the two quests he has available right after are displayed in the wrong order in his gossip menu and he should be doing /talk animation when you accept 'Sting of the Scorpid'

5:48 Zureetha Fargaze (NPC) is supposed to do /talk animation when you interact with her initially (nothing when you accept the quest), currently she does nothing at all.

5:53 Jen'shan (NPC - Hunter Trainer) is supposed to do /bow animation when you select the quest to turn it in from the gossip menu, currently she does /talk animation. Then when you press continue to the next quest she is supposed to do either /talk or /question animation (I can't really make it out as she has her back turned -.-) - currently she does nothing there.

21:05 Quest giver is supposed to greet you with emote (the same emote as when adding '!' at the end of a message); curerently he just turns to your location - you can also make out that he does /talk animation on last interaction with him (accept quest)

21:19 Duokna (NPC) should be selling 'Crude Throwing Axe' as well as 'Small Throwing Knife' in stacks of 200 for 15c , currently she doesn't sell those items at all. Also the items she does sell are presented in the wrong order.

21:46 this quest giver is also supposed to emote you on interaction (/talk animation). Should once again do /talk animation when you have chosen your quest reward. Currently also just turns to your location (default behaviour).

24:48 the cactus she loots in the video at this moment in the video does not exist in cmangos (at least not for classic-db)

31:27 When you turn in the quest to the questiver who's supposed to emote you when he has a quest, he's supposed to do the /question animation, and then /talk animation once you accept it.

31:59 When you turn in the quest at this questgiver he's supposed to greet you with the '!' emote, then when you take the follow-up quest he's supposed to greet you with /talk emote) - currently he does neither.

Using the Hearthstone as troll/orc to return to it's default location (at the den) then the spawn position is wrong; it may only be orientation (which is almost as wrong as it gets) but the position itself may also be messed up.

39:04 This NPC should be kneeling, he should also greet you with emote /talk when you engage.

39:15 This NPC is supposed to greet you with /talk emote animation when you turn in the quest. You also see he is about to start the /talk animation again as joana leaves after taking the 3rd quest from him. Furthermore the quests are not presented in the right order, we clearly see the one word quest being in the middle in the vid while it appears last on cmangos. Two next questgivers in the video also react with /talk emote animation when you interact with them, on cmangos they do nothing.

40:20 NPC missing /talk animation on interaction.

49:52 Player has wrong answer / gossipt choise when wanting to train, it should read: "Please train me" - and no, it's not supposed to be punctuated as far as I can make out.

50:02 When you take the 'vanquish the betrayers' quest or what it's called, the npc is supposed to do '!' animation at you, when you open the gossip menu to turn in the quest without having done it he will point at you. currently in cmangos he actually does something when you interact with him, too bad he is actually not supposed to do anything on initial contact, but in cmangos he does /talk animation.

50:22 the questgiver is supposed to do '!' animation at you, currently he does not. Also when he is idle he should be doing /talk emote to noone in particular, while currently in cmangos he does something weird with his hands like he's making potions. He even does this while you speak to him. the vendor next to him actually does /talk animation when you speak to him on cmangos, but this is wrong, he shouldn't be doing any animation. also it should go directly to his shop window, his NPC should not have a gossip window. Also the items in his shop are listed in the wrong order; they should be listed in the following order: First all food items, then recipies (he only has 1) then all drink items. On cmangos it looks a right mess honestly.

51:10 this NPC should bow down when you interact with him, currently on cmangos he does nothing.

51:45 This NPC should; /talk animation when you turn in the quest, /question when he does the gossip menu for which reward you wanna choose and once again /talk when you've made your choise. Currently he only does the first of those, but not the 2 last ones.

Edit*: Added the very early ones (didn't start paying attention to NPC interaction until a couple of levels in, as you may have noticed, so just redid the first 20 minutes of the video, and indeed there was a couple in the beginning)

~~General: The lazy peons are not chopping at the trees on cmangos, they're schopping at their pile, which seems very weird and wrong, the peons real behaviour can be seen throughout the first half hour of the video.~~ Has rightly been raised as a core issue recently; https://github.com/cmangos/issues/issues/1143

cala commented 8 years ago

This video is obviously fake. It is suggesting that orcs would be able of more subtle gestures than grunting or burping. Who would believe that? What next ? Gnomes with well-taste haircut ? Tss...

I'll look at this and the ACID part when I'm back.

Tobschinski commented 8 years ago

assign more calas, unleash them

Phatcat commented 7 years ago

Aw, only 1 cala on this now.. =/