search

clearlinux / clr-bundles

Bundle definitions for Clear Linux OS
112 stars 54 forks source link

Java LTS (17 and 11)? #226

Open K0-RR opened 2 years ago

K0-RR commented 2 years ago

The only bundles that provide java are these: https://clearlinux.org/software/bundle/java13-basic https://clearlinux.org/software/bundle/java13-runtime https://clearlinux.org/software/bundle/java-basic https://clearlinux.org/software/bundle/java-runtime

It looks like it's only java 8 and 13. None of them are supported anymore and should not be used. Can you add bundle with the jdk 17 (and 11 if possible). Without these you cannot run many java programs.

skjolber commented 2 years ago

What about this? https://clearlinux.org/software/bundle/java11-basic Cant seem to find any for 17 though.

jnorthrup commented 2 years ago

suggesting NOT having distro-level support of jdk/jvm families of tools and offloading support to https://sdkman.io for the java bytecode domain and especially the maven/gradle tools.

skjolber commented 2 years ago

@jnorthrup but will those sdkman binaries be compiled in the same way as the current clear linux OpenJDK?

jnorthrup commented 2 years ago

@jnorthrup but will those sdkman binaries be compiled in the same way as the current clear linux OpenJDK?

given the CLR usecase of shrink-wrapping highest performing builds, @marc0der might be persuaded to consider such a thing.

marc0der commented 2 years ago

@jnorthrup the binaries downloaded through SDKMAN are the exact binaries found on the origin download sites; we do not tamper with any binaries that upstream vendors provide.

romario74 commented 1 year ago

Please forgive my ignorance, we are new to clear linux and looking for JRE17. Is there already a decision if the Java LTS version will be included? Seems we now have to downgrade out app to jre11?

fenrus75 commented 1 year ago

we're at a slightly newer JDK but unlike the 8-11 transition, newer JDKs are (supposed to be) fully compatible... So I wouldn't downgrade but just use the main JDK

On Wed, Feb 15, 2023 at 5:56 AM Rainer @.***> wrote:

Please forgive my ignorance, we are new to clear linux and looking for JRE17. Is there already a decision if the Java LTS version will be included? Seems we now have to downgrade out app to jre11?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>

fenrus75 commented 1 year ago

btw if there's a strong reason why current JDK is not compatible/working we'd like to know (adding more jdk's is work for us in both maintenance and dealing with the logic to switch between them... we rather have one really good one than a mess with switching if we can)

On Wed, Feb 15, 2023 at 6:07 AM Arjan van de Ven @.***> wrote:

we're at a slightly newer JDK but unlike the 8-11 transition, newer JDKs are (supposed to be) fully compatible... So I wouldn't downgrade but just use the main JDK

On Wed, Feb 15, 2023 at 5:56 AM Rainer @.***> wrote:

Please forgive my ignorance, we are new to clear linux and looking for JRE17. Is there already a decision if the Java LTS version will be included? Seems we now have to downgrade out app to jre11?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>