Closed cleder closed 1 month ago
This pull request implements XML schema validation for KML documents and reorganizes code to ensure proper validation. The changes include adding a new validation module, restructuring registry entries to match schema order, and updating test cases to validate against the schema.
classDiagram
class RegistryItem {
+ns_ids: Tuple[str, ...]
+attr_name: str
+node_name: str
+classes: Tuple[Type, ...]
+get_kwarg: Callable
+set_element: Callable
+default: Any
}
class AltitudeMode {
+absolute
+clamp_to_ground
+relative_to_ground
+get_ns_id() str
}
class Point
class LineString
class Polygon
class Link
class SimpleField
class Data
class Track
class MultiTrack
RegistryItem --> AltitudeMode
RegistryItem --> Point
RegistryItem --> LineString
RegistryItem --> Polygon
RegistryItem --> Link
RegistryItem --> SimpleField
RegistryItem --> Data
RegistryItem --> Track
RegistryItem --> MultiTrack
AltitudeMode --> RegistryItem
Point --> RegistryItem
LineString --> RegistryItem
Polygon --> RegistryItem
Link --> RegistryItem
SimpleField --> RegistryItem
Data --> RegistryItem
Track --> RegistryItem
MultiTrack --> RegistryItem
Change | Details | Files |
---|---|---|
Added XML schema validation functionality |
|
fastkml/validate.py tests/base.py |
Reorganized registry entries to match XML schema order |
|
fastkml/geometry.py fastkml/links.py fastkml/data.py fastkml/enums.py |
Updated test infrastructure and test cases |
|
tests/hypothesis/links_test.py tests/hypothesis/common.py tests/hypothesis/multi_geometry_test.py tests/hypothesis/geometry_test.py |
Fixed path handling in example scripts |
|
examples/shp2kml.py examples/shp2kml_timed.py examples/simple_example.py examples/transform_cascading_style.py |
[!WARNING]
Rate limit exceeded
@cleder has exceeded the limit for the number of commits or files that can be reviewed per hour. Please wait 13 minutes and 49 seconds before requesting another review.
โ How to resolve this issue?
After the wait time has elapsed, a review can be triggered using the `@coderabbitai review` command as a PR comment. Alternatively, push new commits to this PR. We recommend that you space out your commits to avoid hitting the rate limit.๐ฆ How do rate limits work?
CodeRabbit enforces hourly rate limits for each developer per organization. Our paid plans have higher rate limits than the trial, open-source and free plans. In all cases, we re-allow further reviews after a brief timeout. Please see our [FAQ](https://coderabbit.ai/docs/faq) for further information.๐ฅ Commits
Reviewing files that changed from the base of the PR and between 2ce6a642726353a614d3188667dfbe0d22ab193c and 0d0423eec884cab02da36d7d0c10e56ff786fa81.
The pull request introduces multiple changes across various files, primarily focusing on enhancements to the GitHub Actions workflow, updates to geometry handling in the fastkml
library, and improvements in test coverage and structure. Key modifications include the addition of new jobs in the CI/CD process, updates to KML handling functions, and the introduction of new test cases for validating the functionality of KML elements and geometry classes.
File | Change Summary |
---|---|
.github/workflows/run-all-tests.yml |
- Added build-package and test-publish jobs.- Modified publish job to be conditional and include additional steps. |
.pre-commit-config.yaml |
- Updated exclusion pattern for mixed-line-ending hook.- Removed flynt and pyupgrade hooks. |
docs/working_with_kml.rst |
- Updated documentation with new examples for find and find_all functions; modified KML Placemark ID. |
examples/shp2kml.py |
- Replaced hardcoded paths with dynamic path constructions using pathlib.Path . |
examples/shp2kml_timed.py |
- Similar path handling updates as shp2kml.py . |
examples/simple_example.py |
- Changed hardcoded KML sample path to dynamic construction. |
examples/transform_cascading_style.py |
- Added dynamic path handling for KML file. |
fastkml/data.py |
- Updated registrations for SimpleField and Data classes to reorganize attribute handling. |
fastkml/enums.py |
- Added get_ns_id method to AltitudeMode enum class. |
fastkml/features.py |
- Reordered attributes in _Feature class related to atom_link and atom_author . |
fastkml/geometry.py |
- Removed _Geometry class registration; updated Point , LineString , and Polygon registrations to include altitude_mode . |
fastkml/gx.py |
- Enhanced Track and MultiTrack class registrations with new attributes. |
fastkml/helpers.py |
- Modified enum_subelement function for dynamic namespace handling. |
fastkml/links.py |
- Restructured registrations for Link class attributes with renamed and adjusted default values. |
fastkml/schema/atom-author-link.xsd |
- Introduced new XML Schema Definition for Atom author and link elements. |
fastkml/validate.py |
- Added functionality for validating KML files against an XML schema. |
fastkml/views.py |
- Made altitude_mode parameter optional in Camera and LookAt classes. |
tests/base.py |
- Imported get_schema_parser function for lxml setup. |
tests/geometries/geometry_test.py |
- Removed multiple test methods related to to_string functionality; adjusted assertions regarding altitude_mode . |
tests/geometries/multigeometry_test.py |
- Updated assertions in test_multi_geometries_verbose and added test_geometry_error method for invalid geometry handling. |
tests/geometries/polygon_test.py |
- Modified assertions in test_exterior_interior_tessellate_extrude_altitude_mode . |
tests/gx_test.py |
- Simplified assertions in test_track_from_linestring and updated test_track_from_track_items method. |
tests/hypothesis/common.py |
- Introduced common functionality for property-based testing using Hypothesis. |
tests/hypothesis/geometry_test.py |
- Refactored test cases into a new TestLxml class; added validation checks using validate function. |
tests/hypothesis/links_test.py |
- Added a test suite for the Link class using property-based testing. |
tests/hypothesis/multi_geometry_test.py |
- Enhanced structure and functionality of tests for various geometry classes; added validation and refactored test methods into a new TestLxml class. |
tests/overlays_test.py |
- Updated assertions related to altitude_mode in PhotoOverlay class tests. |
enhancement
, Review effort [1-5]: 4
, Tests
In the garden where KMLs bloom,
We tweak and test, dispelling gloom.
With paths that flex and workflows bright,
Our code hops high, a joyful sight!
So here's to changes, fresh and spry,
A leap of code, oh my, oh my! ๐โจ
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media?
Enhanced GitHub Actions Workflow: We've made improvements to our checks, tests, and package creation process. This includes adding more checks to the process, a clearer name for the job that builds our software package, and stricter validations before that package is published.
Adjusted Pre-commit Config: We've excluded additional test files from pre-checks to optimize this process.
Documentation Correction: A typographical error in our documentation has been addressed.
Improved Path Management in Scripts: We've enhanced how example scripts handle data file paths. The update ensures that the paths are set up dynamically, which should make these scripts more resilient and easy to run in different environments.
New Schema File Added: We've introduced a new file that outlines the structure of our data, which can help during data validation and troubleshooting.
Codebase Enhancements: Our code for handling geospatial data and XML has been improved. This has included adding features and improving the management of XML data in various classes of our software package.
Removed Redundant Registrations: To make our software more efficient and easier to maintain, we've cleaned up repetitive data entries.
New File for KML Validation: We've introduced a new script that makes it easier to check if KML (a format for geographic data) files are in the correct format according to the prescribed structure.
Updated altitude_mode parameter: We've made changes to how we handle one of the key parameters in our application, increasing the flexibility of how altitude data can be processed.
Import Updated for schema validation in tests: Our tests can now use our new KML validation more effectively.
Updated Test Cases to Reflect Codebase Changes: We've ensured that our tests accurately reflect the current state of our application, including changes made to how we manage altitude data.
New Files for More Robust Testing: We've added new tools for testing, making it easier to identify and fix any issues with our property-based testing. It will facilitate thorough check for properties of Link and Icon.
Attention: Patch coverage is 94.71545%
with 13 lines
in your changes missing coverage. Please review.
Project coverage is 98.40%. Comparing base (
1bb3536
) to head (0d0423e
). Report is 15 commits behind head on develop.
Files with missing lines | Patch % | Lines |
---|---|---|
fastkml/validate.py | 60.71% | 6 Missing and 5 partials :warning: |
fastkml/enums.py | 50.00% | 1 Missing and 1 partial :warning: |
:umbrella: View full report in Codecov by Sentry.
:loudspeaker: Have feedback on the report? Share it here.
Preparing review...
Preparing review...
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Test Coverage The new TestLxml class adds XML validation to existing tests. Review if all important geometry types and edge cases are covered. Error Handling The validate function uses lxml for XML validation. Review the error handling and logging to ensure it provides useful information for debugging invalid KML. API Changes Changes to the AltitudeMode handling in geometry classes. Verify that this doesn't break existing code relying on default values. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Use a context manager for file operations to ensure proper resource management___ **Consider using a context manager to handle file operations when parsing the XMLschema. This ensures proper resource management and file closure, even if an exception occurs.** [fastkml/validate.py [45]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/373/files#diff-7fda623fa44359e3728843087ee3ccf328f6af66ff6ea423263608881cac1de9R45-R45) ```diff -return config.etree.XMLSchema(config.etree.parse(schema)) +with open(schema, 'rb') as schema_file: + return config.etree.XMLSchema(config.etree.parse(schema_file)) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion to use a context manager for file operations is valid as it ensures proper resource management and file closure, even if an exception occurs. This enhances the robustness of the code. | 8 |
Add a timeout to the Hypothesis settings to prevent indefinite test execution___ **Consider adding a timeout parameter to thesettings decorator to prevent long-running tests from blocking the test suite.** [tests/hypothesis/geometry_test.py [149]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/373/files#diff-fef1f4e6f2bce9c140d9912c7cd16e73f8f5b17e8abd9a08ed6469202915b7caR149-R149) ```diff -@settings(deadline=None) +@settings(deadline=None, max_examples=100, timeout=60) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding a timeout to the Hypothesis settings is a good practice to prevent tests from running indefinitely, which can block the test suite. This suggestion improves test reliability and efficiency. | 7 | |
Use a constant for the default view format string to improve code maintainability___ **Consider using a constant or an enum for the default view format string to improvemaintainability and reduce the risk of typos.** [fastkml/geometry.py [202]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/373/files#diff-47314ad0817fc0fdde5a4ccab1250d104c27d592f1dd0f9952b454a4e3cdf65dR202-R202) ```diff -default="BBOX=[bboxWest],[bboxSouth],[bboxEast],[bboxNorth]", +DEFAULT_VIEW_FORMAT = "BBOX=[bboxWest],[bboxSouth],[bboxEast],[bboxNorth]" +# ... (earlier in the file) +default=DEFAULT_VIEW_FORMAT, ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Using a constant for the default view format string enhances code maintainability and reduces the risk of typos. This suggestion is beneficial for improving code readability and consistency. | 6 | |
Use standard Python notation for numeric literals in decorators___ **Consider using a more specific decorator like@settings(deadline=1000) instead of @settings(deadline=1_000) for better readability and consistency with Python's standard notation for numeric literals.** [tests/hypothesis/multi_geometry_test.py [202-203]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/373/files#diff-62429ef5316bba4d85f3d395ed68e6adaf2bfa4bc618ac4ebadc42ca78d6a568R202-R203) ```diff -@settings(deadline=1_000) +@settings(deadline=1000) def test_multipoint_repr_roundtrip( ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 2Why: The suggestion to change the numeric literal format from '1_000' to '1000' is minor and primarily stylistic. It does not affect functionality but may improve readability for some developers. | 2 | |
Maintainability |
Use more descriptive variable names to improve code readability___ **Consider using a more descriptive variable name instead ofe in the error logging loop to improve code readability and maintainability.** [fastkml/validate.py [85-99]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/373/files#diff-7fda623fa44359e3728843087ee3ccf328f6af66ff6ea423263608881cac1de9R85-R99) ```diff -for e in log: +for error_entry in log: try: - parent = element.xpath(e.path)[ # type: ignore[union-attr] + parent = element.xpath(error_entry.path)[ # type: ignore[union-attr] 0 ].getparent() except config.etree.XPathEvalError: parent = element error_in_xml = config.etree.tostring( parent, encoding="UTF-8", pretty_print=True, ).decode( "UTF-8", ) - logger.error("Error <%s> in XML:\n %s", e.message, error_in_xml) + logger.error("Error <%s> in XML:\n %s", error_entry.message, error_in_xml) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The suggestion to use a more descriptive variable name instead of `e` improves code readability and maintainability. While it is a minor enhancement, it contributes positively to the code's clarity. | 6 |
Use a constant for the deadline value in test settings___ **Consider using a constant for the deadline value in the@settings decorator to improve maintainability and allow for easier adjustments across multiple tests if needed.** [tests/hypothesis/multi_geometry_test.py [202-203]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/373/files#diff-62429ef5316bba4d85f3d395ed68e6adaf2bfa4bc618ac4ebadc42ca78d6a568R202-R203) ```diff -@settings(deadline=1_000) +MULTIPOINT_TEST_DEADLINE = 1000 + +@settings(deadline=MULTIPOINT_TEST_DEADLINE) def test_multipoint_repr_roundtrip( ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: Using a constant for the deadline value can improve maintainability by allowing easier adjustments across multiple tests. This suggestion is practical and enhances code manageability. | 5 |
๐ก Need additional feedback ? start a PR chat
Failed to generate code suggestions for PR
Preparing review...
User description
PR Type
enhancement, tests, bug fix, documentation, configuration changes, dependencies
Description
get_schema_parser
andvalidate
functions.pathlib
.atom:link
andatom:author
.flynt
andpyupgrade
hooks.Changes walkthrough ๐
10 files
multi_geometry_test.py
Enhance multi-geometry tests with XML validation and refactoring.
tests/hypothesis/multi_geometry_test.py
validate
function calls to ensure XML schema validation.TestLxml
class for testing withlxml
.TestLxml
.ID_TEXT
withnc_name
strategy for generating IDs.geometry_test.py
Enhance geometry tests with XML validation and refactoring.
tests/hypothesis/geometry_test.py
validate
function calls for XML schema validation.TestLxml
class for testing withlxml
.TestLxml
.ID_TEXT
withnc_name
strategy for generating IDs.geometry_test.py
Simplify geometry tests by removing verbosity checks.
tests/geometries/geometry_test.py
links_test.py
Add hypothesis-based tests for Link and Icon with validation.
tests/hypothesis/links_test.py
Link
andIcon
using Hypothesis.common.py
Add common strategies for hypothesis tests.
tests/hypothesis/common.py
nc_name
andquery_strings
strategies.overlays_test.py
Adjust overlay tests for new altitude mode defaults.
tests/overlays_test.py - Updated test to reflect changes in default altitude mode.
polygon_test.py
Adjust polygon tests for new altitude mode handling.
tests/geometries/polygon_test.py - Updated assertions to reflect changes in altitude mode handling.
multigeometry_test.py
Adjust multigeometry tests for new altitude mode handling.
tests/geometries/multigeometry_test.py - Updated assertions to reflect changes in altitude mode handling.
gx_test.py
Adjust GX tests for new altitude mode handling.
tests/gx_test.py - Updated assertions to reflect changes in altitude mode handling.
base.py
Initialize schema parser in Lxml setup method.
tests/base.py - Added schema parser setup in `Lxml` setup method.
13 files
geometry.py
Refactor geometry registry entries for clarity and consistency.
fastkml/geometry.py
AltitudeMode
andCoordinates
.validate.py
Add XML schema validation module for KML files.
fastkml/validate.py
get_schema_parser
andvalidate
functions.links.py
Update Link class registry entries and defaults.
fastkml/links.py
Link
class attributes.data.py
Refactor data registry entries for consistency.
fastkml/data.py
SimpleField
andData
.gx.py
Register altitude mode for Track and MultiTrack.
fastkml/gx.py
Track
andMultiTrack
altitude modes.transform_cascading_style.py
Use pathlib for file path handling in examples.
examples/transform_cascading_style.py
pathlib
for handling file paths.views.py
Update default altitude mode in view constructors.
fastkml/views.py - Changed default `altitude_mode` to `None` in constructors.
shp2kml_timed.py
Use pathlib for file path handling in examples.
examples/shp2kml_timed.py
pathlib
for handling file paths.shp2kml.py
Use pathlib for file path handling in examples.
examples/shp2kml.py
pathlib
for handling file paths.simple_example.py
Use pathlib for file path handling in examples.
examples/simple_example.py
pathlib
for handling file paths.enums.py
Add namespace ID retrieval to AltitudeMode.
fastkml/enums.py - Added `get_ns_id` method to `AltitudeMode`.
helpers.py
Enhance enum_subelement to support namespace IDs.
fastkml/helpers.py - Modified `enum_subelement` to handle namespace IDs.
ogckml22.xsd
Add XML Schema Definition for OGC KML 2.2
fastkml/schema/ogckml22.xsd
1 files
features.py
Correct registry entries for atom link and author.
fastkml/features.py - Swapped registry entries for `atom:link` and `atom:author`.
2 files
run-all-tests.yml
Update CI workflow to include example runs and test-publish.
.github/workflows/run-all-tests.yml
.pre-commit-config.yaml
Update pre-commit configuration and hooks.
.pre-commit-config.yaml
flynt
andpyupgrade
hooks.1 files
atom-author-link.xsd
Add XML schema for Atom author and link.
fastkml/schema/atom-author-link.xsd - Added new XML schema for Atom author and link elements.
1 files
working_with_kml.rst
Fix typo in KML example in documentation.
docs/working_with_kml.rst - Corrected a typo in the KML example.
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
fastkml
library.Bug Fixes
Tests
Chores