Closed cleder closed 3 weeks ago
This PR refactors and improves the KML library's handling of GX (Google Earth Extensions) tracks and coordinates, while also adding hypothesis tests for atom and GX components. The changes focus on improving type safety, validation, and test coverage.
classDiagram
class Angle {
float heading
float tilt
float roll
PointType coords
}
class TrackItem {
KmlDateTime when
geo.Point coord
Angle angle
}
class Track {
List~TrackItem~ track_items
Tuple~KmlDateTime~ whens
Tuple~PointType~ coords
Tuple~PointType~ angles
+Track(ns: str, id: Optional~str~, target_id: Optional~str~, altitude_mode: Optional~AltitudeMode~, track_items: Optional~Iterable~TrackItem~~, whens: Optional~Iterable~KmlDateTime~~, coords: Optional~Iterable~PointType~~, angles: Optional~Iterable~PointType~~)
}
classDiagram
class Link {
str href
Optional~RefreshMode~ refresh_mode
Optional~float~ refresh_interval
Optional~ViewRefreshMode~ view_refresh_mode
Optional~float~ view_refresh_time
Optional~float~ view_bound_scale
str view_format
str http_query
}
class Icon {
str href
Optional~RefreshMode~ refresh_mode
Optional~float~ refresh_interval
Optional~ViewRefreshMode~ view_refresh_mode
Optional~float~ view_refresh_time
Optional~float~ view_bound_scale
str view_format
str http_query
}
Change | Details | Files |
---|---|---|
Refactored GX Track and MultiTrack implementation |
|
fastkml/gx.py |
Enhanced validation and helper functions |
|
fastkml/validator.py fastkml/helpers.py |
Added comprehensive hypothesis testing |
|
tests/hypothesis/atom_test.py tests/hypothesis/gx_test.py tests/hypothesis/strategies.py tests/validator_test.py |
Improved type handling in Atom components |
|
fastkml/atom.py |
Attention: Patch coverage is 99.68847%
with 1 line
in your changes missing coverage. Please review.
Project coverage is 98.69%. Comparing base (
68a3a8a
) to head (742f731
).
Files with missing lines | Patch % | Lines |
---|---|---|
fastkml/gx.py | 97.14% | 0 Missing and 1 partial :warning: |
:umbrella: View full report in Codecov by Sentry.
:loudspeaker: Have feedback on the report? Share it here.
[!WARNING]
Rate limit exceeded
@cleder has exceeded the limit for the number of commits or files that can be reviewed per hour. Please wait 4 minutes and 32 seconds before requesting another review.
โ How to resolve this issue?
After the wait time has elapsed, a review can be triggered using the `@coderabbitai review` command as a PR comment. Alternatively, push new commits to this PR. We recommend that you space out your commits to avoid hitting the rate limit.๐ฆ How do rate limits work?
CodeRabbit enforces hourly rate limits for each developer per organization. Our paid plans have higher rate limits than the trial, open-source and free plans. In all cases, we re-allow further reviews after a brief timeout. Please see our [FAQ](https://coderabbit.ai/docs/faq) for further information.๐ฅ Commits
Reviewing files that changed from the base of the PR and between d8de3a0b51c1928e6e3c59049914a887af1ba1a9 and 28e0deebb6ff5f746b862e7febadb5ca51d2b2ce.
The pull request introduces several modifications across various files, primarily focusing on type annotations, error handling, and test enhancements. Key changes include updates to the .pre-commit-config.yaml
for hook configurations, adjustments in type requirements for attributes in class definitions, and the addition of new testing strategies utilizing the Hypothesis library. The changes aim to improve code robustness, maintainability, and test coverage without altering existing functionalities significantly.
File | Change Summary |
---|---|
.pre-commit-config.yaml |
Updated exclusion patterns for the name-tests-test hook, removing tests/hypothesis/common.py and adding tests/hypothesis/strategies.py . |
fastkml/atom.py |
Changed type annotations from Optional[str] to str for several attributes in Link and _Person classes, ensuring they are required. Updated constructors for default empty string initialization. Removed NS from __all__ . |
fastkml/base.py |
Simplified __eq__ method in _XMLObject class by removing type assertion and directly comparing __dict__ attributes. |
fastkml/geometry.py |
Updated classes parameter type in subelement_coordinates_kwarg function to Tuple[Type[object], ...] . Refined error handling in create_kml_geometry . |
fastkml/gx.py |
Enhanced Track and MultiTrack classes with new properties and constructor parameters. Added coords property to Angle class. |
fastkml/helpers.py |
Introduced new functions for handling KML data types and improved type hinting throughout. |
fastkml/links.py |
Changed href , view_format , and http_query attributes from Optional[str] to str , ensuring they are required. |
fastkml/registry.py |
Removed known_types type alias and updated its usage in GetKWArgs and RegistryItem . |
fastkml/schema/kml22gx.xsd |
Updated schema location from an absolute URL to a relative path. |
fastkml/times.py |
Added get_ns_id method to KmlDateTime class for standardized namespace ID access. |
fastkml/utils.py |
Enhanced docstrings for several functions to improve clarity on parameters and return types. |
fastkml/validator.py |
Introduced constants for error messages and refined error handling in the validate function. Updated return type annotation for get_schema_parser . |
pyproject.toml |
Updated tests dependency from "hypothesis" to "hypothesis[zoneinfo]" . |
tests/atom_test.py |
Modified assertions for href and name attributes to check for empty strings instead of None . |
tests/base.py |
Updated import path for get_schema_parser from validate to validator . |
tests/gx_test.py |
Refactored tests to use KmlDateTime for time data and simplified from_string method calls. Added new tests for invalid date formats. |
tests/helper_test.py |
Added tests for subelement_bool_kwarg function and removed duplicate imports. |
tests/hypothesis/atom_test.py |
Introduced unit tests for Link and Author classes using Hypothesis for property-based testing. |
tests/hypothesis/common.py |
Added new functions for string round-trip assertions and removed unused imports. |
tests/hypothesis/geometry_test.py |
Updated import paths and refactored test functions to utilize new assertion helpers. |
tests/hypothesis/gx_test.py |
Added property-based tests for Track and MultiTrack classes, focusing on various parameters and roundtrip assertions. |
tests/hypothesis/links_test.py |
Consolidated test strategies using a common decorator and updated import paths. |
tests/hypothesis/multi_geometry_test.py |
Updated import paths to reflect changes in module structure. |
tests/hypothesis/strategies.py |
Introduced custom strategies for generating test data using Hypothesis. |
tests/registry_test.py |
Updated get_kwarg function signature to remove known_types alias. |
tests/styles_test.py |
Added imports for Document and Placemark to enhance test accessibility. |
tests/validator_test.py |
Introduced a new test suite for the validator module, enhancing coverage for various validation scenarios. |
.pre-commit-config.yaml
file, directly relating to updates made in this PR regarding pre-commit hook configurations.hypothesis
library as a dependency, aligning with updates in the main PR.features_test.py
and helper_test.py
, related to improvements in testing practices in the main PR.enhancement
, Tests
, hacktoberfest-accepted
๐ฐ In the meadow, changes bloom,
Code refined, dispelling gloom.
Tests now dance with Hypothesis flair,
Type safety's here, a breath of fresh air!
With each line, our code grows bright,
Hopping forward, coding's delight! ๐ผ
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media?
Update and Refactoring of Key Files
The key files .pre-commit-config.yaml
, fastkml/atom.py
and fastkml/geometry.py
among others have been updated with a number of changes. Major ones include simplification of code for better readability, and modification in attribute types for better practical use.
Rename and Improvements for Validator File
The file fastkml/validate.py
was renamed to fastkml/validator.py
, and multiple improvements were made for the validation functions within the file.
New Class Method Addition
One new class method get_ns_id
was introduced in fastkml/times.py
.
Assertions and Test Changes
Several assertions in the tests were changed. Instead of checking for None
, the updated versions now check for empty strings where appropriate. The pyproject.toml
file was updated to include extra parameters for hypothesis
testing.
Addition of New Hypothesis Tests and Updates in Existing Tests
New hypothesis tests were added in tests/hypothesis/atom_test.py
. Hypothesis tests were also updated in other test files such as strategies.py
, gx_test.py
and registry_test.py
. Meanwhile, improvements were also made on the common test utilities in tests/hypothesis/common.py
.
New Test File and Improved Test Coverage
New test files were added, such as gx_test.py
and validator_test.py
, to cover various validation scenarios. Meanwhile, existing test files like links_test.py
were updated to include fuzz tests for improved test coverage and to better prepare for test scenarios.
Import Statement and Assertion Fixes
Import statements in a number of test files were updated, and there was a minor fix in times_test.py
to correct an assertion on datetime parsing. Minor import rearrangements for better clarity were also performed in styles_test.py
.
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Type Annotations Several functions have been updated with more specific type annotations, particularly for the 'obj' parameter. Verify that these changes are correct and consistent throughout the file. API Changes The Track and MultiTrack classes have been significantly refactored. Ensure that these changes maintain backwards compatibility and that the new implementation correctly handles all use cases. New Tests New hypothesis-based tests have been added for the gx module. Review these tests to ensure they cover all relevant scenarios and edge cases for the Track and MultiTrack classes. |
Preparing review...
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible issue |
โ Add error handling for coordinate conversion to improve robustness___Suggestion Impact:The commit added error handling for ValueError exceptions when converting coordinate strings to floats in the coords_subelement_list function, similar to the suggestion. However, the error handling uses a different function (handle_error) and parameters than the suggestion. code diff: ```diff + try: + coords = cast( + PointType, + tuple(float(coord) for coord in subelement.text.split()), + ) + args_list.append(coords) + except ValueError as exc: + handle_error( + error=exc, + strict=strict, + element=element, + node=subelement, + expected="DateTime", + ) ```coords_subelement_list function, consider adding error handling for potential ValueError when converting coordinate strings to floats.**
[fastkml/helpers.py [1069-1072]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-b5b3941187e8c15a6401d21669f3dd0d541c710ecbb6238620a56e24305fc02cR1069-R1072)
```diff
-coords = cast(
- PointType,
- tuple(float(coord) for coord in subelement.text.split()),
-)
+try:
+ coords = cast(
+ PointType,
+ tuple(float(coord) for coord in subelement.text.split()),
+ )
+except ValueError as e:
+ logger.warning(f"Invalid coordinate value in {node_name}: {e}")
+ continue
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion correctly identifies a potential issue with converting coordinate strings to floats and provides a robust solution by adding error handling for ValueError. This enhances the function's reliability and prevents runtime errors. | 9 |
Possible bug |
Improve error handling in XML parsing to prevent potential exceptions___ **In thexml_subelement_kwarg function, consider adding a check for subelement being None before returning the dictionary to avoid potential TypeError .**
[fastkml/helpers.py [1110-1115]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-b5b3941187e8c15a6401d21669f3dd0d541c710ecbb6238620a56e24305fc02cR1110-R1115)
```diff
if subelement is not None:
- return {
- kwarg: cls.class_from_element( # type: ignore[attr-defined]
- ns=ns,
- name_spaces=name_spaces,
- element=subelement,
+ try:
+ return {
+ kwarg: cls.class_from_element( # type: ignore[attr-defined]
+ ns=ns,
+ name_spaces=name_spaces,
+ element=subelement,
+ )
+ }
+ except AttributeError:
+ logger.warning(f"Failed to create {cls.__name__} from element")
+return {}
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion adds error handling for potential AttributeError during XML parsing, which can prevent runtime exceptions and improve the robustness of the function. This is a valuable enhancement for error-prone operations. | 8 |
Best practice |
Use more specific assertions for object equality instead of string comparisons___ **Consider using a more specific assertion to verify the equality ofMultiTrack objects. Instead of comparing string representations, compare the objects directly or their relevant attributes.** [tests/gx_test.py [293]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-4ac18980a60351fdb90de277ced50c1429130b451c36d8cb7ef5fa9e9b90203dR293-R293) ```diff -assert track.to_string() == expected_track.to_string() +assert track == expected_track ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion improves the robustness of the test by comparing objects directly, which is more reliable than comparing their string representations. It enhances the accuracy of the test by ensuring that all relevant attributes are considered in the comparison. | 8 |
Use more descriptive variable names in list comprehensions to improve code readability___ **Consider using a more descriptive variable name instead of 't' in the listcomprehension. This will improve code readability.** [fastkml/gx.py [319]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-e8a849efde73ecb6716b27ad17fa34756392e8fb8731d213e8f0070c2986bf02R319-R319) ```diff -return tuple(t.when for t in self.track_items) +return tuple(track_item.when for track_item in self.track_items) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The suggestion to use a more descriptive variable name improves code readability and maintainability, which is beneficial for understanding the code's purpose and logic. | 6 | |
Use setup methods or context managers for test data initialization___ **Consider using a context manager or a setup/teardown method to handle the creationand cleanup of test data, especially for complex objects like MultiTrack .**
[tests/gx_test.py [299-307]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-4ac18980a60351fdb90de277ced50c1429130b451c36d8cb7ef5fa9e9b90203dR299-R307)
```diff
-def test_multitrack(self) -> None:
- track = MultiTrack(
+def setUp(self):
+ self.track = MultiTrack(
ns="",
tracks=[
Track(
ns="",
track_items=[
TrackItem(
+def test_multitrack(self) -> None:
+ # Use self.track in the test
+
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: While using setup methods can improve code organization and reduce redundancy, the current test setup is not overly complex. The suggestion is valid but offers only a moderate improvement in maintainability. | 5 | |
Enhancement |
Use parameterized tests for different TrackItem configurations in MultiTrack tests___ **Consider using parameterized tests to reduce code duplication and improve testcoverage for different TrackItem configurations within the MultiTrack test.**
[tests/gx_test.py [299-307]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-4ac18980a60351fdb90de277ced50c1429130b451c36d8cb7ef5fa9e9b90203dR299-R307)
```diff
-def test_multitrack(self) -> None:
+@pytest.mark.parametrize("track_items", [
+ [TrackItem(when=KmlDateTime(...), coord=geo.Point(0, 0), angle=None)],
+ [TrackItem(when=KmlDateTime(...), coord=geo.Point(1, 1), angle=None)],
+ # Add more variations here
+])
+def test_multitrack(self, track_items) -> None:
track = MultiTrack(
ns="",
- tracks=[
- Track(
- ns="",
- track_items=[
- TrackItem(
+ tracks=[Track(ns="", track_items=track_items)]
+ )
+ # Test assertions here
```
- [ ] **Apply this suggestion**
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Parameterized tests can significantly enhance test coverage and reduce code duplication. This suggestion is beneficial for testing multiple configurations efficiently, though the current test case might not be complex enough to necessitate this change. | 7 |
Improve type hinting by using more specific return type annotations___ **Consider using a more explicit type annotation for the return value of the 'angles'property to improve type hinting.** [fastkml/gx.py [339-349]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-e8a849efde73ecb6716b27ad17fa34756392e8fb8731d213e8f0070c2986bf02R339-R349) ```diff -def angles(self) -> Tuple[PointType, ...]: +def angles(self) -> Tuple[Tuple[float, float, float], ...]: """ Get the angles of the track items. Returns ------- - Iterator[Angle] - The angles of the track items. + Tuple[Tuple[float, float, float], ...] + The angles of the track items as tuples of (heading, tilt, roll). """ return tuple(item.angle.coords for item in self.track_items if item.angle) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Using a more explicit type annotation for the return value enhances type hinting, which can improve code clarity and assist developers in understanding the expected data structure. | 7 | |
Add a check for empty lists before performing list comprehensions to avoid potential issues___ **Consider adding a check for empty track_items before performing the listcomprehension to avoid potential issues with empty lists.** [fastkml/gx.py [333-337]](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/pull/375/files#diff-e8a849efde73ecb6716b27ad17fa34756392e8fb8731d213e8f0070c2986bf02R333-R337) ```diff +if not self.track_items: + return tuple() return tuple( item.coord.coords[0] # type: ignore[misc] for item in self.track_items if item.coord ) ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: Adding a check for empty lists before performing list comprehensions can prevent unnecessary operations and potential errors, enhancing the code's robustness. | 5 |
๐ก Need additional feedback ? start a PR chat
Failed to generate code suggestions for PR
Preparing review...
Preparing review...
Preparing review...
**Action:** cpython-lxml (3.10) |
**Failed stage:** [Test with pytest](https://github.com/cleder/fastkml/actions/runs/11651608370/job/32441781983) [โ] |
**Failed test name:** test_fuzz_multi_track |
**Failure summary:**
The action failed because the test test_fuzz_multi_track in the file tests/hypothesis/gx_test.py encountered a FileNotFoundError .Asia/Hanoi could not be found or opened. |
Relevant error logs:```yaml 1: ##[group]Operating System 2: Ubuntu ... 274: tests/overlays_test.py ............................... [ 79%] 275: tests/registry_test.py .... [ 79%] 276: tests/repr_eq_test.py ...... [ 80%] 277: tests/styles_test.py .......................................... [ 87%] 278: tests/times_test.py .............................................. [ 95%] 279: tests/utils_test.py ...... [ 96%] 280: tests/validator_test.py ...... [ 97%] 281: tests/views_test.py .............. [100%] 282: =================================== FAILURES =================================== ... 317: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 318: self = tzfile('Asia/Hanoi'), fileobj = 'Asia/Hanoi', filename = None 319: def __init__(self, fileobj, filename=None): 320: super(tzfile, self).__init__() 321: file_opened_here = False 322: if isinstance(fileobj, string_types): 323: self._filename = fileobj 324: > fileobj = open(fileobj, 'rb') 325: E FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: 'Asia/Hanoi' 326: E Falsifying example: test_fuzz_multi_track( 327: E # The test always failed when commented parts were varied together. ... 345: E dt=datetime.datetime(2000, 1, 1, 0, 0, tzinfo=tzfile('Asia/Hanoi')), 346: E ), 347: E coord=Point(0.0, 0.0), 348: E angle=Angle(heading=0.0, tilt=0.0, roll=0.0))], 349: E )], 350: E interpolate=None, # or any other generated value 351: E ) 352: E 353: E You can reproduce this example by temporarily adding @reproduce_failure('6.116.0', b'AXicY2BgYGQEISIAZYoYl6FwAQvhAK4=') as a decorator on your test case 354: /opt/hostedtoolcache/Python/3.10.15/x64/lib/python3.10/site-packages/dateutil/tz/tz.py:464: FileNotFoundError 355: ---------- coverage: platform linux, python 3.10.15-final-0 ---------- 356: Coverage XML written to file coverage.xml 357: Required test coverage of 95% reached. Total coverage: 98.58% 358: =========================== short test summary info ============================ 359: FAILED tests/hypothesis/gx_test.py::TestGx::test_fuzz_multi_track - FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: 'Asia/Hanoi' 360: Falsifying example: test_fuzz_multi_track( 361: # The test always failed when commented parts were varied together. ... 378: TrackItem(when=KmlDateTime( 379: dt=datetime.datetime(2000, 1, 1, 0, 0, tzinfo=tzfile('Asia/Hanoi')), 380: ), 381: coord=Point(0.0, 0.0), 382: angle=Angle(heading=0.0, tilt=0.0, roll=0.0))], 383: )], 384: interpolate=None, # or any other generated value 385: ) 386: You can reproduce this example by temporarily adding @reproduce_failure('6.116.0', b'AXicY2BgYGQEISIAZYoYl6FwAQvhAK4=') as a decorator on your test case 387: ================== 1 failed, 593 passed in 109.04s (0:01:49) =================== 388: ##[error]Process completed with exit code 1. ``` |
Preparing review...
User description
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
Track
andMultiTrack
classes to improve track management.Changes walkthrough ๐
9 files
atom.py
Refactor Atom module to improve attribute handling
fastkml/atom.py
Link
and_Person
classes.
NS
from__all__
.base.py
Simplify equality check in base module
fastkml/base.py - Simplified equality check in `__eq__` method.
geometry.py
Update geometry handling and type annotations
fastkml/geometry.py
known_types
withType[object]
in function signatures.gx.py
Refactor GX module for improved track management
fastkml/gx.py
Track
andMultiTrack
classes to improve track management.MultiTrack
initialization.whens
,coords
, andangles
.helpers.py
Enhance helper functions for XML processing
fastkml/helpers.py
subelements.
links.py
Refactor Links module to improve attribute handling
fastkml/links.py
Link
class.registry.py
Simplify type handling in registry module
fastkml/registry.py
known_types
union type.times.py
Add namespace ID retrieval to KmlDateTime
fastkml/times.py - Added `get_ns_id` method to `KmlDateTime` class.
validator.py
Refactor validator module for improved error handling
fastkml/validator.py
6 files
atom_test.py
Update Atom tests for refactored attribute handling
tests/atom_test.py
Link
and_Person
attributehandling.
gx_test.py
Update GX tests for refactored track management
tests/gx_test.py
Track
andMultiTrack
classes.atom_test.py
Add hypothesis tests for Atom module
tests/hypothesis/atom_test.py - Added hypothesis-based tests for `Link` and `Author` classes.
common.py
Add common utilities for hypothesis tests
tests/hypothesis/common.py - Added utility functions for hypothesis tests.
gx_test.py
Add hypothesis tests for GX module
tests/hypothesis/gx_test.py - Added hypothesis-based tests for `Track` and `MultiTrack` classes.
strategies.py
Add custom strategies for hypothesis tests
tests/hypothesis/strategies.py - Added custom hypothesis strategies for testing.
Summary by CodeRabbit
Release Notes
New Features
Track
,MultiTrack
,Link
, andAuthor
classes to improve test coverage.get_ns_id
added to theKmlDateTime
class for standardized namespace ID access.Bug Fixes
validate
function to provide clearer messages.Documentation
Refactor
Tests