search

clementine-player / Clementine

:tangerine: Clementine Music Player
https://www.clementine-player.org/
GNU General Public License v3.0
3.77k stars 677 forks source link

Audio-CD error: Could not read from CD. #2442

Open Clementine-Issue-Importer opened 10 years ago

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From felix.na...@googlemail.com on November 30, 2011 10:10:52

Insert an Audio-CD (which could be played by AIMP, WinMC), go to devices, doule click the CD.

Clementine should start playing the CD, but its loops trough all tracks (which are correctly named) and shows error "Could not read from CD." for each track.

Im using v0.7.3-468-g32d7096 on Win7.

Original issue: http://code.google.com/p/clementine-player/issues/detail?id=2442

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From arnaud.bienner on December 03, 2011 02:43:05

Just out of curiosity, have you try with VLC? Does it work?

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From felix.na...@googlemail.com on December 15, 2011 05:55:03

Works in VLC without problems. Tested with different CDs.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From arnaud.bienner on December 15, 2011 06:01:49

From the mailing list:

"Ok so I have tried the debug version 0.7.3-532-g8bfedeb and here is what I got trying to load Audio CD:

13:12:39.897 INFO SongLoaderInserter:97 Loading audio CD... 13:12:39.901 ERROR SongLoader:121 Error while changing CDDA GstElement's state

and the message about not being able to load audio cd...

I can see the cd in Device tab, but I can only eject the cd by using 'Safely remove device' and open Device Properties

When I try doubleclick on the device icon I get:

13:22:55.481 INFO DeviceManager:555 Connecting QUrl( "cdda:" ) 13:22:55.481 INFO ConnectedDevice:43 connected QUrl( "cdda:" )".\E:" false 13:22:55.509 WARN Transcoder:256 Unsupported format in PresetForFileType: 0 13:22:55.509 WARN Transcoder:256 Unsupported format in PresetForFileType: 0

I also tried to play the cd in VLC and it works without any problem...

Zdar !!! Atrament"

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From snakefin...@gmail.com on January 08, 2012 08:59:11

Also seeing this issue on two machines with Win 7, however I have two machines with OpenSuSE 12.1 that are playing CDs without issue. All are using Clementine version 1.0.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From felix.na...@googlemail.com on January 11, 2012 01:11:40

Ive tested v1.0.0 with Win7 and it seems not to work yet.

This issue is a duplicate of #701

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From arnaud.bienner on January 11, 2012 02:37:44

No, it's not really a duplicate of issue 701 . Issue 701 was about implementing CD support. If there is some bugs that prevent it to work in some case, it's better to track this in another issue.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From john.maguire on January 11, 2012 09:22:12

Issue 2577 has been merged into this issue.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From hariskar on January 29, 2012 05:51:53

Ive tested v1.0.1 with Win7 and it seems not to work yet. I get "Error while loading audio CD". At Devices I see my player but it says 0 songs. Foobar plays it normally. Any solution?

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From hariskar on January 31, 2012 07:08:58

Is there any workaround for this?

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From john.maguire on February 03, 2012 05:00:58

Issue 2692 has been merged into this issue.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From weltQ...@gmail.com on February 21, 2012 12:36:49

I can confirm the problem on today's developer build. Settings: Ubuntu 11.04 (derivative) GNOME 2.32, Compiz, "Error while loading audio CD"

Here's the console output: me@home:~$ clementine 21:25:51.656 DEBUG NetworkProxyFactory:30 Detected system proxy URLs: ("", "", "", "") 21:25:51.656 DEBUG CoverProviders:34 Registered cover provider "Amazon" 21:25:51.656 DEBUG CoverProviders:34 Registered cover provider "Discogs" 21:25:51.657 DEBUG WorkerPool:277 Starting worker 0x7fe7bd74d3a0 "/usr/bin/clementine-tagreader" "/tmp/clementine_505728209" 21:25:51.658 DEBUG WorkerPool:277 Starting worker 0x7fe7bd74d3a0 "/usr/bin/clementine-tagreader" "/tmp/clementine_1157110443" 21:25:51.666 INFO main:46 TagReader worker connecting to "/tmp/clementine_505728209" 21:25:51.666 DEBUG WorkerPool:297 Worker 0x24deb70 connected to "/tmp/clementine_505728209" 21:25:51.666 INFO main:46 TagReader worker connecting to "/tmp/clementine_1157110443" 21:25:51.667 DEBUG WorkerPool:297 Worker 0x24de520 connected to "/tmp/clementine_1157110443" 21:25:51.693 INFO Player:534 Registered URL handler for "di" 21:25:51.693 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "DigitallyImported" 21:25:51.750 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "Icecast" 21:25:51.773 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "Jamendo" 21:25:51.827 INFO Player:534 Registered URL handler for "lastfm" 21:25:51.828 DEBUG CoverProviders:34 Registered cover provider "last.fm" 21:25:51.828 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "Last.fm" 21:25:51.828 INFO Player:534 Registered URL handler for "grooveshark" 21:25:51.828 INFO PlaylistManager:417 Registered special playlist type "grooveshark-search" 21:25:51.829 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "Grooveshark" 21:25:51.834 INFO Player:534 Registered URL handler for "magnatune" 21:25:51.834 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "Magnatune" 21:25:51.845 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "SavedRadio" 21:25:51.846 INFO Player:534 Registered URL handler for "sky" 21:25:51.846 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "SKY.fm" 21:25:51.846 INFO Player:534 Registered URL handler for "somafm" 21:25:51.847 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "SomaFM" 21:25:51.847 DEBUG SpotifyService:70 Spotify system blob path: "/usr/bin/clementine-spotifyblob" 21:25:51.847 DEBUG SpotifyService:71 Spotify local blob path: "/home/pingjamin2/.config/Clementine/spotifyblob/version11-64bit/blob" 21:25:51.847 INFO PlaylistManager:417 Registered special playlist type "spotify-search" 21:25:51.847 DEBUG InternetModel:94 Adding internet service: "Spotify" 21:25:51.857 WARN IconLoader:54 Couldn't load icon "clementine-panel" 21:25:51.867 WARN IconLoader:54 Couldn't load icon "clementine-panel-grey" 21:25:51.894 DEBUG GnomeGlobalShortcutBackend:50 registering 21:25:51.950 DEBUG MainWindow:207 Starting 21:25:52.032 WARN unknown Application asked to unregister timer 0x5300000c which is not registered in this thread. Fix application. 21:25:52.096 DEBUG MainWindow:269 Initialising player 21:25:52.099 DEBUG MainWindow:275 Creating models 21:25:52.160 DEBUG MainWindow:299 Creating UI 21:25:52.202 DEBUG MainWindow:659 Creating equalizer 21:25:52.202 DEBUG MainWindow:674 Creating now playing widget 21:25:52.325 DEBUG MainWindow:716 Loading settings 21:25:52.404 DEBUG MainWindow:762 Initialising library 21:25:52.407 DEBUG MainWindow:775 Started 21:25:52.419 INFO DeviceManager:413 Device added: "Gio/unmounted/38358416" 21:25:53.177 DEBUG GnomeGlobalShortcutBackend:93 registered 21:25:53.274 INFO DeviceManager:462 Device removed: "Gio/unmounted/38358416" 21:25:53.274 INFO DeviceManager:413 Device added: "Gio//cdda/462764032" 21:26:04.889 INFO SongLoaderInserter:97 Loading audio CD... opera: Activated running instance 21:27:15.759 INFO DeviceManager:462 Device removed: "Gio//cdda/462764032"

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From tomprend...@googlemail.com on May 12, 2012 15:22:17

I have Kubuntu 12.04 and Mint KDE 12 and I am finding that whilst Kubuntu plays CDs, Mint doesn't getting the error message "Could not read from CD." I have the same version of Clementine on both distros. One other thing, it would be nice if the tracks were named rather than just getting track numbers.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From alain.an...@gmail.com on May 13, 2012 03:19:37

I got the very same issue for a while now, and problem disappeared since I upgraded to Kubuntu Precise Pangolin: for the first time, I am able to play CD with Clementine without getting the "Could not read from CD"error message. Thanks.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From hariskar on May 13, 2012 03:59:07

Any solution for windows? It is a major bug..

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From tomprend...@googlemail.com on June 07, 2012 12:13:26

Can anybody tell me why Kubuntu 12.04 works whilst Linux Mint 12 KDE doesn't?

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From tomprend...@googlemail.com on June 29, 2012 15:34:18

I have just installed Zorin OS 6 and used Rhythmbox, it is truly excellent. CDs play without any problems and the track info comes up as well. I suggest that someone need to look at what they are doing right!

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From hariskar on October 05, 2012 07:16:25

Any info about this? Is there any plan for CD playback??? Some of us have a lot of CDs...

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From unconfu...@gmail.com on January 29, 2013 07:56:21

I've just downloaded and installed v1.1.1 on Windows 7 and this CD playback error still exists. Error is "Could not read from CD." But I can play CD audio in VLC or Windows Media Player.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From davidsansome on April 15, 2013 17:04:02

Issue 3621 has been merged into this issue.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From TJW...@gmail.com on August 23, 2013 19:59:35

Windows 7 Home Premium (+SP1), 64-bit 4GB RAM, AMD Turion II P520 2.3 GHz

Latest version from website as of posting (1.1 I think) still has this issue.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From arnaud.bienner on September 26, 2013 11:06:30

Issue 3868 has been merged into this issue.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From vascofal...@gmail.com on September 29, 2013 07:36:19

I don't think my Issue 3868 is a duplicate. Here, people are reporting the CD tracks were listed even though they could not be played, while I don't even get to see anything about them. Sorry if I missed someone else saying this there too.

Clementine-Issue-Importer commented 10 years ago

From Atrament...@googlemail.com on October 15, 2013 12:36:01

It's been almost two years now, any progress on this one? Version 1.2 out and Audio CD playback still doesn't work (Tried it in Windows 8 Pro and Mint KDE 15 both 64bit version)

AeSix commented 9 years ago

Clementine 1.2.3 (32bit) Win7 x64 Pro, same issue. I think I'm done with Clementine. I found and used it for it's good Android remote control support - but I no longer have a need for that, and honestly VLC has good android remotes now as well. It was an OK run while it lasted Clementine, but your developers don't want to take care of you and I can't keep nursing a sick puppy.

ArnaudBienner commented 9 years ago

Can someone who this issue try with one of the developer build? http://builds.clementine-player.org/ We migrate to Gstreamer1.0 so hopefully this fixed this issue.

SeenCanary commented 9 years ago

I've just installed http://builds.clementine-player.org/win32/release/ClementineSetup-1.2.3-1030-g946c038.exe (dated yesterday evening) and, while I no longer receive the "Could not read from CD" error message, there are no tracks listed so no ability to playback.

Win 8.1 Pro x64.

AeSix commented 9 years ago

I updated to the release linked, from Feb 28. Win32 build on Win7 x64. It don't work. I don't know if Windows is intercepting it or if VLC is or what, but it's a damned shame I can have VLC open and still open the CD via Windows Media Player, but not Clementine. I can open the CD in a number of other programs too. So I don't think it's anything else I have installed, especially considering this is a different OS and computer than I used when I originally reported the issue.

On Sun, Mar 1, 2015 at 1:41 PM, SeenCanary notifications@github.com wrote:

I've just installed http://builds.clementine-player.org/win32/release/ClementineSetup-1.2.3-1030-g946c038.exe (dated yesterday evening) and, while I no longer receive the "Could not read from CD" error message, there are no tracks listed so no ability to playback.

Win 8.1 Pro x64.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/clementine-player/Clementine/issues/2442#issuecomment-76623237 .

mtngchi commented 9 years ago

Also happens with me. Windows 8.1 x64, Clementine 1.2.3-1144.

togakangaroo commented 9 years ago

I'm getting this with Windows 8.1 x64, Clementine 1.2.3. Can't open the CD at all. This is with an external CD player, but other apps can read it just fine.

Has anyone tracked down the issue more specifically?

SeenCanary commented 9 years ago

I did see the same thing happen on a Linux box with an old version of Gstreamer (pre 1.0 with a known defect). In that case updating Gstreamer to a version with a fix, fixed the issue. At the time the win32 Clementine version was also using an pre1.0 Gstreamer version but it was updated back in Feb and the issue still remained.

I've just tried updating to a development build dated today (2015-09-28 - gdaddbde) and the behaviour is as I reported in March (no error but a listing of 0 tracks).

mtngchi commented 9 years ago

build -1396 and still doesn't work.... same thing @SeenCanary described

crumdev commented 8 years ago

I am running Windows 10 Enterprise 64bit with Clementine v1.3.1 and can see my disc reading device but 0 tracks. I can eject the disc and view device properties but cannot rip or play my CD's. If it cannot be implemented it's almost best to just say it's a player and remove. It's still a great player and it's probably better and not all that inconvenient to just use EAC for personal cd Archiving.

mxa commented 7 years ago

Having this issue with Version 1.3.1-228-gd9b3a93 on Linux Mint 18.1 64bit Cinnamon

SeenCanary commented 7 years ago

@mxa Can you please check your version of Gstreamer? As myself and (I think) others have mentioned, there was a known bug in older Gstreamer versions that lead to this behaviour and Clementine doesn't seem to have a minimum version requirement that precludes these versions.

On Linux Gstreamer is a pre-requisite that is up to the system admin to update but on Windows Clementine includes a copy of Gstreamer. I've just uninstalled, cleaned out the %%System Drive%%/Program Files (x86)/Clementine/ folder and installed the most recent dev build (2017-04-03 - g2c60481) and still get no error but a listing of 0 tracks on a CD.

However, I checked and Gstreamer are now doing Windows binaries which they weren't at the beginning of this ticket. I tried installing the current version (1.11.2 - I note the .dll in the Clementine folder is numbered 1.0-0) but it seems that Clementine is still using the .dlls bundled with itself, as I still get the same behaviour. I don't have any other software that uses Gstreamer so I can't directly check whether even the current version is able to read the CD correctly outside of Clementine.

Windows 10 Pro x64 - not using an Insider build.

mxa commented 7 years ago

@SeenCanary libgstreamer is in version gstreamer1.0 (1.8.3-1~ubuntu0.1) here

jaclas commented 5 years ago

Clementine still not read CD-audio

AeSix commented 5 years ago

I haven't thought about Clementine in almost 2 years. Glad to see my time hasn't been wasted with this. Damned shame the devs can't figure out how to write (or import VLC's) disc reader.