SGF invalid for fechgo league - unknown reasons

[alexmitrani]

I checked and both players are registered, they tagged the game, komi and time settings are compliant. I don't know why the system says it is invalid and no explanation is given. Please help. Thanks!

This is the SGF:

http://files.gokgs.com/games/2019/4/28/Fiona-clachalote.sgf

[alexmitrani]

I tried stripping things out to see if there was something in the contents that was causing a problem. This was also considered invalid:

(;GM[1]FF[4]CA[UTF-8]AP[CGoban:3]ST[2]
RU[Japanese]SZ[19]KM[6.50]TM[1800]OT[5x30 byo-yomi]
PW[Fiona]PB[clachalote]WR[7k]BR[8k]DT[2019-04-28]PC[The KGS Go Server at http://www.gokgs.com/]
RE[W+21.50]
;B[qd]BL[1779.066]
;W[od]WL[1770.578]
;B[pf]BL[1772.265]
;W[qc]WL[1759.696]
;B[rc]BL[1762.26]
;W[pc]WL[1754.056]
;B[pp]BL[1750.265]
;W[dp]WL[1688.015]
;B[dd]BL[1736.648]
;W[fc]WL[1682.308]
;B[cf]BL[1729.561]
;W[nq]WL[1667.449]
;B[oq]BL[1720.529]
;W[np]WL[1662.237]
;B[qn]BL[1718.916]
;W[jq]WL[1655.089]
;B[cn]BL[1715.454]
;W[co]WL[1647.015]
;B[dn]BL[1713.919]
;W[fp]WL[1641.974]
;B[cj]BL[1711.758]
;W[db]WL[1629.17]
;B[cc]BL[1705.466]
;W[ic]WL[1621.502]
;B[qj]BL[1678.508]
;W[nf]WL[1592.319]
;B[pd]BL[1654.466]
;W[nc]WL[1583.583]
;B[jn]BL[1640.684]
;W[hp]WL[1510.477]
;B[fn]BL[1632.099]
;W[ej]WL[1496.761]
;B[fe]BL[1629.285]
;W[ie]WL[1454.382]
;B[ei]BL[1623.525]
;W[dj]WL[1420.3]
;B[di]BL[1620.318]
;W[fj]WL[1364.811]
;B[fi]BL[1607.672]
;W[gj]WL[1335.743]
;B[dk]BL[1592.914]
;W[gi]WL[1317.826]
;B[gh]BL[1590.041]
;W[hh]WL[1276.165]
;B[hg]BL[1573.21]
;W[ci]WL[1187.4]
;B[ck]BL[1568.281]
;W[fh]WL[1180.354]
;B[fg]BL[1548.9]
;W[eh]WL[1160.384]
;B[dh]BL[1542.594]
;W[eg]WL[1098.766]
;B[gg]BL[1513.084]
;W[ih]WL[787.677]
;B[ig]BL[1498.885]
;W[jh]WL[778.314]
;B[jg]BL[1493.593]
;W[kh]WL[776.113]
;B[kg]BL[1490.242]
;W[hn]WL[762.063]
;B[nn]BL[1484.426]
;W[ln]WL[753.713]
;B[go]BL[1482.178]
;W[ho]WL[751.955]
;B[gp]BL[1480.242]
;W[gq]WL[749.965]
;B[mo]BL[1473.739]
;W[lp]WL[744.312]
;B[lo]BL[1470.488]
;W[ko]WL[741.723]
;B[kn]BL[1467.789]
;W[lm]WL[736.422]
;B[kp]BL[1465.537]
;W[jo]WL[733.441]
;B[mp]BL[1463.402]
;W[lq]WL[724.767]
;B[mq]BL[1462.088]
;W[kq]WL[723.043]
;B[mr]BL[1460.248]
;W[lj]WL[673.255]
;B[hd]BL[1452.385]
;W[hc]WL[660.805]
;B[id]BL[1450.502]
;W[jd]WL[658.723]
;B[je]BL[1448.875]
;W[kd]WL[654.769]
;B[ke]BL[1447.129]
;W[ld]WL[652.654]
;B[le]BL[1443.923]
;W[qh]WL[592.155]
;B[ph]BL[1439.375]
;W[qi]WL[581.649]
;B[pi]BL[1436.723]
;W[rj]WL[539.417]
;B[qk]BL[1433.572]
;W[rk]WL[531.229]
;B[ql]BL[1426.297]
;W[qg]WL[528.732]
;B[pg]BL[1421.535]
;W[re]WL[522.296]
;B[qf]BL[1419.409]
;W[rf]WL[517.855]
;B[rd]BL[1414.49]
;W[bo]WL[467.349]
;B[bn]BL[1411.095]
;W[an]WL[464.934]
;B[am]BL[1400.303]
;W[ao]WL[463.267]
;B[bl]BL[1399.008]
;W[fm]WL[460.266]
;B[gm]BL[1395.606]
;W[gn]WL[316.484]
;B[fo]BL[1392.285]
;W[ep]WL[306.068]
;B[em]BL[1344.137]
;W[fl]WL[291.047]
;B[cb]BL[1304.326]
;W[lr]WL[283.308]
;B[eb]BL[1301.065]
;W[ms]WL[280.581]
;B[ns]BL[1298.635]
;W[ls]WL[274.955]
;B[nr]BL[1297.168]
;W[ec]WL[255.204]
;B[dc]BL[1294.382]
;W[fb]WL[254.136]
;B[ij]BL[1261.167]
;W[hi]WL[208.841]
;B[sh]BL[1258.607]
;W[rh]WL[103.206]
;B[rl]BL[1254.28]
;W[si]WL[91.501]
;B[sk]BL[1250.281]
;W[sg]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[lh]BL[1236.359]
;W[li]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[mh]BL[1234.647]
;W[gd]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[he]BL[1231.07]
;W[ge]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[hf]BL[1220.174]
;W[dg]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[ch]BL[1209.248]
;W[cg]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[bh]BL[1201.698]
;W[bg]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[bi]BL[1199.666]
;W[ee]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[ff]BL[1154.292]
;W[ed]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[ef]BL[1150.62]
;W[de]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[df]BL[1148.091]
;W[ce]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[be]BL[1142.997]
;W[bd]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[bf]BL[1137.012]
;W[cd]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[bc]BL[1135.698]
;W[ad]WL[30]OW[5]
;B[da]BL[1126.936]
;W[nl]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[mm]BL[1122.779]
;W[ml]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[ll]BL[1120.442]
;W[km]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[kl]BL[1114.448]
;W[jm]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[jl]BL[1099.179]
;W[lk]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[mn]BL[1094.658]
;W[in]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[mk]BL[1089.342]
;W[nj]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[mi]BL[1087.651]
;W[mj]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[ok]BL[1085.972]
;W[nk]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[el]BL[1081.277]
;W[fk]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[qb]BL[1066.952]
;W[pb]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[rb]BL[1063.862]
;W[om]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[on]BL[1061.22]
;W[pm]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[ne]BL[1055.218]
;W[oe]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[md]BL[1053.739]
;W[mc]WL[30]OW[4]
;B[of]BL[1050.497]
;W[qm]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[rm]BL[1045.89]
;W[pn]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[po]BL[1034.688]
;W[ni]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[nh]BL[1031.799]
;W[oj]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[pj]BL[1026.692]
;W[ae]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[af]BL[1019.498]
;W[fa]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[ea]BL[1016.886]
;W[ba]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[bb]BL[993.141]
;W[ac]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[ab]BL[986.465]
;W[nd]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[me]BL[982.227]
;W[do]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[en]BL[979.26]
;W[qa]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[ra]BL[974.9]
;W[pa]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[ol]BL[969.185]
;W[nm]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[pl]BL[967.11]
;W[jj]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[oi]BL[963.512]
;W[sj]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[sl]BL[958.07]
;W[sd]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[sc]BL[956.359]
;W[se]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[fd]BL[953.443]
;W[jc]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[gf]BL[948.158]
;W[gc]WL[30]OW[3]
;B[]BL[948.158]
;W[]WL[30]OW[3])

[alexmitrani]

I was expecting it to say that it was invalid because the tag was missing but it didn't. It just continued to say that it was invalid without any explanation.

[alexmitrani]

It's been scraped now. I don't know what happened there.

[alexmitrani]

Maybe when I tried uploading it manually it was already in the queue to be scraped. If that is the case the manual upload might have been treated as invalid to avoid the game being counted twice. If this is so, it would be great if there could be a message to the user explaining the situation. Thanks.

[climu]

It seems there is an issue here and I will try to work on this before next week.

In theory when a sgf is in queue to be scraped, you can upload the same one without worry. The one in the queue will then be scraped with the output "same sgf already in db".

There shouldn't be an invalid sgf without any error message. As I said I ll work on that.

[climu]

Bad news. I won't be able to work on that for now.

Since the automatic scraper seems to work I guess it's not that urgent.

We should check all that and maybe work on #369 in the same time.

[alexmitrani]

I had a similar experience just now, it was saying a kifu was invalid without any explanation. I found a possible cause and a workaround. In Django-Admin the SGF was on the list and marked as invalid. I deleted that record. Then I went back to the admin SGF interface and scrobbled the kifu anew, this time it worked. So my tentative conclusion is that the case where someone tries to scrobble a pre-existing SGF needs to be dealt with better, maybe with an error message and / or an option to replace the pre-existing SGF.
Thanks.

[climu]

There should be a message for that telling you the id of the similar sgf.

Its a bug.

You can look for sgf and manage/delete it in admin tool;)

Le ven. 14 juin 2019 06:21, alexmitrani notifications@github.com a écrit :

I had a similar experience just now, it was saying a kifu was invalid without any explanation. I found a possible cause and a workaround. In Django-Admin the SGF was on the list and marked as invalid. I deleted that record. Then I went back to the admin SGF interface and scrobbled the kifu anew, this time it worked. So my tentative conclusion is that the case where someone tries to scrobble a pre-existing SGF needs to be dealt with better, maybe with an error message and / or an option to replace the pre-existing SGF. Thanks.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/climu/openstudyroom/issues/374?email_source=notifications&email_token=AAUGUTL5Y2X44DWO52MUAUDP2MTD3A5CNFSM4HI6ZZXKYY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGODXVXW7I#issuecomment-501971837, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAUGUTPFTUHQRR4YPQHH6QDP2MTD3ANCNFSM4HI6ZZXA .

[climu]

Since eb92e7e we have better way of handling sgf errors:

So I close this issue for now.