clingen-data-model / allele

Documentation for data model of ClinGen
10 stars 2 forks source link

intronOffsetGenomicCoordinate #108

Closed ronakypatel closed 9 years ago

ronakypatel commented 9 years ago

To create simple allele for intronic region, one needs to define intronOffsetGenomicCoordinate, which looks good. Just to make sure this genomic coordinate (reference+coordinate+allele) will be used to create different simple allele, right?

The intronic allele defined with respect to transcript which has genomic coordinates and a different simple allele defined with respect to genomic reference will be part of the same canonical allele. This looks little redundant but want to make sure my understanding is right.

larrybabb commented 9 years ago

In the examples, we do have a several Simple alleles tied to the canonical allele which includes the intronic simple allele representation. The simple alleles in this group include...

To be clear, there is no requirement that the intronOffsetGenomicCoordinate data (start, end, referenceSeq) be explicitly used in a separate SimpleAllele, however, it does make sense that it would occur most of the time, since the genomic reference is itself a standalone simple allele too.

I suppose if someone was to define an intron simple allele and base the intronOffsetGenomicCoordinate on a genomic reference sequence that was not also used explicitly in a genomic simple allele it would not be wrong. It would be more likely observed to be missing as another obvious form of the canonical allele's set of simple alleles.

I hope that is helpful.

larrybabb commented 9 years ago

Ronak, please confirm whether or not you have a satisfactory answer. If so, please close this otherwise let's discuss at the next meeting.