clojars / clojars-web

A community repository for open-source Clojure libraries
https://clojars.org
Eclipse Public License 1.0
471 stars 114 forks source link

Delete request #594

Closed devth closed 7 years ago

devth commented 7 years ago

Hi, I decided to not 1.0 my project yet. Please delete all versions starting with "1.0.0" on the following two projects:

https://clojars.org/yetibot.core

https://clojars.org/yetibot

danielcompton commented 7 years ago

I'm a little bit cautious about deleting these JARs. They've all been out for a while and have had some number of downloads. This probably doesn't fit into our deletions policy, but will let Toby weigh in too.

devth commented 7 years ago

Pretty sure all the downloads are from me and my nightly tests on Travis. The changes for these jars have not been merged to master. Thanks.

devth commented 7 years ago

Any word on a decision here? Thanks.

tobias commented 7 years ago

I'm inclined to deny these deletions, for two reasons:

1) yetibot/yetibot-core are mature enough to have users, and there's no guarantee a user hasn't noticed these releases and upgraded to one 2) If we delete 1.0.0, and you then release a 1.0.0 in the future, then the value pointed to by 1.0.0 changes, which may lead to unexpected results for anyone that mirrors/caches clojars

Version numbers are free and infinite, so I recommend leaving 1.0.0 here and using a higher number for your next stable release. Feel free to blame me directly in the release notes :)

devth commented 7 years ago

Fair enough. I guess 1.0.1 will have to be Yetibot's "1.0". And I blame lein release† for incorrectly bumping from 1.0.0-RC9 to 1.0.0!! 😡

† or maybe I messed it up somehow. 😭