search

cloudflare / circl

CIRCL: Cloudflare Interoperable Reusable Cryptographic Library
http://blog.cloudflare.com/introducing-circl
Other
1.22k stars 136 forks source link

Why were the patch versions for CVE-2023-1732 released so late? #466

Closed Silence-worker-02 closed 7 months ago

Silence-worker-02 commented 7 months ago

We are a research team dedicated to Golang, have discovered that CVE-2023-1732 was addressed in commit f4c0e87526ec17305e8a573f1c58acedc5539a92. However, upon analyzing the commit, we observed that the patch version (v1.3.3) was released after a lapse of over one month. We are interested in understanding the reasons behind this delay in releasing the patch version, as it could potentially impede the prompt dissemination of patches to downstream users. We seek clarification on whether the delay might be attributed to:

  1. Issues with testing and CI checking.
  2. Other commits requiring inclusion in a single release.
  3. By convention, infrequent release of versions.
  4. Other reasons. We appreciate your attention to this matter and eagerly await your response. Thank you.
Lekensteyn commented 7 months ago

Hi, I wrote a more detailed reply regarding this specific issue in https://github.com/cloudflare/circl/pull/417#issuecomment-1812682972

It is not a problem with points 1-3. In summary, a theoretical issue was reported that does not affect realistic systems. So despite the scary CVE score, there was no issue that warranted an urgent release. It was included in the next maintenance release.

armfazh commented 7 months ago

Thanks @Lekensteyn for the expanded explanation. @Silence-worker-02 feel free to reach ask-research@cloudflare.com if there are more questions.