cloudflare / wildebeest

Wildebeest is an ActivityPub and Mastodon-compatible server
Other
2.04k stars 400 forks source link

Support for account migrations (Mastodon to Wildebeest) #238

Closed jonaharagon closed 1 year ago

jonaharagon commented 1 year ago

Mastodon supports redirecting profiles and moving your followers between different Mastodon accounts with its account migrations feature. Is this something Wildebeest might support in the future?

It doesn't feel realistic for many people to move their Mastodon accounts to a personal Wildebeest instance on their own domain, even if Wildebeest allows them to create a personal instance more easily than Mastodon does, because there's no way to bring the following many people already have on Mastodon over here. This is the dealbreaker for me trying out Wildebeest personally anyways. It'd also be nice to support migrating out of Wildebeest in case of a domain change or a need to use ActivityPub software with a different feature-set later on.

ThatOneCalculator commented 1 year ago

Not just Mastodon -- Akkoma, Calckey, and Pleroma have this.

Keisial commented 1 year ago

While not as obvious as the right to get a copy of your own toots, I think that a broad interpretation of GDPR Article 20 does imply that the subjects should be able to move their fediverse activity from one ActivityPub provider to another.

Which should include the relatively simple feature of being able to point your followers to the new place, as implemented by most other competitor servers.

mkarliner commented 1 year ago

+1 Absolutely

xtuc commented 1 year ago

@Keisial I'm no laywer but I'm guessing GDPR Article 20 doesn't apply to Wildebeest. The data is owned by your account, in your D1 database. You are free to delete / download / move it.

That being said, we don't support Mastodon migrations right now but we are planning to.

filipesmedeiros commented 1 year ago

@xtuc amazing to hear. I'd love to migrate into Wildebeest as soon as that's ready 😄

alasaarela commented 1 year ago

That being said, we don't support Mastodon migrations right now but we are planning to.

@xtuc Thanks, I look forward to testing out Wildebeest for our Mastodon server as soon as the migration functionality is in!

Keisial commented 1 year ago

@xtuc don't get me wrong, I was thinking on this as an interesting fact. I agree it's not clear it does (thus the broad interpretation) but my reading of the GDPR is that it would "want" that you should be able to move your followers as well. Ironically, only because the protocol allows that. IANAL, so I might be completely wrong as well.

xtuc commented 1 year ago

Migrating from Mastodon to Wildebeest is now possible.

japzone1 commented 1 year ago

Migrating from Mastodon to Wildebeest is now possible.

What about the other way around? Can people migrate off of Wildebeest?

xtuc commented 1 year ago

@japzone1 only Mastodon to Wildebeest account migration is supported at the moment.

japzone1 commented 1 year ago

@japzone1 only Mastodon to Wildebeest account migration is supported at the moment.

Why'd you rename and close the issue then? The opening post specifically mentions migration away from Wildebeest as well.

xtuc commented 1 year ago

Ah ok, please create a dedicated issue for Wildebeest to Mastodon migration.