[Common] If we fail the compilation; the status in the Leaderboard display as 'Compiled'

sdgun commented 9 years ago

Description

Steps

Open the Web Arena URL: https://arena.topcoder.com/ Login as valid user In the 'Dashboard' When the coding phase starts Click ENTER Go to the code editor Enter code and Don't compile it Click the Leaderboard and check the status of that problem --> Opened Now go to code editor Remove the class name Compile it When the Error message displays Check 'Leaderboard' Check the Status --> Compiled

Expected result

Must fix the Issue

Must not display as Compiled
User may think he compiled that successfully when he saw that
Must remain Opened or compiled with Errors
Actual result

[Common] If we fail the compilation; the status in the Leaderboard display as 'Compiled'

Image

Environment

IE 10,11, Chrome 39.0.2171.65 m, FF 33.1.1 and Safari 5.1.7 in Windows 7 Pro 64bit

Bug Hunt

Web Arena QA for 201411 Release

Goodwine commented 9 years ago

I would disagree, "Compiled" would mean that the contestant "Compiled his/her code", and I don't think that the other contestants should know if the compilation succeeded/failed.
It would mean that the contestant is no longer on the coding phase, and he/she might have a solution already which would put pressure on the others.

mdesiderio commented 9 years ago

This issue was moved to appirio-tech/arena-web#22

cloudspokes / arena-web