search

cmroche / OctoPrint-HomeAssistant

Home Assistant plugin for OctoPrint, enabling MQTT discovery of you device and sensors
110 stars 18 forks source link

Plugin incompatibility with OpenHAB? #75

Closed dido77-arduino closed 2 years ago

dido77-arduino commented 3 years ago

Hi

it looks there is a datatype incompatibility between channels as announced by the Octoprint HA plugin and its OpenHAB counterpart.

I have an Ender3 and I can discover the printer on OpenHAB with the HA plugin. All channels are there. However, after the inclusion it goes in OH online and offline a few times before the system puts it in offline. It seems that the relevant line in OpenHAB log is this

2021-02-16 21:14:45.796 [WARN ] [ab.binding.mqtt.generic.ChannelState] - Command 'false' not supported by type 'OnOffValue': No enum constant org.openhab.core.library.types.OnOffType.false

I posted the whole story on the OH community forum (link), but they could not help to understand who between the Octoprint and OpenHAB plugins is right/wrong.

Happy to help in debugging this if needed, the functionalities offered by this plugin are fantastic!

cmroche commented 2 years ago

Hi @dido77-arduino thanks for the report.

I read through the thread, haphazardly I'm going to suggest the issue is with OpenHAB as HA's documentation allows for the use of true and false by specifying the pl-on and pl-off attributes, which is also why this works fully on HA.

Sure, it's true the Tasmota doesn't use this approach, but I don't think that alone should be a sign that something is wrong on the HA side.

Can you tell me which sensor specifically is causing this though? It's not clear which makes it a bit difficult to investigate further.

cmroche commented 2 years ago

Closing due to inactivity. If you think this is an error and there is something to resolve within the Octoprint HomeAssistant Discovery plugin feel free to re-open with more information. Cheers.