search

cncf / tag-env-sustainability

🌳🌍♻️ TAG Environmental Sustainability
https://tag-env-sustainability.cncf.io/
Apache License 2.0
243 stars 113 forks source link

[BUG] Meeting recordings are not uploaded to YouTube #545

Closed nikimanoledaki closed 1 month ago

nikimanoledaki commented 1 month ago

What happened?

@locomundo and I are working on the slides for the Green Reviews intro for the mini conference. We just noticed that the meeting recordings have not been uploaded to the YouTube channel since June. 🙊 https://www.youtube.com/@CNCFEnvTAG/videos

Code of Conduct

Comments

No response

nikimanoledaki commented 1 month ago

FYI @cncf/tag-env-sustainability

claire-fletcher commented 1 month ago

Do you have admin access? It is likely that they are there but haven't had their thumbnail added and status set to public. One of the comms group action points for our roadmap planning will be a potential rota across the leads (maybe TAG wide so its less burden?) to ensure this gets done.

vallss commented 1 month ago

Should we add the wg-comms label so we can talk about this issue later today?

claire-fletcher commented 1 month ago

Yes lets. It has come up before (during roles review) but became too much for me to monitor on my own. Definitely worth floating the rota idea/some sort of check-in.

claire-fletcher commented 1 month ago

We've discussed this and we are going to take the opportunity to make a document explaining how, some new thumbnails, upload this all to the drive and then have chairs of the meetings be in charge of ensuring each of the meetings they run is correctly uploaded.

claire-fletcher commented 1 month ago

I have created a document: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PmhITy-7zpJxgW2iVGgwuF2ro5vgVyv5fMYqpsblQWc/edit#heading=h.iauc1y6zsy7a

We are also going to improve the thumbnails

leonardpahlke commented 1 month ago

👍, good to talk about this. +1, that the chairs (tag/wg) are responsible for the meeting upload.

riaankleinhans commented 1 month ago

If logging into Zoom and getting hold of the meeting files is a blocker for the TAG, you might consider using LFX / Zoom, where the recording is publicly available after the meeting on the community LFX Calendar.

leonardpahlke commented 1 month ago

maybe there is a way to automate it better. If smb has any ideas.. 💡

There is the option to create multiple zoom meeting rooms (so there is a link for each of the WGs, for the TAG and maybe additional ones). In this case the zappier automisatipn could set title, playlist, description, etc. and also set the video live.

Downsides (& reasons why we are not doing this approach):

  1. its easier with just one meeting link. You don't need to look it up.
  2. we need to regularly create new meeting rooms in zoom to cover varring meeting
  3. zappier free tier will be exceeded, so we would need to pay for a subscription.
leonardpahlke commented 1 month ago

That's a good point @riaankleinhans. I haven't checked out all the LFX functions recently. There might be smth we could use!

SamYuan1990 commented 1 month ago

@leonardpahlke , I have a question, as in China we can't access YouTube or google drive, hence is there any chance for me to get a copy of the recordings and upload them to Chinese social media?

riaankleinhans commented 1 month ago

@leonardpahlke , I have a question, as in China we can't access YouTube or google drive, hence is there any chance for me to get a copy of the recordings and upload them to Chinese social media?

@SamYuan1990 can you view this recording: (It is from another TAG in the LFX system) https://zoom.us/rec/play/Vb8Ar6mrk-P7_HK6lKa05r6HVJbzdTb34xgeCaqF3vY76XjETdMcfjgurKPQmcJaFf81eJb-Pw8mYv4.PV7DWPM7wE2A-lAt?canPlayFromShare=true&from=share_recording_detail&continueMode=true&componentName=rec-play&originRequestUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fzoom.us%2Frec%2Fshare%2FuVMsYigixfGh5Dn3M7of8M2Hah3-ytlgJhbmb3PXiHVDff3zqqWIVSn66hcGr2nW.k5FE65bI6bbi6Clu

SamYuan1990 commented 1 month ago

@leonardpahlke , I have a question, as in China we can't access YouTube or google drive, hence is there any chance for me to get a copy of the recordings and upload them to Chinese social media?

@SamYuan1990 can you view this recording: (It is from another TAG in the LFX system) https://zoom.us/rec/play/Vb8Ar6mrk-P7_HK6lKa05r6HVJbzdTb34xgeCaqF3vY76XjETdMcfjgurKPQmcJaFf81eJb-Pw8mYv4.PV7DWPM7wE2A-lAt?canPlayFromShare=true&from=share_recording_detail&continueMode=true&componentName=rec-play&originRequestUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fzoom.us%2Frec%2Fshare%2FuVMsYigixfGh5Dn3M7of8M2Hah3-ytlgJhbmb3PXiHVDff3zqqWIVSn66hcGr2nW.k5FE65bI6bbi6Clu

I can access this link and download the files. Great

riaankleinhans commented 1 month ago

Great, glad that work for you. If this TAG choose to move to LFX/Zoom meetings the recordings would be available on the community calendar and can be view anywhere in the world (specifically China) The LFX/Zoom instance also do not need signing in, so the meetings also work in China. Some TAGs moved their APAC meetings to LFX/Zoom for this reason.

SamYuan1990 commented 1 month ago

Great, glad that work for you. If this TAG choose to move to LFX/Zoom meetings the recordings would be available on the community calendar and can be view anywhere in the world (specifically China) The LFX/Zoom instance also do not need signing in, so the meetings also work in China. Some TAGs moved their APAC meetings to LFX/Zoom for this reason.

well, where can I find all the recordings via a LFX/Zoom link? so that I can regularly/schedule to make the content into social media in China.

riaankleinhans commented 1 month ago

Great, glad that work for you. If this TAG choose to move to LFX/Zoom meetings the recordings would be available on the community calendar and can be view anywhere in the world (specifically China) The LFX/Zoom instance also do not need signing in, so the meetings also work in China. Some TAGs moved their APAC meetings to LFX/Zoom for this reason.

well, where can I find all the recordings via a LFX/Zoom link? so that I can regularly/schedule to make the content into social media in China.

The TAG are not using LFX/Zoom yet. If they switch, it would be available going forward.

saiyam1814 commented 1 month ago

Great, glad that work for you. If this TAG choose to move to LFX/Zoom meetings the recordings would be available on the community calendar and can be view anywhere in the world (specifically China) The LFX/Zoom instance also do not need signing in, so the meetings also work in China. Some TAGs moved their APAC meetings to LFX/Zoom for this reason.

well, where can I find all the recordings via a LFX/Zoom link? so that I can regularly/schedule to make the content into social media in China.

The TAG are not using LFX/Zoom yet. If they switch, it would be available going forward.

Hello @riaankleinhans how can we request for LFX/Zoom?

leonardpahlke commented 1 month ago

Kristina updated the documentation last week regarding uploading videos to YT https://github.com/cncf/tag-env-sustainability/pull/556.