search

coastal-science / call-catalog-viewer

https://orca.research.sfu.ca/catalogue
Other
1 stars 0 forks source link

S09 example has an S04 confusing the start #2

Open scottveirs opened 2 years ago

scottveirs commented 2 years ago

Ideally each sample would include only the stereotyped pulsed call. In this case the S09 has a leading S04 right before it, right John, et al.? :

This issue is a particularly high priority for the S09 call type because the third example provided by John also has a fainter, brief S04 at the beginning of the S09:

Together, this could confuse a listener into thinking the S09 always begins with a low-frequency buzz-like part (when it is actually a preceding S04 call).

scottveirs commented 1 year ago

@JKBF Can you confirm S09 calls do or do not have an S04-like as their first part?

JKBF commented 1 year ago

Many thanks, Scott. That example of S09 has a particularly loud S04 at the beginning, which only overlaps slightly with the S09. This is indeed confusing and I will remove that example.