code-423n4 / org

Code4rena Governance and Discussion
70 stars 17 forks source link

Proposal - Allow new judges to appoint their own first judge mentor #120

Open 5z1punch opened 1 year ago

5z1punch commented 1 year ago

There is a new rule added to the Judge Guidelines, that "when judging an audit for the very first time, the new judge's work is reviewed by a senior judge.". This will be very helpful for new judges to get started with their work.

I hope to allow new judges to appoint their own first judge mentor. Allowing new judges to choose senior judges they trust and are more familiar with for assistance can lead to more efficient collaboration.

GalloDaSballo commented 1 year ago

This was done in the past, where the new Judge would offer a portion of their Judging Fee to a Senior Judge to get advice and reviews

liveactionllama commented 1 year ago

Yes, just want to clarify that the requirement isn't new regarding a senior judge reviewing a new judge's work the first time. It has been consistently followed. I just noticed that it wasn't mentioned in our Judge Guidelines, so I recently added it there for more awareness, especially for new judges during onboarding.