search

code4lib / code-of-conduct

Code4lib code of conduct
https://code4lib.org/
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
84 stars 74 forks source link

Changed one line. #14

Closed gloriousgeneralist closed 11 years ago

gloriousgeneralist commented 11 years ago

This was a suggestion from Devchix mailing list, want to see it people like it.

anarchivist commented 11 years ago

+1. Looks good to me, and I think it makes the same point a bit more eloquently than was in there previously.

ruebot commented 11 years ago

:+1:

mjgiarlo commented 11 years ago

The big diff, AFAICT, is that is somewhat softens what we had in there before. Making someone uncomfortable isn't in there anymore. I'm OK with that change, but I want to be sure this is the desired effect of this change.

If so, y'all, merge away.

gloriousgeneralist commented 11 years ago

You've got it. That is the idea, and I think is a good change.

ruebot commented 11 years ago

This is the really hard part, and what @gloriousgeneralist and @mjgiarlo have raised are getting at. You want to hit the nail on the head the first time if you can, but we can revisit it later if need be. At least we are not approving this in a giant council using Robert's Rules of order. This past May, CAUT updated their Anti-harassment statement and we had 1.5hr debate over the word vexatious. I've never seen Robert's Rules go that deep.

This is the CAUT definition: "Harassment is any vexatious comment or conduct against someone that is known or ought reasonably to be known to be unwelcome. It includes harassment on the prohibited grounds identified under provincial human rights codes, as well as sexual, psychological and personal harassment."

mjgiarlo commented 11 years ago

OK then, merge time. :smiley: Thanks for the pull request!