Contao 4.4.x: Cache

[derastronaut]

Hello Kamil,

as you may be know the cache in Contao 4.4.7+ is broken, because of an error in Symfony. Now, Johannes Pichler (https://packagist.org/packages/pliigo/pagecacheenabler-bundle) wrote an extension which fixes that issue but Cookiebar is being cachet too. I know there was the same problem in Contao 3.x some time ago and you fixed it. Now, in Contao 4 (I am using 4.4.13) the issue is back again. I can push the "accept"-button as many times I want but on some (cached) pages the Cookiebar still shows up.

Greetings Sebastian

[qzminski]

This should be fixed in #34. Are you using the latest version of the extension?

If it's still broken then probably all Contao insert tags are affected...

[derastronaut]

I have version 1.4.0 installed from 26.01.2018.

[joeherold]

@derastronaut it is not an error of symfony... :)

[qzminski]

@derastronaut can you check if other insert tags are working fine with cache? For example {{date}}.

[derastronaut]

Yes, {{date}} is working.

[joeherold]

@derastronaut I changed the behaviour in the cache fix for insert-tags using uncached flag. updated to version 1.1.5 https://packagist.org/packages/pliigo/pagecacheenabler-bundle

[qzminski]

@derastronaut can you check the solution proposed by @joeherold ? The cookiebar will be rewritten to be JS-only in version 2.0 – see #36, so maybe it's better to release that instead of fixing this issue over and over...

[joeherold]

@qzminski it was my fault, because in my quick fix, the |uncached was cached as well :)

[qzminski]

I know, yet the cookiebar concept is still wrong as it should be JS-only 😉

[joeherold]

LOL, thats why I am using: https://cookieconsent.insites.com/

[derastronaut]

Now the Cookiebar disappears by hitting "command+r". I do not push the "accept"-button. I tried it in Firefox and Safari.

[joeherold]

did you clear the cache?

[joeherold]

and clear the cookies you already have?

[derastronaut]

Yes

[joeherold]

ok, but that seems to be something different. the inserttag is now not cached anymore

[derastronaut]

Yes to both.

[joeherold]

if this issue is according to my quickfix, which works for me, you may force symfony/symfony to version 3.4.3 in your composer.json of your website and do update all your packages in symfony 3.4.3 the session thing was not present

[joeherold]

@qzminski @derastronaut Issue should be closed, because it is not related to this extension

[derastronaut]

Ok, thanks for the hint with Symfony. But I'll give Cookie Consent a try until Cookiebar 2.0 is released :)

[qzminski]

Thanks for investigating this! Any ideas if there is a Cookie Consent extension for Contao 4?

[derastronaut]

I guess this could it be: https://packagist.org/packages/trilobit-gmbh/contao-cookiebar-bundle ?

In https://github.com/trilobit-gmbh/contao-cookiebar-bundle/tree/master/src/Resources/public/assets/src there is a cookieconsent.js. But I didn't tried this extension yet.

[qzminski]

Thanks, I may consider switching to cookieconsent.js in version 2 as well.