World Bank organisation-identifier mismatch

codeforIATI / iati-data-bugtracker

🐛 A public log of issues with IATI data and metadata

https://bugtracker.codeforiati.org

3 stars 0 forks source link

World Bank organisation-identifier mismatch #6

Open notshi opened 4 years ago

notshi commented 4 years ago

Explanation of the bug

We found that The World Bank has reported a different organisation-identifier to their reporting-org/@ref in their organisation file.

This means they now have two profiles on d-portal.

No data, just org-file http://d-portal.org/ctrack.html?publisher=44002#view=main
All data, incomplete org-file http://d-portal.org/ctrack.html?publisher=44000#view=main

URLs / screenshots

iati_44000

Does the publisher know?

Unsure. Was raised here with tech-team mentioned.

notshi commented 3 years ago

Have raised it again directly via email to IATI Support and Publisher contact. Awaiting response.

notshi commented 3 years ago

Received a response yesterday:

I am not sure that our reporting is incorrect. The World Bank (44000) publish data for the International Development Association (44200) and the International Bank for Development and Reconstruction (44100).

The World Bank only publish a Organisation file for the International Development Association, so I think the reported information is correct?

The World Bank org file in question - https://iatiregistry.org/dataset/worldbank-org

Might need to dig out the publishing guidance for this so that things are clearer for how we handle multiple organisations in an org file. Also raised here.

Will await response from IATI Support on the matter.

stale[bot] commented 3 years ago

Hello! There has been no activity on this issue in the last 30 days. I wonder if it has now been resolved?!

If you’re reading this, would you mind checking to see if the issue is still applicable?

If it has been resolved, please add a message to that effect, and (if you’re able to) close it.
If the problem still applies, please add a message to let us know. I’ll remove the "awaiting update" label, and will check in again next month.

Thank you!

notshi commented 3 years ago

Problem still applies - and it might be an ongoing issue with the org identifier element and how publishers are using it.

codeforIATIbot commented 3 years ago

Hello! There has been no activity on this issue in the last 30 days. I wonder if it has now been resolved?

If you’re reading this, would you mind checking to see if the issue is still applicable?

If it has been resolved, please add a message to that effect, and (if you’re able to) close it.
If the problem still applies, please add a message to let us know. I’ll remove the "awaiting update" label, and will check in again next month.

Thank you!

notshi commented 3 years ago

This has been confirmed as an ongoing issue by the tech team as it is about how a particular publisher interprets the guidance document of this IATI element usage.

codeforIATIbot commented 3 years ago

Hello! There has been no activity on this issue in the last 30 days. I wonder if it has now been resolved?

If you’re reading this, would you mind checking to see if the issue is still applicable?

If it has been resolved, please add a message to that effect, and (if you’re able to) close it.
If the problem still applies, please add a message to let us know. I’ll remove the "awaiting update" label, and will check in again next month.

Thank you!

notshi commented 3 years ago

I believe this could qualify as an evergreen issue as the publisher sees no error in their usage of the element and it is more of a publisher relation with the standard for the IATI tech team.

Furthermore, it looks like the IATI Support ticket has been deleted/hidden so I can't nudge or follow through. What do you think, @andylolz?