codeforamerica / civic-tech-patterns

common patterns and anti-patterns for civic tech and civic apps
http://codeforamerica.github.io/civic-tech-patterns
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
197 stars 25 forks source link

Understand what wicked problems are #28

Open louh opened 10 years ago

louh commented 10 years ago

Not all civic tech problems are necessarily wicked problems, but understanding what they are in the context of social policy will give you a level of wisdom and zen about the problems you try to tackle.

My restatement of a wicked problem in the CfA fellowship experience:

  1. Every situation is inherently unique. Cities have their own culture, subcultures, histories, people, politics, and economic conditions. (Yes, you can always generalize about different groups, regions, states, political parties, etc but start there and then ask, "but how is this situation unique?)
  2. The problem is difficult to define. See also #27 "The problem is not always the problem." The problem may not be definable until after an attempt at a solution (or several).
  3. The best solutions will never be immediately obvious.
  4. There is no such thing as a "best" solution, only "better" ones.
  5. The metrics for success are themselves difficult to define, because stakeholders and participants have different worldviews about what the problem is and what constitutes success.
  6. Solutions are never actually finished. Fellowship projects are not truly final deliverables but the beginning of an experiment.
  7. Problems and solutions are not inherently generalizable to other contexts. This makes projects actually difficult to redeploy and plug into different cities and their problems unless someone goes through the hard part of understanding each situation thoroughly.

The one big difference from civic tech and the classic definition of a wicked problem:

Brain dumped; maybe this is better broken up as several patterns / anti-patterns?

louh commented 10 years ago

Also should mention that while this seems like a fully formed thought it really isn't.