search

codetaylor / pyrotech-1.12

An early game mod with new primitive devices, combustion machines, smelting mechanics, storage options, tools, torches, advancements, and absolutely zero GUIs -- with exception to the substantially complete, mostly illustrated, and charred guidebook.
https://pyrotech.readthedocs.io/en/latest/
Other
52 stars 19 forks source link

pottery shard cycling #203

Open Divineaspect opened 4 years ago

Divineaspect commented 4 years ago

I would like to be able to hammer or otherwise grind (I'm using adv mortars) pottery shards into dried clay dust, which in turn can be soaked in water to regain workable clay.

nephatrine commented 4 years ago

Once you bake clay, you can't really turn it back into workable clay again. The high temperatures change the material pretty radically. Grinding the pottery into dust would give you basically the same thing as grinding up a rock into dust and clay formation from rock sediments is a long geologic process. So I think the sand pile you get currently from pottery shards is pretty accurate.

As far as game mechanics go, there's already a dirt clump -> clay recipe the mod adds that is simple enough if you're just looking for an easy way to obtain more clay.

Divineaspect commented 4 years ago

does more research that's kinda interesting, because when I was a scout they had us grind it up and use it to make mortar if it broke when firing. While clay isn't the same material, I think it's the closest one in minecraft.

codetaylor commented 4 years ago

What problem would this solution solve? Not enough clay or not enough to do with the broken clay?

Divineaspect commented 4 years ago

I was thinking of both, but I'd be satisfied with resolving both of them separately. the clay issue could be resolved by just adding a soaking pot recipe for the dirt instead of requiring iron buckets. The only uses I can think of for pottery shards other then mortars is making mosaics or arrowheads but flint isn't exactly rare.

nephatrine commented 4 years ago

I don't think this belongs in pyrotech necessarily, but it'd be neat to make kintsugi repaired pottery with the shards. Maybe also could use either pottery shards or rocks to make gravel? They do seem a bit pointless to me as it currently stands.

As for making clay, yeah it would be neat to have a better way to make it from dirt, though it'd be nice if the soaking tub could return multiple outputs so soaking a dirt you could extract maybe both sand pile and clay from it since both are components of many dirts.