search

codinguser / gnucash-android

Gnucash for Android mobile companion application.
Apache License 2.0
1.23k stars 540 forks source link

Nextcloud 11 login test not working #651

Closed poVoq closed 6 years ago

poVoq commented 7 years ago

Steps to reproduce the behaviour

  1. Go to setting and back up on owncloud
  2. Input nextcloud11 server adress(http) and credentials
  3. When pressing test it says oc server ok, but login details incorrect

Expected behaviour

Nextcloud 11 should still be fully compatible with owncloud, or did they change the login Api?

Actual behaviour

Software specifications

sehucke commented 7 years ago

Same with GnuCash 2.1.5 on a Moto G 4G (peregrine) and a Nextcloud 11.0.2 instance. Neither user/password nor user/app-pin currently work.

codinguser commented 7 years ago

@poVoq can you use the new Save As.. functionality in v2.2.0 with your NextCloud successfully?

wenxin-wang commented 7 years ago

Seems that GnuCash is using /index.php/ocs/cloud/user for logging-in, but at least on NextCloud 11 the GET request will get 302 redirected to the login page (/login)

codinguser commented 7 years ago

@wenxin-wang are you referring to the "Save As.." functionality, or the logging in via ownCloud integration?

sehucke commented 7 years ago

You can use the "Send to..." export target for use with the Nextcloud app. It is not that much convenient (you have to choose the upload folder each time) but it works.

IMHO, this is a more general solution and should work with other cloud storages as well - as long as they provide an Android client. ;-)

Johnjustdoit commented 7 years ago

Did you set a new APP-Pin for gnucash in the nextcloud settings in the webpanel?

Johnjustdoit commented 7 years ago

Go to the nextcloud webpanel->press your nickname in the top right-> personal. Then set a new APP-PIN and copy the new passwort. Paste the passwort into the gnucash panel with your nextcloud Nickname and your Serveradress.

poVoq commented 7 years ago

AFAIK the app pin should only be necessary if an external auth system like SAML or LDAP is used in Nextcloud and thus no password is stored in the Nextcloud database.

sehucke commented 7 years ago

@poVoq @Johnjustdoit : An app pin is necessary if you activated TOTP for your user. AFAIK, it is fully transparent to the client if you enter your password or an app pin.

Just do as follows:

  1. Log into your Nextcloud Android client with your password.
  2. Activate TOTP via web interface.
  3. Watch your Android client mourn about invalid credentials.
  4. Create an app pin and use that pin instead of your password.
  5. Watch your Android client successfully connect to your NC instance.

That means it won't make any difference for GnuCash.

BTW: Has anyone tried to use GnuCash app with NC12?

Johnjustdoit commented 7 years ago

Thank you for clearing it up! I found a workaround to sync it automatically in my private network. (Should also work with a nextcloud reachable in the www) I use the app Foldersync Pro (3,19€) and the app tasker (2,99€). First I set a periodic export in GnuCash to my SD Card. Then I set a task in tasker to sync all my previous added syncronisations(GnuCash, Photos,...etc) in FolderSync when my phone log into my home WLAN. This is posible for any folder and file on your phone. On my PC I use the nextcloudapp to use the file in my nextcloud folder with GnuCash.

sehucke commented 7 years ago

Yep, that should do the trick. :-)

Nevertheless, the NC Android client v1.5 (and above) has the potential to render this toolchain obsolete. See nextcloud/android#285 (it is a meta ticket gathering the work done in separate tickets).

This would render a separate interface implementation in GnuCash for NC obsolete. All you need is a local export folder and an auto upload watcher in your NC app.

denysvitali commented 7 years ago

I'm having the exact same problem with Nextcloud 11.0.3. @sehucke tip didn't work (I don't have 2FA enabled atm, which may be the cause)

Update: Apparently neither NC 12.0.0 works

sehucke commented 7 years ago

Which tip did you mean @denysvitali ? I suppose you are referring to https://github.com/codinguser/gnucash-android/issues/651#issuecomment-315597218 ? My explanation of app pin usage was not meant to be a tip for getting GnuCash to work with NC. I tried to explain the exact opposite: It does not matter if you use your password or an app pin inside GnuCash. The client does not know there is a difference.

At the moment there seem to be only two ways to get GnuCash working with NC:

  1. To use "Send to..." as described in https://github.com/codinguser/gnucash-android/issues/651#issuecomment-312599156 or...
  2. ... to set up a toolchain like @Johnjustdoit explained in https://github.com/codinguser/gnucash-android/issues/651#issuecomment-315598825. (Which I have not tested so far by myself. Should work anyway.)

Besides that: App pins should work regardless of whether you have enabled 2FA or not. If I remember correctly, I have successfully tried that before enabling 2FA in my NC installation. You can easily verify if your app pins work correctly. Just generate a new pin and use an app to log in with it (NC, DAVdroid, CalDAV, CardDAV...). However, atm this won't help you with this GnuCash problem.

denysvitali commented 7 years ago

I'm already working on a fix to integrate NextCloud into GnuCash... I thought NC and OC had the same authentication mechanism

5nafu commented 7 years ago

With Nextcloud 12 I could successfully work around the Issue with an entry in my webserver config (in this case apache2 with virtualhosts):

RewriteEngine On
RewriteRule ^/index.php/ocs/cloud/user /ocs/v1.php/cloud/user
rivaldi8 commented 6 years ago

Fixed develop branch (fc261f7).