colonistio / design

https://colonist.io
3 stars 0 forks source link

End Game MMR Improvement #1 - Showing Progress Bar #129

Closed samgawaran closed 2 years ago

samgawaran commented 2 years ago

Summary

@JeffdEon mentioned that we would be adding divisions in the next update. here: https://github.com/colonistio/katan/issues/7867, sending this submission to show the intended animation and what it looks like if you ranked up/down

Comparison:

image

  1. Made the time and and turns smaller to make room for the division icon
  2. Added division icon and reworked how we present MMR change
  3. Added the progress bar I'll leave to @JeffdEon whats the cap for each divisions

Details

Ranked End Game - Victory

End Game MMR - Victory V2

Ranked End Game - Defeat

End Game MMR - Defeat V2

Ranked Up/Down

image

Progress Bar in Lowest/Highest Ranks

image

Top Ranked Player

image

IDEA: Add a crown icon for the top players

Related links

Submission Checklist

demiculus commented 2 years ago

Changed Continue button as the current button design in the end-game screen is inconsistent to what we're using in all of the other pages on the website

  1. this is a separate issue
  2. you need to post screenshots of all the other places as well that use this button style
samgawaran commented 2 years ago

for review: @JuanRoman77 @JeffdEon

Changed Continue button as the current button design in the end-game screen is inconsistent to what we're using in all of the other pages on the website

this is a separate issue you need to post screenshots of all the other places as well that use this button style

@demiculus got it. I updated the continue buttons in the design I added here. I'll just create a separate issue to discuss the buttons

JeffdEon commented 2 years ago

Ranked Up/Down

I didn't get a chance to code whether user just got promoted or not in the backend. It should be ignored for this version and added next version.

JuanRoman77 commented 2 years ago

Ranked Up -> Promoted Ranked Down -> No text

Ranked up/down is not the best option, players rank up and down every time they win or lose. Here they are going to a higher division. Thoughts?

JuanRoman77 commented 2 years ago

1- This is not a good design. When I see this it looks like I'm Bronze going for Gold. I don't think this is how other games do it? It should be clearer. I'd start by adding the divisions' names. Also the numbers should be at the same height. image

2- Silver icon in the middle of the bar is different size than the bronze and gold, that doesn't look great. Shouldn't it be the other way around?

3- The MMR for each division changes each season depending on number of players. I don't think we should show the limits, it might cause confusion

4- Current design for earned and new MMR (https://i.imgur.com/qOc0lpA.png) is clearer than the suggested. It's easy to read how much MMR has been earned in that game, and what the new value is. Keep current.

samgawaran commented 2 years ago

Closing this issue, latest iteration is in here: https://github.com/colonistio/design/issues/133