Indicate Missing Resource Cards - revised submission

colonistio / design

https://colonist.io

3 stars 0 forks source link

Indicate Missing Resource Cards - revised submission #132

Closed seojoon-y closed 2 years ago

seojoon-y commented 2 years ago

Summary

When playing colonist.io, I always have to think about which resource card I'm missing to build a settlement, road, etc... It would be super useful to indicate which resource cards you already have, and which you are missing. (Summary copied from https://github.com/colonistio/design/issues/131 )

Details

Proposed designs are below. Suppose that you have a tree card but you don't have a brick card:

Submission Checklist

[x] This submission abides by Des-lvl-1, Des-lvl-2 & Des-lvl-3

demiculus commented 2 years ago

Here is how don't starve does it, doesn't quite work for our case

Esqarrouth commented 2 years ago

great research and solutions @seojoon-y

also mention which one you recommend after your research and design

I liked v2 + v5. it highlights + lowers opacity.

@samgawaran give your inputs

let's decide on a design then you can work on a solution

samgawaran commented 2 years ago

Hey @seojoon-y, I like both v2 & v5 as well. though for your next submission, could you also create some specific scenarios like:

What does it look like for settlements & cities, since the action bar is above them? this won't work for opacity for v2 : https://prnt.sc/XuPdEvSPlze1
How will it look for Cities and Knights and Seafarer assets?
what will happen if they click on the cards that have incomplete resource? will it stay the same like in the current implementation?

Also try to check these similar catan games if ever: KatanDao, Catan Universe, Landover. But overall, nice submission :)

seojoon-y commented 2 years ago

Completed this task here: https://github.com/colonistio/katan/pull/7941

colonistio / design