search

comment-anything / proposal

Comment Anything Browser Extension
MIT License
0 stars 0 forks source link

Project Title #3

Closed Bkrenz closed 1 year ago

Bkrenz commented 1 year ago

I note the Organization for the Project is titled Comment Anything, though I was using Comment Anywhere in my initial documentation.

Personally, I think it's a better fit to use Anywhere over Anything. While Comment Anything does give the sense that we can Comment ON Anything, it perhaps also conveys that we allow any comments. Comment Anywhere is perhaps a bit more specific in my mind, but I welcome discussion.

Also, these perhaps superficial conversations are the essence of corporate bureaucracy.

klm127 commented 1 year ago

I absolutely agree. I prefer your suggestion, Comment Anywhere.

I disagree that naming is a superficial activity. Naming something gives you dominion of it, like Adam in Eden. Moreover, it's the first thing about this project anyone sees - it's the first sales pitch.

LBytes-32 commented 1 year ago

"Comment Anywhere" definitely rolls off the tongue much better, in my opinion. Should we have some form of slogan as well?

klm127 commented 1 year ago

I am going to close this issue and attempt to rename the organization. If anyone wants a name reconsider, just open another issue.

You may have to update your git repositories upstreams, but better now than when we are further in.

@LBytes-32 I don't think we should worry about the slogan right now. That's more a corporate culture and branding type thing IMO. At any rate it would deserve its own issue and discussion.

klm127 commented 1 year ago

Update: The github page https://github.com/comment-anywhere is not available so the github org url identifier won't change for now.

Comment Anywhere is still our project name though.