data-default-0.8 obsoletes data-defaults-instance's

juhp commented 1 month ago

data-default-0.8.0.0 is out of bounds for:

[ ] HMock-0.5.1.2 (>=0.7.1 && < 0.8). Chris Smith cdsmith@gmail.com. Used by: library
[ ] aws-0.24.2 (>=0.5.3 && < 0.8). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] clash-lib-1.8.1 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). QBayLogic B.V. devops@qbaylogic.com @martijnbastiaan. Used by: library
[ ] copilot-theorem-4.0 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). Jens Petersen juhpetersen@gmail.com @juhp. Used by: library
[x] data-effects-0.2.0.0 (^>=0.7.1). Sayo Koyoneda ymdfield@outlook.jp. Used by: library
[x] data-effects-th-0.2.0.0 (^>=0.7.1). Sayo Koyoneda ymdfield@outlook.jp. Used by: library
[x] diagrams-contrib-1.4.5.1 (>=0.5.2 && < 0.8). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[x] ersatz-0.5 (>=0.5 && < 0.8). Edward Kmett ekmett@gmail.com @ekmett. Used by: library
[ ] falsify-0.2.0 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). Preetham Gujjula libraries@mail.preetham.io @pgujjula. Used by: library
[ ] hakyll-4.16.2.2 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). Jasper Van der Jeugt @jaspervdj & Alexander Batischev eual.jp@gmail.com @Minoru. Used by: library
[x] hakyll-convert-0.3.0.5 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). Alexander Batischev eual.jp@gmail.com @Minoru. Used by: library
[ ] hoauth2-2.14.0 (^>=0.7). Haisheng Wu freizl@gmail.com @freizl. Used by: library
[x] incipit-base-0.6.1.0 (>=0.2 && < 0.8). Torsten Schmits stackage@schmits.me @tek. Used by: library
[ ] lsp-2.7.0.0 (^>=0.7). Michael Peyton Jones me@michaelpj.com. Used by: library
[ ] lsp-test-0.17.1.0 (^>=0.7). Michael Peyton Jones me@michaelpj.com. Used by: library
[ ] lsp-types-2.3.0.0 (^>=0.7). Michael Peyton Jones me@michaelpj.com. Used by: library
[ ] pandoc-3.4 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). John MacFarlane jgm@berkeley.edu @jgm, Stackage upper bounds. Used by: library
[ ] pandoc-lua-engine-0.3.2 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). Albert Krewinkel albert+stackage@zeitkraut.de @tarleb, Stackage upper bounds. Used by: library
[ ] pandoc-server-0.1.0.8 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). John MacFarlane jgm@berkeley.edu @jgm, Stackage upper bounds. Used by: library
[ ] run-haskell-module-0.0.2 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] strive-6.0.0.12 (^>=0.7.1.1). Taylor Fausak taylor@fausak.me @tfausak. Used by: library
[ ] threepenny-gui-0.9.4.1 (>=0.5.0 && < 0.8). Simon Jakobi simon.jakobi@gmail.com @sjakobi. Used by: library
[ ] tmp-proc-0.7.1.0 (>=0.5 && < 0.8). Tim Emiola tim.emiola@gmail.com @adetokunbo. Used by: test-suite
[x] tz-0.1.3.6 (>=0.5 && < 0.8). Mihaly Barasz klao@nilcons.com @klao. Used by: library
[ ] wai-middleware-delegate-0.1.4.1 (^>=0.7.1.1). Tim Emiola tim.emiola@gmail.com @adetokunbo. Used by: library
[ ] wuss-2.0.2.0 (^>=0.7.1.1). Taylor Fausak taylor@fausak.me @tfausak. Used by: library

Note that this basically obsoletes `data-default-instances-`*

See below for the changelog

byorgey commented 1 month ago

Does anyone know what the breaking changes are? There doesn't seem to be a changelog.

tfausak commented 1 month ago

I can't find a change log either. Here's the diff: https://github.com/mauke/data-default/compare/1e4f789429f098d851105a761d5ff539113f5bb9...8178c677200b6a92a2a634921ea20f5649ac83f0

tarleb commented 1 month ago

I've opened an issue: https://github.com/mauke/data-default/issues/28

mauke commented 1 month ago

Changes in 0.8.0.0:

The split into multiple packages (data-default-class, data-default-instances-*) is gone. There is only data-default now (with no dependencies on data-default-class or anything).
data-default only depends on containers and base now (but requires base >= 4.8).
The Default instances for Data.DList and System.Locale are gone (but could be revived with updated versions of data-default-instances-dlist and data-default-instances-old-locale in the future?).
The Default instances for e -> a and IO a have been removed.
The "generic" default Default instance now supports sum types as well (by always choosing the left constructor).
The internal GDefault type is now semi-public (in the Data.Default.Internal module) and has stub documentation.
New instances:
- Tuples of size up to 31 (previously 7)
- Identity
- Const
- Proxy
- Solo
- Bool
- CBool
- Ptr
- ConstPtr
- FunPtr
- IntPtr
- WordPtr

jgm commented 1 month ago

The split into multiple packages (data-default-class, data-default-instances-*) is gone. There is only data-default now (with no dependencies on data-default-class or anything).

In that case, every package that depends on data-default-class or data-default-instances needs to be modified, right? So the above list is incomplete. I discovered this by trying to compile pandoc with the constraint data-default >= 0.8; it fails with an error building xml-conduit:

    • No instance for ‘Data.Default.Internal.Default X.ParseSettings’
        arising from a use of ‘def’

xml-conduit depends on data-default-class but not data-default.

tfausak commented 1 month ago

Yes, I ran into the same issue.

tek commented 1 month ago

published a revision of incipit-base ✅

juhp commented 1 month ago

The split into multiple packages (data-default-class, data-default-instances-*) is gone. There is only data-default now (with no dependencies on data-default-class or anything).

In that case, every package that depends on data-default-class or data-default-instances needs to be modified, right? So the above list is incomplete. I discovered this by trying to compile pandoc with the constraint data-default >= 0.8; it fails with an error building xml-conduit

Ah I see - feels like this needs wider awareness, a Discourse post/announcement would probably make sense? But okay I guess we could try to generate a list of dependents (I suppose data-default-class should be sufficient):

https://www.stackage.org/nightly-2024-10-25/package/data-default-class-0.1.2.2/revdeps

Minoru commented 1 month ago

/cc @LaurentRDC . NB: Hakyll will have to wait until pandoc is updated.

Minoru commented 1 month ago

Fixed for hakyll-convert by revision 0.3.0.5@rev:2.

jgm commented 1 month ago

At the very least xml-conduit should be added to the list above and its maintainer notified. Pandoc won't build with data-default 0.8 without changes there. Perhaps there are other packages, too, that depend on data-default-class but not data-default.

byorgey commented 1 month ago

Perhaps there are other packages, too, that depend on data-default-class but not data-default.

@jgm see @juhp 's above comment with a link to a list of such packages. I agree perhaps we should add those packages to the list in this issue as well.

juhp commented 1 month ago

edit: Note data-default-class-0.2.0 compatibility library has now been released though it probably still makes sense to drop it as a dependency going forward?

These are the current Nightly packages that depend on data-default-class directly or indirectly

data-default-class (Grandfathered dependencies) (not present) depended on by:

[ ] Chart-1.9.5 (< 0.2). Vitaly Bragilevsky vit.bragilevsky@gmail.com @bravit. Used by: library
[ ] Chart-cairo-1.9.4.1 (< 0.2). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] Chart-diagrams-1.9.5.1 (< 0.2). Vitaly Bragilevsky vit.bragilevsky@gmail.com @bravit. Used by: library
[ ] Color-0.3.3 (>=0). Alexey Kuleshevich lehins@yandex.ru @lehins. Used by: library
[ ] SVGFonts-1.8.0.1 (< 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[ ] X11-1.10.3 (>=0.1 && < 0.2). xmonad xmonad@haskell.org. Used by: library
[ ] amqp-0.24.0 (>=0.1). Roman Cheplyaka roma@ro-che.info @feuerbach. Used by: library
[ ] blank-canvas-0.7.4 (>=0.0.1 && < 0.2). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] bzlib-conduit-0.3.0.3 (>=0). Michael Snoyman michael@snoyman.com @snoyberg. Used by: library
[ ] clash-prelude-1.8.1 (>=0.1.2 && < 0.2). QBayLogic B.V. devops@qbaylogic.com @martijnbastiaan. Used by: library
[ ] cookie-0.5.0 (>=0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] cron-0.7.1 (>=0.0.1). Michael Xavier michael@michaelxavier.net @MichaelXavier. Used by: library
[ ] crypton-connection-0.4.1 (>=0). Kazu Yamamoto kazu@iij.ad.jp @kazu-yamamoto. Used by: library
[ ] crypton-x509-validation-1.6.12 (>=0). Kazu Yamamoto kazu@iij.ad.jp @kazu-yamamoto. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-0.7.1.3 (^>=0.1.2.1). Grandfathered dependencies, Stackage upper bounds. Used by: library
[ ] diagrams-cairo-1.4.2.1 (>=0.0.1 && < 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[ ] diagrams-canvas-1.4.1.2 (>=0.0.1 && < 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey, Jeffrey Rosenbluth jeffrey.rosenbluth@gmail.com @jeffreyrosenbluth. Used by: library
[ ] diagrams-contrib-1.4.5.1 (< 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[ ] diagrams-lib-1.4.6.2 (< 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[ ] diagrams-postscript-1.5.1.1 (< 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[ ] diagrams-rasterific-1.4.2.3 (>=0.0 && < 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[ ] dotenv-0.12.0.0 (>=0.1.2 && < 0.2). Stack Builders stackage@stackbuilders.com @stackbuilders. Used by: library
[ ] elynx-tree-0.7.2.2 (>=0). Dominik Schrempf dominik.schrempf@gmail.com @dschrempf. Used by: library
[ ] emd-0.2.0.0 (>=0). Justin Le justin@jle.im @mstksg. Used by: library
[ ] fold-debounce-0.2.0.12 (^>=0.1.2). Toshio Ito debug.ito@gmail.com @debug-ito. Used by: library
[ ] force-layout-0.4.0.6 (>=0.0.1 && < 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey, Stackage upper bounds. Used by: library
[ ] ftp-client-0.5.1.6 (>=0.1.2.0 && < 0.2). Dan Burton danburton.email@gmail.com @DanBurton. Used by: library
[ ] gitlab-haskell-1.0.1.0 (>=0). Rob Stewart robstewart57@gmail.com @robstewart57. Used by: library
[ ] hnix-store-core-0.8.0.0 (>=0). Abandoned packages. Used by: library
[ ] hsass-0.8.0 (>=0). Jakub Fijałkowski kuba@codinginfinity.me @jakubfijalkowski. Used by: library
[ ] http-client-tls-0.3.6.3 (>=0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] kansas-comet-0.4.2 (>=0.0.1 && < 0.2). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] language-docker-13.0.0 (>=0). José Lorenzo Rodríguez jose.zap@gmail.com @lorenzo. Used by: library
[ ] libmpd-0.10.0.1 (>=0.0.1 && < 1). Joachim Fasting joachifm@fastmail.fm @joachifm. Used by: library
[ ] logstash-0.1.0.4 (>=0). Michael B. Gale github@michael-gale.co.uk @mbg. Used by: library
[ ] massiv-io-1.0.0.1 (>=0). Alexey Kuleshevich lehins@yandex.ru @lehins. Used by: library
[ ] massiv-test-1.1.0.0 (>=0). Alexey Kuleshevich lehins@yandex.ru @lehins. Used by: library
[ ] math-functions-0.3.4.4 (>=0.1.2.0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] mathexpr-0.3.1.0 (>=0). Mahdi Dibaiee mdibaiee@aol.com @mdibaiee. Used by: library
[ ] memcache-0.3.0.2 (>=0.1.0). David Terei code@davidterei.com @dterei. Used by: library
[ ] monad-chronicle-1.0.2 (>=0.1.2.0 && < 0.2). Clint Adams clint@debian.org @clinty. Used by: library
[ ] mongoDB-2.7.1.4 (>=0). Victor Denisov denisovenator@gmail.com @VictorDenisov. Used by: library
[ ] mysql-haskell-1.1.5 (>=0.1.2 && < 0.2). Winter Han winterland1989@gmail.com @winterland1989. Used by: library
[ ] network-conduit-tls-1.4.0.1 (>=0). Michael Snoyman michael@snoyman.com @snoyberg. Used by: library
[ ] network-ip-0.3.0.3 (>=0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] pointed-5.0.4 (>=0.0.1 && < 0.2). Edward Kmett ekmett@gmail.com @ekmett. Used by: library
[ ] req-3.13.4 (>=0). Mark Karpov markkarpov92@gmail.com @mrkkrp. Used by: library
[ ] rzk-0.7.5 (>=0.1.2.0). Nikolai Kudasov nickolay.kudasov@gmail.com @fizruk. Used by: library
[ ] scotty-0.22 (>=0.1). Andrew Farmer afarmer@ittc.ku.edu @xich, Marco Zocca @ocramz. Used by: library
[ ] servant-auth-server-0.4.9.0 (>=0.1.2.0 && < 0.2). Domen Kozar domen@enlambda.com @domenkozar. Used by: library
[ ] servant-quickcheck-0.1.1.0 (>=0.0 && < 0.2). Matt Parsons parsonsmatt@gmail.com @parsonsmatt. Used by: library
[ ] shellify-0.11.0.3 (>=0.1.2.0 && < 0.2). Daniel Rolls daniel.rolls.27@googlemail.com @danielrolls. Used by: library
[ ] smtp-mail-0.5.0.0 (^>=0.1.2.0). Spencer Janssen spencerjanssen@gmail.com @spencerjanssen. Used by: library
[ ] statistics-0.16.2.1 (>=0.1.2). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] tls-2.0.6 (>=0.1 && < 0.2). Kazu Yamamoto kazu@iij.ad.jp @kazu-yamamoto, Stackage upper bounds. Used by: library
[ ] tlynx-0.7.2.2 (>=0). Dominik Schrempf dominik.schrempf@gmail.com @dschrempf. Used by: library
[ ] wai-extra-3.1.15 (>=0). Michael Snoyman michael@snoyman.com @snoyberg. Used by: library
[ ] wai-saml2-0.6 (< 1). Michael B. Gale github@michael-gale.co.uk @mbg. Used by: library
[ ] warp-tls-3.4.7 (>=0.0.1). Michael Snoyman michael@snoyman.com @snoyberg. Used by: library
[ ] webdriver-0.12.0.0 (>=0). Tom McLaughlin tom@codedown.io @thomasjm. Used by: library
[ ] xml-conduit-1.9.1.3 (>=0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] xmonad-0.18.0 (>=0). xmonad xmonad@haskell.org. Used by: library
[ ] yesod-1.6.2.1 (>=0). Michael Snoyman michael@snoyman.com @snoyberg. Used by: library
[ ] yesod-bin-1.6.2.3 (>=0). Michael Snoyman michael@snoyman.com @snoyberg. Used by: executable

danielrolls commented 1 month ago

Fixed in shellify-0.11.0.5

juhp commented 1 month ago

Okay so actually data-default-class 0.2.0 was released for backward compatibility now.

juhp commented 1 month ago

@jgm, does data-default-class-0.2.0 help?

(Hmm I hid my data-default-class bounds comment, though maybe it is still better for packages to drop it)

dschrempf commented 1 month ago

Fixed for tlynx-0.8.0.0, and elynx-tree-0.8.0.0.

jgm commented 4 weeks ago

I was able to compile pandoc and its dependencies using --constrain 'data-default >= 0.8' -- constrain 'data-default-class >= 0.2' --allow-newer=data-default-class.

To get it to work without --allow-newer, the dependencies (e.g. tls) will need to relax their upper bound on data-default-class.

lehins commented 4 weeks ago

Color, massiv-io and massiv-test are all fine, since they never had an upper bound and they'll work just fine with data-default-class-0.2

lehins commented 4 weeks ago

I hid my data-default-class bounds comment, though maybe it is still better for packages to drop it

@juhp It would be better for packages to drop it, but there are 330 direct dependencies. So, addition of data-default-class-0.2 makes it possible to drop it over a longer period of time, instead of forcing maintainers of those packages to make a change ASAP.

Maybe at some point deprecating data-default-class will raise more awareness and will lead to it eventually being dropped, but at least there is no immediate pressure.

debug-ito commented 3 weeks ago

I released fold-debounce-0.2.0.13. I switched to data-default.

adetokunbo commented 3 weeks ago

I released wai-middleware-delegate-0.2.0.0 The library no longer uses data-default, and the test-suite upper-bound allows data-default-0.8

adetokunbo commented 3 weeks ago

I released https://hackage.haskell.org/package/tmp-proc-0.7.2.0 which relaxes the upper-bound to allow data-default-0.8

mihaimaruseac commented 2 weeks ago

Current status:

data-default-0.8.0.0 (changelog) (Grandfathered dependencies) is out of bounds for:

[ ] HMock-0.5.1.2 (>=0.7.1 && < 0.8). Chris Smith cdsmith@gmail.com. Used by: library
[ ] aws-0.24.2 (>=0.5.3 && < 0.8). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] clash-lib-1.8.1 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). QBayLogic B.V. devops@qbaylogic.com @martijnbastiaan. Used by: library
[ ] copilot-theorem-4.0 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). Jens Petersen juhpetersen@gmail.com @juhp. Used by: library
[ ] falsify-0.2.0 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). Preetham Gujjula libraries@mail.preetham.io @pgujjula. Used by: library
[ ] hakyll-4.16.3.0 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). Jasper Van der Jeugt @jaspervdj & Laurent P. René de Cotret laurent.decotret@outlook.com @LaurentRDC. Used by: library
[ ] hoauth2-2.14.0 (^>=0.7). Haisheng Wu freizl@gmail.com @freizl. Used by: library
[ ] lsp-2.7.0.0 (^>=0.7). Michael Peyton Jones me@michaelpj.com. Used by: library
[ ] lsp-test-0.17.1.0 (^>=0.7). Michael Peyton Jones me@michaelpj.com. Used by: library
[ ] lsp-types-2.3.0.0 (^>=0.7). Michael Peyton Jones me@michaelpj.com. Used by: library
[ ] pandoc-3.5 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). John MacFarlane jgm@berkeley.edu @jgm. Used by: library
[ ] pandoc-lua-engine-0.3.3 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). Albert Krewinkel albert+stackage@zeitkraut.de @tarleb. Used by: library
[ ] pandoc-server-0.1.0.9 (>=0.4 && < 0.8). John MacFarlane jgm@berkeley.edu @jgm. Used by: library
[ ] run-haskell-module-0.0.2 (>=0.7 && < 0.8). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] strive-6.0.0.12 (^>=0.7.1.1). Taylor Fausak taylor@fausak.me @tfausak. Used by: library
[ ] threepenny-gui-0.9.4.1 (>=0.5.0 && < 0.8). Simon Jakobi simon.jakobi@gmail.com @sjakobi. Used by: library
[ ] wuss-2.0.2.0 (^>=0.7.1.1). Taylor Fausak taylor@fausak.me @tfausak. Used by: library

data-default-class-0.2.0.0 (changelog) (Grandfathered dependencies) is out of bounds for:

[ ] Chart-1.9.5 (< 0.2). Vitaly Bragilevsky vit.bragilevsky@gmail.com @bravit. Used by: library
[ ] Chart-cairo-1.9.4.1 (< 0.2). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] Chart-diagrams-1.9.5.1 (< 0.2). Vitaly Bragilevsky vit.bragilevsky@gmail.com @bravit. Used by: library
[ ] X11-1.10.3 (>=0.1 && < 0.2). xmonad xmonad@haskell.org. Used by: library
[ ] clash-prelude-1.8.1 (>=0.1.2 && < 0.2). QBayLogic B.V. devops@qbaylogic.com @martijnbastiaan. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-base-0.1.0.3 (^>=0.1.2.0). Edward Yang qwbarch@gmail.com @qwbarch. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-bytestring-0.0.1 (>=0.0 && < 0.1 || >=0.1 && < 0.2). Edward Yang qwbarch@gmail.com @qwbarch. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-case-insensitive-0.0.1 (>=0.0 && < 0.1 || >=0.1 && < 0.2). Edward Yang qwbarch@gmail.com @qwbarch. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-containers-0.1.0.3 (^>=0.1.2.0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-dlist-0.0.1.2 (^>=0.1.2.0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-old-locale-0.0.1.2 (^>=0.1.2.0). Grandfathered dependencies. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-unordered-containers-0.0.1 (>=0.0 && < 0.1 || >=0.1 && < 0.2). Edward Yang qwbarch@gmail.com @qwbarch. Used by: library
[ ] data-default-instances-vector-0.0.1 (>=0.0 && < 0.1 || >=0.1 && < 0.2). Edward Yang qwbarch@gmail.com @qwbarch. Used by: library
[ ] diagrams-cairo-1.4.2.1 (>=0.0.1 && < 0.2). Brent Yorgey byorgey@gmail.com @byorgey. Used by: library
[ ] dotenv-0.12.0.0 (>=0.1.2 && < 0.2). Stack Builders stackage@stackbuilders.com @stackbuilders. Used by: library
[ ] monad-chronicle-1.0.2 (>=0.1.2.0 && < 0.2). Clint Adams clint@debian.org @clinty. Used by: library
[ ] mysql-haskell-1.1.6 (>=0.1.2 && < 0.2). Winter Han winterland1989@gmail.com @winterland1989. Used by: library
[ ] servant-auth-server-0.4.9.0 (>=0.1.2.0 && < 0.2). Domen Kozar domen@enlambda.com @domenkozar. Used by: library
[ ] servant-quickcheck-0.1.1.0 (>=0.0 && < 0.2). Matt Parsons parsonsmatt@gmail.com @parsonsmatt. Used by: library