Closed mathisloge closed 4 years ago
Sorry Mathis, I must reject this pull request. There are many other CMake projects that use current scheme of integration. Your proposed changes will break many things.
Also maybe you should do support for the COMMS library only (-DCC_COMMS_LIB_ONLY=ON), don't do tools yet. We can always do it in the future as separate package. There is a thought that's been popping up in my head for quite a while now to split the "comms_champion" repository into two separate ones "libcomms" and "tools". There is a chance I'll do it in the future.
Hi Alex,
I dislike the idea of having absolute paths (BIN_INSTALL_DIR and PLUGIN_INSTALL_DIR). Why do yo need it absolute?
That was just my point of view. But of course, we can make the paths relative.
Why do you need to change the Qt5 path variable? What's wrong with CC_QT_DIR?
The Qt5_DIR
is the official way to set the path for qt. With that in mind all components that you will specify withfind_package(Qt5 COMPONENTS Widgets REQUIRED)
would be found.
So you don't need to write hardcoded variables like CC_QT_DIR + "/lib/"
etc.
As a reference for my decision:
I like the idea to seperate the library from the tools
I like the idea to separate the library from the tools
In such case I suppose no changes to CMake scripts are needed at this stage, right? If this is the case let's close this pull request for now.
Yep
These are mainly changes for vcpkg to make the whole qt finding process a bit more confortable. To use this outside of vcpkg, just pass
cmake -DQt5_DIR=/path/to/qt/lib/cmake/Qt5
I've added ${CMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX} to
BIN_INSTALL_DIR
andPLUGIN_INSTALL_DIR
since the ${CMAKE_INSTALL_BINDIR} just includes a relative path and the windeploy might not find that path if it is outside of the current directory. WithCMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX
it will be the correct install path