search

confluentinc / cp-docker-images

[DEPRECATED] Docker images for Confluent Platform.
Apache License 2.0
1.14k stars 705 forks source link

!! Leader Election Issue in Schema Registry, On leader deletion. #926

Open Shivam0609 opened 1 year ago

Shivam0609 commented 1 year ago

Problem Description :

When running multiple replicas of Schema registry for HA, 1 pod is elected as leader while other are workers. When we are deleting leader pod then it is electing one of the other pod as a new leader. But when new pod scales up , again new pod is elected as leader which causes few seconds of downtime and results in failure of schemas creation while rebalancing. Seems rebalancing is happenning twice.

Expected behaviour :

When running in HA , i.e, multiple replicas of schema registry. Deleting leader pod should elect new leader only once and process further requests without switching leader untill it's deleted again.

Steps to Reproduce :

  1. Run multiple replicas of Schema registry using Deployent/Statefulset.
  2. Delete leader pod and immediately create multiple schemas.
  3. Failure is observed for some of the schemas creation.

Logs

kubectl get po -n kafka -o wide
NAME                        READY   STATUS     IP        
cp-schema-registry-0        1/1     Running    10.0.7.153
cp-schema-registry-1        1/1     Running    10.0.8.175
cp-schema-registry-2        1/1     Running    10.0.32.182 (Current Leader)

kubectl logs cp-schema-registry-0 -n kafka | grep leader
[2023-01-12 06:41:55,177] INFO Finished rebalance with leader election result: Assignment{version=1, error=0, leader='sr-1-6f6c7d7c-e739-400b-9904-620bc282350c', leaderIdentity=version=1,host=10.0.32.182,port=8081,scheme=http,leaderEligibility=true} (io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.leaderelector.kafka.KafkaGroupLeaderElector)

Deleted Leader Pod, New pod scales up with ip (10.0.36.86)

kubectl get po -n kafka -o wide
NAME                        READY   STATUS    RESTARTS   AGE     IP        
cp-schema-registry-0        1/1     Running   0          21h     10.0.7.153
cp-schema-registry-1        1/1     Running   0          6m39s   10.0.8.175
cp-schema-registry-2        1/1     Running   0          36s     10.0.36.86

Logs for leader election

[2023-01-12 06:40:55,135] INFO Rebalance started (io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.leaderelector.kafka.KafkaGroupLeaderElector)
[2023-01-12 06:41:55,177] INFO Finished rebalance with leader election result: Assignment{version=1, error=0, leader='sr-1-6f6c7d7c-e739-400b-9904-620bc282350c', leaderIdentity=version=1,host=10.0.32.182,port=8081,scheme=http,leaderEligibility=true} (io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.leaderelector.kafka.KafkaGroupLeaderElector)
.....
..
.
Caused by: io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.exceptions.UnknownLeaderException: Register schema request failed since leader is unknown
....
..
###### form below you can see existing pod is elected as leader (10.0.7.153- cp-schema-registry-0)
io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.rest.exceptions.RestRequestForwardingException: Error while forwarding register schema request to the leader
[2023-01-12 06:44:25,188] INFO Rebalance started (io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.leaderelector.kafka.KafkaGroupLeaderElector)
[2023-01-12 06:44:25,216] INFO Finished rebalance with leader election result: Assignment{version=1, error=0, leader='sr-1-a5c21494-c85b-4296-9471-7e7c523c3178', leaderIdentity=version=1,host=10.0.7.153,port=8081,scheme=http,leaderEligibility=true} (io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.leaderelector.kafka.KafkaGroupLeaderElector)
....
..
.
##### Once new pod is up and running again rebalancing happened (10.0.36.86- cp-schema-registry-2) is elected as leader
[2023-01-12 06:44:46,213] INFO Rebalance started (io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.leaderelector.kafka.KafkaGroupLeaderElector)
[2023-01-12 06:44:46,218] INFO Finished rebalance with leader election result: Assignment{version=1, error=0, leader='sr-1-bf1e2a4d-a3f0-4817-a856-87cd1aaab60d', leaderIdentity=version=1,host=10.0.36.86,port=8081,scheme=http,leaderEligibility=true} (io.confluent.kafka.schemaregistry.leaderelector.kafka.KafkaGroupLeaderElector)
...
..
.

Sometime leader is not even gets elected until new pod is up and running.

Additional Information :

Image Used : 6.2.5

Kubernetes cluster : AWS EKS

Kubernetes version :

root:~ kubectl version --short

Client Version: v1.23.9
Server Version: v1.23.13-eks-fb459a0
Shivam0609 commented 1 year ago

Any update on this issue.