Importing API Keys does not work using Crossplane

[andrewjc03]

Hi,

I am running into issues when importing API Keys via a Crossplane composition (which uses this provider). From what I understand this is the way to import API Keys:

$ export CONFLUENT_CLOUD_API_KEY="<cloud_api_key>"
$ export CONFLUENT_CLOUD_API_SECRET="<cloud_api_secret>"
$ export API_KEY_SECRET="<api_key_secret>"

# Option #1: Cluster API Key
$ terraform import confluent_api_key.example_kafka_api_key "env-abc123/UTT6WDRXX7FHD2GV"

However, when I try to import API Keys in Crossplane it does not work because the API_KEY_SECRET needs to be set as an environment variable. The issue is that this variable get only be set once in the DeploymentRuntimeConfig of the confluent provider (https://github.com/crossplane-contrib/provider-confluent), which means that if there are multiple keys there is no way to have a separate variable for each one.

Do you know if there is a workaround for this, so that I will be able to import multiple API Key resources successfully? Or if possible can the capability for multiple API_KEY_SECRET environment variables be added, one for each API Key?

Any help would be appreciated on this!

Thank you, Andrew

[linouk23]

Thanks for creating this issue @andrewjc03!

Do you know if there is a workaround for this, so that I will be able to import multiple API Key resources successfully? Or if possible can the capability for multiple API_KEY_SECRET environment variables be added, one for each API Key?

We don't know about such a workaround yet, but we'll think about it.

As a short term workaround, we'd probably recommend to create new API Keys instead.

[andrewjc03]

Got it, thank you @linouk23! Please let me know if there is anything I can do to help if you proceed with adding this feature!

Thanks, Andrew

[andrewjc03]

Hey @linouk23,

I just realized that I won't be able to create new API Keys since I am doing a migration from previous Terraform infrastructure and I am required to use the existing API Keys. 😔

To help with the development process, would you be open to accepting an outside contribution / discussion for this or is this discussion private to existing confluent contributors? I was thinking that with an open discussion with the open source community, we can all come together and think of a way to solve this issue.

Please let me know your thoughts on this!

With gratitude, Andrew

[linouk23]

To help with the development process, would you be open to accepting an outside contribution / discussion for this. <> I was thinking that with an open discussion with the open source community, we can all come together and think of a way to solve this issue.

Sure thing!

[tarciosaraiva]

I'm interested in this from a different point of view: terraform has been supporting import blocks since v1.5 and although marked as experimental it is a nice add to their configuration language as it reduces the amount of cli commands required.

Having a dependency on an environment variable kinda limits that because we could be using a data block to read the secret from a secret store and populate the key appropriately in the imported resouce.

Any chance this could be looked into?

[linouk23]

@tarciosaraiva, could you open a separate issue for your request? I'm not 100% sure, but I suspect yours might be a bit easier to implement? Thank you!