consumer-reports-innovation-lab / data-rights-protocol

The technical standard for exchanging data rights requests
https://datarightsprotocol.org
Apache License 2.0
58 stars 12 forks source link

resolve language around "legal basis" #7

Closed rrix closed 2 years ago

rrix commented 2 years ago

Feedback on 0.3: Re "legal basis" - this may be confusing due to other meaning under GDPR. Perhaps "Regime"? ALSO, is it right to encode this in each request given the ultimate answer may be hard to know conclusively at the start? EG when requests exist under more than one legal regime? Is this better characterized as an educated guess by AA (eg make it explicitly non-binding and optional to parse)? One AA captures country or region but does not characterize applicable legal regime, however providing this as a hint if it's non-binding could be beneficial - main thing is including subject's physical residential address and country of origin. ESPECIALLY useful to have verified claim from AA of address as per section 3.0.4 of V.0.3. Also, region may be best proxy. At testing phase ask if this is a helpful info value. (see: https://openid.net/specs/openid-connect-core-1_0.html#Claims)

bencmbrook commented 2 years ago

Awesome! Couple thoughts on enumerating regimes by their acronyms:

This isn't a huge deal right now so happy to punt on this for the time being.