Building or Running a Service Fails Without Explicit Profile

[VerKWer]

Describe the bug In our compose.yml files, we make active use of profiles to group services together. It it my understanding, that proper profiles support was just recently added to podman-compose, and the newest release (1.1.0) seems to break a bunch of things because of that.

More precisely, if a service has an associated profile, building or running it doesn't seem to work without explicitly specifying a profile that service belongs to. For example, if a service test has profiles: [test_profile], then calling podman-compose build test fails and podman-compose --profile test_profile build test seems to be required.

On the other hand, using docker compose, one doesn't need to specify a profile, and I believe that that's the correct behaviour. Quoting from the spec concerning profiles:

A service is ignored by Compose when none of the listed profiles match the active ones, unless the service is explicitly targeted by a command. In that case its profile is added to the set of active profiles.

The way I interpret this, calling podman-compose build test does explicitly target the test service and specifying the profile should not be necessary.

This happens on both the released version 1.1.0, as well as the latest version in the main branch.

To Reproduce

1. Create a Dockerfile and a compose.yml file setting up a single, minimal service that has an assigned profile.

   • Dockerfile:

     FROM docker.io/library/alpine:latest
     CMD [ "true" ]

   • compose.yml:

     services:
       test:
         image: test:latest
         profiles: [test_profile]
         build:
           context: .
           dockerfile: Dockerfile

2. Try to build the service:

   $ podman-compose build test
   WARNING:podman_compose:missing services [test]

   However, when explicitly specifying a profile as in podman-compose --profile test_profile build test, it works.

3. Similarly, running the service without an explicitly set profile (i.e. podman-compose run test) also fails. If the profile is specified, everything works as expected.

Expected behavior Building or running a service should be possible without explicitly specifying a profile that service is associated with.

Actual behavior The service is not correctly identified, presumably because none of its listed profiles is active.

Output

$ podman-compose version
podman-compose version 1.1.0
podman version 4.9.4

Environment:

• OS: Linux