Use of logrus causes incorrect use of stdout and stderr

[juur]

Logrus appears to have an unresolved (and because logrus is in maintenance mode, will never be resolved) standard way of handling different logging levels going to stdout vs. stderr. As there is also no-way to set the log level and/or engage silent mode, this makes it hard to have fairly-silent scripts that only output on error.

It's not correct behaviour to redirect stdout to /dev/null and get INFO messages printed, really.

There are a few suggestions I can think of:

• Have two different loggers, one for stdout and one for stderr, and use the correct.
• Switch to a different Go logging framework that solves this problem
• Introduce a --log-level option and/or a --silent option to set the logging level to WARN

[mtrmac]

Thanks for the report.

A fairly large stack of dependencies uses logrus; so switching a framework wouldn’t be a simple Skopeo change. It’s an option, in principle, but it’s a fairly hard sell — to my knowledge we don’t have a large set of issues that would motivate such a large-scale work.

For the same reason, having two different loggers isn‘t really possible.

The --log-level option has a precedent in Podman, so that seems the easiest way to handle this.

[github-actions[bot]]

A friendly reminder that this issue had no activity for 30 days.