conveyal / analyst-server

DEPRECATED; see https://github.com/conveyal/analysis-ui
MIT License
37 stars 6 forks source link

Increasing bike distance causes decreases in accessibility #213

Open mattwigway opened 8 years ago

mattwigway commented 8 years ago

image

That probably shouldn't happen.

mattwigway commented 8 years ago

The same issue and basically the same spatial pattern shows up on walk accessibility.

mattwigway commented 8 years ago

Interestingly, there is a frequency-based transit line along Blue Hill Avenue, which is the center of that image.

mattwigway commented 8 years ago

Ah, and frequency-based lines are boarded using a monte carlo simulation, so random variation between runs is not unexpected - the variation is small here (we're talking about changes of access to a few hundred jobs out of the entire Boston job market). Retrying without frequency-based lines, which should be deterministic.

mattwigway commented 8 years ago

Without the frequency service, increasing the walk distance causes three decreases in accessibility in Boston. Of course it shouldn't cause any, but that's a lot better than it was.

mattwigway commented 8 years ago

For bike distance, it's perfectly clean.