Upload speed limit not working

[xewonder]

Hi,

I am using Openwrt 14.07 and now Coova-chilli 1.3.2.

I could NEVER (ffrom coova-chilli 1.2.9 upwards) get the upload speed limit working. Download speed limit is ok.

Any reason and quick fix?

Thank you in advance.

[gbaligh]

Hi,

Could you check the chilli_query list result for the max-bandwidth-up and max-bandwidth-down ?

[nzamps]

Try the command in:

https://github.com/coova/coova-chilli/issues/256

[xewonder]

Hi @gbaligh

Not sure if I have done it right.

root@OpenWrt:# chilli_query list maxbwdown 5849d15e00000002 00-74-00-5F-08-CD 10.1.0.2 pass 5849d23000000002 1 dd 14/60 14/0 0/0 0/0 0 0 0%/0 0%/0 - 78-A3-51-11-E7-5D 10.1.0.3 dnat 5849ce3800000001 0 - 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0 0 0/0 0/0 - root@OpenWrt:# chilli_query list maxbwup 5849d15e00000002 00-74-00-5F-08-CD 10.1.0.2 pass 5849d23000000002 1 dd 34/60 34/0 0/0 0/0 0 0 0%/0 0%/0 - 78-A3-51-11-E7-5D 10.1.0.3 dnat 5849ce3800000001 0 - 0/0 0/0 0/0 0/0 0 0 0/0 0/0 - root@OpenWrt:#

@nzamps

Not sure it's the same problem.... I am trying to throttole the bandwidth. My max-bandwidth-up limit is not being enforced.

[gbaligh]

According to that, the bandwidthmaxup is not configured :

00-74-00-5F-08-CD 10.1.0.2 pass 5849d23000000002 1 dd 34/60 34/0 0/0 0/0 0 0 0%/0 0%/0 - bandwidthmaxup = 0 bandwidthmaxdown = 0

to set a bandwidthmaxup, try execute the command :

root@OpenWrt:~# chilli_query update mac 00-74-00-5F-08-CD maxbwup 1024

Then check it using

root@OpenWrt:~# chilli_query list

Normally, you'll get: 00-74-00-5F-08-CD 10.1.0.2 pass 5849d23000000002 1 dd 14/60 14/0 0/0 0/0 0 0 0%/1024 0%/0 -

[xewonder]

hi @gbaligh thank you.

i did a query on a live user... and it shows what you are saying... sould be 1024 down, 512 up.

E8-50-8B-1D-F7-F6 10.1.0.3 pass 5849f2dc00000002 1 connect@inpiedicafe 377/0 2/300 6550371/0 3985448/0 74762698 0 0%/512000 0%/1024000 http://portal.fb.com/mobile/status.php

But speed test shows 1.14Mbps down and 4.61Mbps up.

Down always stasys on the 1mbps mark where up takes up the whole bandwidth.

Lookse like my issue is like #10

[gbaligh]

So, you need to try what @nzamps suggested, disabling TSO and GSO may resolve your problem. Those services give ability to handle more packets without CPU usage and without the knowledge of kernel.

[jobezic]

@nzamps Can you submit a pull request to solve the issue in chilli ?

[nzamps]

Not much chilli can do about TSO or GSO - a TSO/GSO capable network adapter allows the kernel to assemble large packets for sending at a level chilli has no control over. Only way is to disable TSO/GSO so chilli can "see" each packet.

[xewonder]

Just in case..

Make sure that your interface is not bridged with another.

My WiFi was bridged with the LAN card.. once I took that off both up and down speeds were observed!

[sergencolak]

@xewonder Hi, I use coovachilli and freeradius. I have identified a user. Speeds 1Mbps Download 1Mbps Upload. The download speed is 1MB when user login is done. But upload speed is 4Mbps. I can not restrict. How can I solve the problem. Thank you

[xewonder]

Make sure your WiFi interface is not bridged! That was my problem.

---

Best regards Denis Dorigo

(sent from mobile device)

On 29 January 2018 4:04:55 pm sergencolak notifications@github.com wrote:

@xewonder Hi, I use coovachilli and freeradius. I have identified a user. Speeds 1Mbps Download 1Mbps Upload. The download speed is 1MB when user login is done. But upload speed is 4Mbps. I can not restrict. How can I solve the problem. Thank you

-- You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/coova/coova-chilli/issues/317#issuecomment-361254712