Fix details on figures - Githubissues

coreytcallaghan / Oikos_oik.06158

An analysis of adaptation of urban living in Australian birds

0 stars 0 forks source link

Fix details on figures #51

Closed wcornwell closed 6 years ago

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

By this you mean adding the 'line drawings' or something of the like, correct?

Or other details as well?

I have a student from AFB currently working on these.

wcornwell commented 6 years ago

yeah probably can make a list:

Figure 1 could fix the x-axis so it has real units scale_x_log10()
Figure 2 could fix the x-axis so it has real units scale_x_log10()
Figure 3 fix legend and add line drawings (illustrator)

any others?

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

Cool. For Figure 2, I have the lines on there to represent species, just to give an idea of where birds fell out in the distribution.

Think it is necessary?

I could include these photos as insets, or just present the distribution? The idea of including species gives more credence to the notion of an 'index' I think....?

This was my slide for the talk I gave most recently:

capture

wcornwell commented 6 years ago

yes i think that would be cool.

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

Figure2.pdf

How does this display on your computer? Thoughts?

wcornwell commented 6 years ago

well it's 17 MB which might be overkill but looks good. can take the "log" off the x-axis now and maybe add units?

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

Yeah, it is a lot bigger, but not sure whether to worry about it or not. I don't have much skills with all the illustrator stuff.

Probably worry about that later, maybe?

We wouldn't really have units for our urbanization index though?

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

pushed a customized figure.

For Figure 3 (Phylo tree), what does the "length=100" mean on the legend?

wcornwell commented 6 years ago

It's the length of the color vector. should be deleted.

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

Figure3.pdf

About 1/2 way there. Will get the rest of the drawings from her tomorrow, hopefully.

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

What do y'all think?

capture

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

Should I add scientific names to each species? Might make it a little more messy.... I'm not sure.

johnWilshire commented 6 years ago

Looks good! I think the tree image has been extra compressed though I think names would be helpful as well

On Wed, May 23, 2018 at 2:33 PM, Corey Callaghan notifications@github.com wrote:

What do y'all think?

[image: capture] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/28123686/40403605-3204c354-5e96-11e8-8d1b-685c6a20bae7.PNG

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/cornwell-lab-unsw/bird_urbanness/issues/51#issuecomment-391217161, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABpvalOFLKqFXqeT5YCCq9gpKCnIWAylks5t1OaBgaJpZM4UAgOl .

-- John Wilshire - johnwilshire.github.io

wcornwell commented 6 years ago

looks great! arrows and names are good i think

coreytcallaghan commented 6 years ago

I added names, but arrows make it look a little too busy I think. Plus, because the bars are all different heights it makes the arrows more difficult to add (if that makes sense).

I'm closing this for now, but realizing that we'll still have to edit the figure captions as part of the polishing process of the manuscript.

Plus, need to figure out #58 still too.