search

corona-warn-app / cwa-app-android

Native Android app using the Apple/Google exposure notification API. The CWA development ends on May 31, 2023. You still can warn other users until April 30, 2023. More information:
https://coronawarn.app/en/faq/#ramp_down
Apache License 2.0
2.44k stars 495 forks source link

Android - Prioritised background activity - PRIORISIERTE HINTERGRUNDAKTIVITÄTEN - cannot be activated or deactivates itself #1884

Open dsarkar opened 3 years ago

dsarkar commented 3 years ago

We have some reports from the app stores, that the prioritized background activity (PRIORISIERTE HINTERGRUNDAKTIVITÄTEN) cannot be activated (case 1) or deactivates itself (case 2) on their ANDROID devices. We would appreciate some feedback here from the community. Thank you very much. Best wishes, DS

Corona-Warn-App Open Source Team

Environment:

Preconditions:

CASE 1: Prioritized Background activity cannot be turned on anymore

Steps:

Expected result:

Actual Result:

Reported cases:

CASE 2: Prioritized Background will be disabled automatically

Steps:

Expected result:

Actual Result:

Reported cases:

Related issues:

MikeMcC399 commented 3 years ago

@dsarkar

We have some reports from the app stores, that the prioritized background activity (PRIORISIERTE HINTERGRUNDAKTIVITÄTEN) cannot be activated or deactivates itself.

Can you share any data about which particular makes / models of smartphones are affected according to the Google Play Store feedback so far?

dsarkar commented 3 years ago

Edited first post with more details. DS.

MikeMcC399 commented 3 years ago

With Samsung Galaxy A50 SM-A505FN / Android 10 / CWA 1.7.1 I was able to disable and enable Prioritized Background Activity successfully. I don't recall the device spontaneously enabling optimised battery usage and exposure checks have been working without issue for quite some time.

I find the experience confusing though because of the use of the terms which are defined logically opposite to each other in CWA compared to the Android operating system.

Prioritized Background Activity on = optimised battery usage off Prioritized Background Activity off = optimised battery usage on

The text "You can activate and deactivate prioritized background activity in your device settings." is not literally true. I can activate and deactivate optimised battery usage in my device settings.

Start out with Prioritized Background Activity (off) = optimised battery usage (on)

Enable Prioritized Background Activity

CWA > Settings > Prioritized Background Activity > OPEN DEVICE SETTINGS shows Optimise battery usage with filter "Apps not optimised" so now I have to change the filter to "All" so I can find Corona-Warn which is showing enabled = optimised battery usage on. Now I tap Corona-Warn which disables it = optimised battery usage off. Go back to CWA which correctly shows "Prioritized Background Activity" On.

Disable Prioritized Background Activity

CWA > Settings > Prioritized Background Activity > OPEN DEVICE SETTINGS shows Optimise battery usage with filter "Apps not optimised" Corona-Warn shows disabled = optimised battery usage off So now I have three logical states to keep in my head: Optimise / filter not optimised / switch off (which applies of course to the heading "Optimise battery usage" and not to the filter "Apps not optimised"). Now I tap Corona-Warn which immediately removes it from the filtered list without showing it in enabled optimised battery status. I change the filter from "Apps not optimised" to "All" and find Corona-Warn enabled in the list. Go back to CWA which correctly shows "Prioritized Background Activity" On

I can think of better user experiences than this! 😱

dsarkar commented 3 years ago

Related issues: Improve UX for disabling battery optimization - Internal Tracking ID: EXPOSUREAPP-3835

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

I'm also experiencing case 2 problems on a on a oneplus 3t with Android 9 (stock). After turning on the prioritized background activity it turns itself off after a few days. Any solution yet?

MikeMcC399 commented 3 years ago

@raptor321 Are you using the latest version of the app (1.10.1)? At least on my Samsung Galaxy, selecting Prioritized Background Activity in the app doesn't actually switch it on, it just allows you to use Android's settings to select the app and disable the optimised battery usage settings yourself. I assume that is what you are doing.

It might be helpful to see some screen shots from your device battery settings. The battery optimisation is very device specific, and if it is getting reset, it is more likely to be due to the device and not due to the CWA app.

I found one mention in the https://forums.oneplus.com/threads/battery-optimization-settings-are-reset-for-some-apps.769615/ for a beta software where the device was resetting optimisation settings. It's an old post, but it does describe the problem.

dsarkar commented 3 years ago

@raptor321 as @MikeMcC399 suggests:

Many thanks, DS

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

Hi and sorry that it took me some time. It's like @MikeMcC399 suggests. By clicking on prioritized background activity the phone changes in the battery optimization settings. I have to change from "not optimized" to "all apps" and change the cwa app manually to not optimize. The problem is that it resets after some time. I couldn't figure out if there is a certain time period or if anything else triggers a reset. Since you asked im using cwa v1.10.1 Screenshots are attached Screenshot_20210121-232608 Screenshot_20210121-232649 Screenshot_20210121-232656

MikeMcC399 commented 3 years ago

@raptor321 It's good to see the screen shots which look like the Google Pixel 3a with Android 11.

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

@MikeMcC399 oneplus delivers a very clean android. Sadly the device is older then four years is not longer supported by the manufacturer. So there are no more updates. I turned off the prioritized background activity and will check if it still does checks or if I get a warning.

MikeMcC399 commented 3 years ago

@raptor321

Sadly the device is older then four years is not longer supported by the manufacturer. So there are no more updates.

That is a pity, because I think the issue about battery optimisation being reset could only be fixed by the device vendor.

I turned off the prioritized background activity and will check if it still does checks or if I get a warning.

I'm also doing a test on a Samsung device with all possible battery optimisation enabled (so worst case for CWA) and I should have the results in 36 hours.

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

After a test I got no warning after more then 36 Hours, BUT: the exposure checks are still being done. I checked at 11pm and the last check was at 12:29am. So I think it doesn't check as often as it could, but it still does!

dsarkar commented 3 years ago

@raptor321 Thank you for your observations. We have added your information to the developer's ticket. Best, DS

heinezen commented 3 years ago

Hello everyone,

This might be fixed in CWA release 2.2. Please retest after the update.

Corona-Warn-App Open Source Team

MikeMcC399 commented 3 years ago

It would be good to hear back from users who were having specific problems with the Prioritized Background Activity function, about whether their experience has improved with the new 2.2.1 release.

I checked I could enable and disable Prioritized Background Activity in the new CWA Android version 2.2.1 on my Samsung Galaxy A50, Android 11. I wasn't previously having any technical issues on this device though. The only usability issue remaining for me is the complexity of the user interface, for which there is still a wishlist item open https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-app-android/issues/1884.

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

I'm using v2.2 since Monday. I enabled prioritized background activity and it did not turn off till then. I will try not open the app for a few days and check back if anything has changed.

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

One week of using, 5 days without opening the app and its still working! Seems like the problem is solved. If anything changes I will report again.

dsarkar commented 3 years ago

@raptor321 Thank you very much for your feedback! Best, DS

Corona-Warn-App Open Source Team

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

Round and round it goes... I'm very sorry, but as I opened the app today, the prioritized background activity was deactivated again... The app is on v2.2.1. According to the play store the last update was two weeks ago. I open the app 1-2 times a week. I did not change any settings.

heinezen commented 3 years ago

@raptor321 Thanks for notifying us.

We suspect that the problem might be vendor-specific in some cases, which unfortunately would mean that this cannot be fixed by the CWA team. The OS of some vendors will override the prioritized background settings after a while, even if they were manually set. The way to fix this would have to be a firmware update.

Corona-Warn-App Open Source Team

raptor321 commented 3 years ago

Maybe that's my problem. Oneplus is not offering further firmware updates. But I wanted to notify anyway.