Closed dsarkar closed 3 years ago
Hey @dsarkar
Thanks for creating this issue. What do you prefer, should we only give content feedback here or also feedback reg. spelling?
First point, before I give any feedback, we have many things that are already in https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/coronavirus/faq-covid-19-impfung/faq-digitaler-impfnachweis.html. The only advantage of our FAQ would be an English version.
Do we really need all this in the CWA's FAQ? Probably this was decided like this internally, or? What does the community think (@MikeMcC399?)
@Ein-Tim Any feedback is most welcome! Indeed, BGM material was partly recycled here. At this stage we would try to cover many important questions here in the CWA project in both DE and EN. If at a later stage there is the need/wish to publish on one single point the different FAQs, then shall it be.
We are all open ears, about removing questions, other Q&As, changing order, content, merging (e.g. several devices, several apps, backups, change device questions basically have all the same answer).
I agree, in the first part (intro) there is a lot to remove.
Internal Tracking ID: EXPOSUREAPP-7014
Thanks for opening this here and asking the community for feedback @dsarkar!
Deutschland wird diese europäische Entscheidung nun schnell umsetzen, um allen Bürgern, die dies wünschen, einen digitalen Impfnachweis zur Verfügung stellen zu können.
Will this FAQ be published before the feature is released? Otherwise, the tense needs to be changed.
Ob Sie mit einem vollständigen Impfschutz beispielsweise reisen dürfen, hängt von den Bestimmungen des jeweiligen Landes ab.
Maybe we could find a resource which provides further information here?
Wer kann einen elektronischen Impfnachweis erhalten? Wie erhalte ich ein Impfzertifikat?
Wie kann ich, wenn ich bereits vollständigen Impfschutz haben, den Status nachträglich in die Corona-Warn-App übertragen?
These two questions have very similar answers and should be merged. It is also partially overlapping with the question "Wie funktioniert der digitale Impfnachweis?".
I think the latter question should be the third question after "Was ist…?" and "Warum gibt es…?", and then more questions could provide further details. You should know how it works before being told how to receive it.
Wirkt sich der Impfstatus auf die Berechnung des Risikos aus? Beispielsweise, wenn eine geimpfte Person sich infiziert haben sollte und dann andere Nutzer*innen warnt? Nein, im Moment wird in der Risikoberechnung nicht berücksichtig, ob Sie gegen Corona geimpft oder genesen sind.
Maybe it would be good to add more explanation here: the features are independent of each other. The quality of your risk assessment does not change depending on whether or not you choose to store your vaccination certificate in the application, underlining the fact that this is completely voluntary. However, your personal status may influence how you interpret the warning.
Wie sollte man sich verhalten, wenn man teil- oder vollständig geimpft ist, aber eine rote Warnung in der Corona-Warn-App erhält? Handlungsempfehlung: Wenn eine geimpfte Person als enge Kontakt-Person eingestuft wird, ist zunächst keine Quarantäne (aber eigenes Monitoring) nötig, solange keine Symptome auftreten. Sollten doch Symptomen auftreten, sollten Sie sich unmittelbar testen lassen und in sofort Quarantäne begeben.
It would be helpful to add the detail that you can always get tested if you want to be safe. What does "eigenes Monitoring" mean?
Related: https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-wishlist/issues/457 → also add this advice to the app
- wie in der analogen Welt auch –
You used two different dashes here. '–' is the correct one.
Wie wird dabei sichergestellt, dass die Informationen aus dem gelben Impfheft, bzw. das digitale Impfzertifikat echt und nicht gefälscht sind? Bei der Prüfung der analogen Impfpässe ist besondere Vorsicht geboten ist. Das gilt sowohl dann, wenn der analoge Impfpass genutzt wird, um z. B. Geschäfte zu betreten. Und es gilt auch dann, wenn die Informationen von dem analogen in einen digitalen Impfpass übertragen werden. Die Fälschung von Impfpässen ist strafbewehrt. Das gilt für analoge wie für digitale Impfdokumente.
This question is not needed in my opinion. The answer boils down to "the pass needs to be checked carefully, also forgery is a crime", which is does not actually answer the question what makes the analog pass safe. It also does not answer the question about what makes the digital certificate safe (because this is already answered in the next question).
@fynngodau Many thanks for your feedback, very much appreciated! I adopted basically almost all of your suggestions. Thanks.
Sometimes you use Corona-Warn-App, sometimes only CWA. This should be consistent. I also found some typos. Will you provide a PR? Then it's easier to mark them😆
@fynngodau mentioned quite all my points, I only suggest to capitalise "ihr/e" & "sie", etc.
@dsarkar Thank you for considering my feedback! I have a few more items now:
You are using the term "2D barcode" throughout the FAQ. This is a rather technical term that most users are probably not familiar with. It is also currently not used in the FAQ document. I'd suggest to use the more familiar term "QR code" directly.
No, do not take into account in the risk calculation whether you are vaccinated against or recovered from a corona infection.
I think you mixed up the grammar here. You probably meant to say: "No, the app does not take into account in the risk calculation […]", or even better: "No, the risk calculation in the app does not take into account […]".
How to prevent abuse?
Similarly, here, you probably meant: "How is abuse being prevented?"
Nein, in der Risikoberechnung wird nicht berücksichtig, ob Sie gegen Corona geimpft oder genesen sind. Die Funktionen sind voneinander unabhängig. Die Qualität Ihrer Risikobewertung ändert sich nicht, je nachdem, ob Sie Sich dafür entscheiden, Ihren Impfausweis in der Anwendung zu speichern, was unterstreicht, dass dies völlig freiwillig ist. Ihr persönlicher Impfstatus kann jedoch Ihre Interpretation der Risiko-Warnung beeinflussen.
I didn't mean this suggestion literally, rather as an idea for what points it could mention. The reason is that what I suggested can still be read with the negative spin that both are intentionally equally bad. I thought about it further and came up with a refined suggestion: "[…] Die Funktionen sind unabhängig voneinander – wenn Sie sich entscheiden, Ihren Impfausweis nicht in der Anwendung zu speichern, wird dadurch die Genauigkeit Ihrer Risikobewertung nicht verschlechtert. […]"
Will my data be removed from the Corona-Warn-App when I remove the vaccination certificate?
This question is a bit pointless. Why would a user think that this is not the case?
Ist das Impfzertifikat in meinem Backup enthalten?
This question is not directly answered in the block that follows it. One option would be to remove it here and integrate it with the backup
FAQ.
Then, the backup
FAQ should be updated to reflect this information, and to also address the other features of the app (contact journal etc.). It should also explain that this is done to ensure that the sensitive data that the Corona-Warn-App stores doesn't leave the device.
Reg.: "vaccination_certificate_multiple_scan_possible" please see: https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-website/pull/1312#pullrequestreview-671773415
@DerVogel2020 Thanks for having a look at this. I will provide PR later today. In an FAQ article we use Corona-Warn-App (CWA) the first time, and later within the same article CWA.
@Ein-Tim ok, thanks.
I think a FAQ entry reg. the validity time would be good. See https://github.com/ehn-digital-green-development/hcert-spec/blob/main/hcert_spec.md#61-hcert-signature-validity-time
EDIT: In fact, first I'd like to know what happens to the vaccination certificate in CWA, so I opened: https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-documentation/issues/627
PR https://github.com/corona-warn-app/cwa-website/pull/1313 has been merged with release 2.3
Disclaimer: This is a preliminary version. Content still has to be verified and approved.
Edited:
Q&A - Basic information/Introduction
Q&A - Risk calculation/warnings
Q&A - several apps/change device/backup/several certificates
How can I transfer the vaccination certificate when changing device? What do I do if I lose my phone? Will the vaccination certificate be included in my backup? Can I manage the certificate in the Corona-Warn-App and the CovPass-App at the same time, or do I have to choose one of the two apps? There is no limit to how often you scan the 2D barcode (QR code) of your vaccination certificates. You can add and manage the vaccination certificates on multiple devices, on a new device, on a device you have reset, and even in several apps. Therefore, a backup is not required.
Q&A - DATENSCHUTZ/PRIVATSPHÄRE/Sicherheit
Q&A - Technical details