search

cose-wg / cose-issues

COSE Working Group Issues
0 stars 1 forks source link

Acknowledgements Missing #25

Closed selfissued closed 8 years ago

selfissued commented 9 years ago

Please add an Acknowledgements section acknowledging by name those who have made significant contributions to the specification.

jimsch commented 9 years ago

Parked until the document is finished

selfissued commented 8 years ago

While an Acknowledgements section has been added, all it says is "This document is a product of the COSE working group of the IETF." This does not satisfy the intent of having an Acknowledgments section, which is to acknowledge by name those who have made significant contributions to the specification. This is not only a standard practice and a common courtesy - it's the right thing to do.

Until this is done, it is incorrect to categorize this issue as "complete".

jricher commented 8 years ago

The section has been created, and it's up to the editor how to list the acknowledgements as they see fit (within reason). That said, during WGLC we will work with the editor to make sure the appropriate acknowledgement is given in the final document.

Closing this issue.