search

cosmos / ledger-cosmos-obsolete

Ledger Nano S support for Tendermint/Cosmos
Apache License 2.0
42 stars 29 forks source link

Cannot sign in with Ledger devices in win10 may 2019 update + chrome #157

Closed jleni closed 4 years ago

jleni commented 5 years ago

Copying over https://github.com/luniehq/lunie/issues/2754 opened by @williamchong007 to simplify tracking.

Describe the bug I am using ledger nano S to sign in on windows 10 may 2019 update (version 1903 build 18362.175). After clicking sign in with ledger, Windows Security popup (the new native FIDO U2F from Microsoft i suppose) keep on popup up and automatically closing itself for a while. After the popup flashing stops and I accepted login on ledger, I got stuck with an error screen in the windows security popup. Closing the window and retrying sign in yields either another error popup or getting stuck with Take action on your security key , while ledger is stuck in Returning Address...

To Reproduce

  1. Go to lunie and try sign in with ledger. Click the signin button with ledger connected and cosmo app open.
  2. Get a lot of "Windows security" popup on and off flashing the screen. Wait until it stop and a prompt appears on ledger.
  3. Click accept button on ledger.
  4. See an error screen in the Windows Security popup. Ledger stuck in Returning Address.

Expected behavior Only 1 popup of Windows security asking me to press button should appear, I should be about to login after I press accept on ledger.

Screenshots After the "Windows Security" popup flashing decided to stop 1 After pressing accept on ledger: image Result: 3

Desktop (please complete the following information):

  • OS: Windows 10 (version 1903 build 18362.175)
  • Browser: Chrome
  • Version: 75.0.3770.100

The issue has been reproduced and affects browsers running Windows 10 v1903 (and upwards). The U2F transport has been affected by this upgrade.

HID and WebUSB transports are not affected. Unfortunately, Windows 10 does not support WebUSB (unless drivers are manually installed).

Current workarounds / alternatives

jleni commented 4 years ago

The latest recommendation with respect to this issue is to use:

jleni commented 4 years ago

@faboweb Now that Lunie has upgraded to WebHID in Windows. I think we can close this issue, agree?

faboweb commented 4 years ago

Yes finally!!

wordkeepa commented 4 years ago

How to enable WebHID in Chrome?

faboweb commented 4 years ago

Copy this URL into your address bar: chrome://flags/#enable-experimental-web-platform-features

wordkeepa commented 4 years ago

Thank you!