cowinapi / developer.cowin

This group is created to facilitate technical and integration discussions related to cowin platform. API related contents can be obtained at API setu portal https://apisetu.gov.in/public/marketplace/api/cowin
115 stars 30 forks source link

Why not just have a lottery system on daily basis.. #145

Closed nagesh-salunke closed 3 years ago

nagesh-salunke commented 3 years ago

Why not just have a lottery system on daily basis? The booking system isn't fair for a large number of users, an only select hundred from thousands who are trying are getting slots and it's also based on the luck of their request reaching servers fast!

The lottery can be drawn between applied people for a center on a daily basis

monish-1234 commented 3 years ago

Not sure if you're sarcastic or if you're actually recommending it. I would say the issue is with the low availability of vaccines and importantly the tons of people who register and then not show up to Vaccinate.

63 This issue would solve that problem.

nagesh-salunke commented 3 years ago

In the current scenario, If we have to be really "fair" for distribution, I see the Lottery option could be more realistic Given that there is already a vaccine shortage, there are very few paid centers Also, I don't think people are booking slots unnecessarily, Given that how hard it is to book and get a slot, Doing that for fun itself is a task!

zerebral commented 3 years ago

In the current scenario, If we have to be really "fair" for distribution, I see the Lottery option could be more realistic Given that there is already a vaccine shortage, there are very few paid centers Also, I don't think people are booking slots unnecessarily, Given that how hard it is to book and get a slot, Doing that for fun itself is a task!

True. Looking out an active slot is quite an ask and is wasting hours of productive time! (at least for those who care for it) - I think the CoWIN app needs to probably allot slots on a first come first serve basis and those who do not accept or miss it should not get another chance for a few weeks at least or should be placed at the back end of the queue perhaps!

nagesh-salunke commented 3 years ago

"First come first serve basis" is very difficult on "internet" scale Example : My daily help and my driver won't be able to get the vaccine slots for months with the current scenario. First - They would need "high" speed internet Second - They should be lucky enough to be first

The system is adding to the problem of vaccine shortage by being discriminative on who gets the vaccine! Software systems are supposed to "solve" the problem and not add more problems!

zerebral commented 3 years ago

People are travelling to other districts as well to get the jab and the locals there are opposing, sending them back. Perhaps rightly so! To curtail such issues CoWIN needs to just put people in a centrally managed queue per zip code and then notify them when their day arrives! This way the data could be used centrally to ensure vaccine availability where there is more demand!

zerebral commented 3 years ago

"First come first serve basis" is very difficult on "internet" scale Example : My daily help and my driver won't be able to get the vaccine slots for months with the current scenario. First - They would need "high" speed internet Second - They should be lucky enough to be first

The system is adding to the problem of vaccine shortage by being discriminative on who gets the vaccine! Software systems are supposed to "solve" the problem and not add more problems!

Yeah, unfair that way! Totally! CoWIN would know the target demographics and can schedule people from various categories to make it fair. There are smart people out there I suppose who can solve these internet scale problems! But I get it, a vast majority may not even have a cell phone (let alone internet access!) - poor guys just have to walk-in and get lucky! :-(

karanssh commented 3 years ago

Adding on to this, I would recommend devs to please add something like "Book for me when available" - similar to a lottery system, but at least you don't have to spend all day hoping to get a slot.