cplusplus / nbballot

Handling of NB comments in response to ballots
14 stars 4 forks source link

CS016 Address 39 specific comments in edited DIS document #392

Closed jensmaurer closed 3 years ago

jensmaurer commented 3 years ago

An edited file of the DIS has been prepared by ISO/CS. Please note that the DIS edited file contains 39 comments on specific elements of the document, which need to be fixed so the document complies with the Directives, Part 2.

Please take all the comments in to consideration to avoid rejection at the next stage.

jensmaurer commented 3 years ago

@zygoloid , do you have the "edited file of the DIS" this comment is talking about? Please send it to the co-editors.

zygoloid commented 3 years ago

I don't have it; I have requested that ISO/CS provide us with this file.

zygoloid commented 3 years ago

I've made a pass through these, and I think #393 and #395 capture the only remaining open issues here.

tkoeppe commented 3 years ago

This concludes the review. All PDF comments have been address, and all but one have been accepted. The one that we rejected is a reference to CS-19, #395.

tkoeppe commented 3 years ago

Final disposition: Accepted with modifications: All but one comment from the annotated document have been accepted and addressed. The one rejected comment is a reference to **019, see there for the rejection rationale.