P3284 R1 `finally`, `write_env`, and `unstoppable` Sender Adaptors

wg21bot commented 6 months ago

P3284R0 finally, write_env, and unstoppable Sender Adaptors (Eric Niebler)

ben-craig commented 4 months ago

2024-07-16 Library Evolution Telecon

P3284R0: finally, write_env, and unstoppable Sender Adaptors

Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Ben Craig Minute Taker: Mark Hoemmen

__POLL: Approve the design of write_env (in P3284R0) (still need wording review)__

SF	WF	N	WA	SA
3	5	0	0	0

Attendance: 15

# of Authors: 1

Author Position: SF

Outcome: Unanimous consent

Comments:

POLL: Approve the design of unstoppable (in P3284R0) (still need wording review)

SF	WF	N	WA	SA
4	2	0	0	0

Attendance: 15

# of Authors: 1

Author Position: SF

Outcome: Consent? Low voting turnout

Comments:

Fix the write_env calls in 3.2 unstoppable, so that they construct a prop.

LEWG will pick up design review with finally, and then go on to wording review.

FabioFracassi commented 3 months ago

P3284R1: finally, write_env, and unstoppable Sender Adaptors

Champion: Eric Niebler Chair: Fabio Fracassi Minute Taker: Ben Craig

Paper Forwarding Checklist:

Why should this utility go into the standard library? - Expressiveness/UX of S/R customizations
Examples? - Yes
Discussion of prior art? - Yes
Implementation experience? - Yes
Usage experience? - Yes
Deployment experience? - No
Performance considerations? - N/A
Changes Library Evolution previously requested? - Yes
Support in "std::format" and "hash" (if required)? - N/A
Feature test macro? - See discussion on P3325
Freestanding? - N/A
Wording? - Yes, reviewed everything but finally

Reviewed and approved wording of write_env and unstoppable. Discussed finally. Esp. wrt. error forwarding behavior

Author will add rationale for the error forwarding behavior. Next revision will be seen by LEWG.

wg21bot commented 3 months ago

P3284R1 finally, write_env, and unstoppable Sender Adaptors (Eric Niebler)