craigsapp
commented
9 years ago Now they are known :-). The regression tests should now all work properly on your computer. To update the software, it is probably best to erase the humdrum-tools directory:
rm -rf humdrum-toolsand reinstall with the command:
git clone --recursive https://github.com/humdrum-tools/humdrum-toolsand then install as before. Normally typing make update in the humdrum-tools directory is sufficient to download a new version of the code, but I fixed a problem in git thinking that the "humdrum.1" man page should be spelled "Humdrum.1" which causes problems if trying to update in the normal manner...
1. Problem with accent regression test
This was a tricky problem to track down, and it was a error occurring on your computer (the test was correct). The problem was due to the backslash characters in \' (and \") in regular expressions related to assigning accents weightings to articulations. After the backslashes were removed, the tests seems to be successful. The \' was causing all notes to be marked as accent (with ART=0.95 in the sample output below). The notes were not accented and should have an ART=0.5 in the output.
Here is the input:
**kern
*clefG2
*M4/4
*k[]
*C:
=1-
4c
4d
4e
4f
=2
2g
2a
=3
2b
2cc
==
*-Here is the correct output (as before):
**accent
*clefG2
*M4/4
*k[]
*C:
*
=1-
0.763636 AGO:1.0000 MEL:1 MET:1 DEG:1 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
0.621433 AGO:1.0000 MEL:0.33 MET:0.333333 DEG:0.548031 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
0.638972 AGO:1.0000 MEL:0.2211 MET:0.5 DEG:0.689764 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
0.620499 AGO:1.0000 MEL:0.2211 MET:0.333333 DEG:0.644094 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
=2
0.693703 AGO:1 MEL:0.2211 MET:1 DEG:0.817323 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
0.630726 AGO:1 MEL:0.2211 MET:0.5 DEG:0.576378 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
=3
0.667247 AGO:1 MEL:0.2211 MET:1 DEG:0.453543 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
0.694182 AGO:1 MEL:0.67 MET:0.5 DEG:1 ART:0.5 VOC:1 PHR:
==
*-Here is incorrect output caused by \' in a regular expression which caused all notes to be considered accented (ART=0.95), apparently in certain version of awk and/or bash only:
**accent
*clefG2
*M4/4
*k[]
*C:
*
=1-
0.878182 AGO:1.0000 MEL:1 MET:1 DEG:1 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
0.735978 AGO:1.0000 MEL:0.33 MET:0.333333 DEG:0.548031 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
0.753517 AGO:1.0000 MEL:0.2211 MET:0.5 DEG:0.689764 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
0.735044 AGO:1.0000 MEL:0.2211 MET:0.333333 DEG:0.644094 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
=2
0.808249 AGO:1 MEL:0.2211 MET:1 DEG:0.817323 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
0.745271 AGO:1 MEL:0.2211 MET:0.5 DEG:0.576378 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
=3
0.781792 AGO:1 MEL:0.2211 MET:1 DEG:0.453543 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
0.808727 AGO:1 MEL:0.67 MET:0.5 DEG:1 ART:0.95 VOC:1 PHR:
==
*-On my OS X 10.9.5 laptop, I was getting the correct results for some reason (maybe you are not using the default bash shell or awk version that I was using). But in any case it should now be fixed in both computer configurations since quotes should not be backslash escaped in regular expressions.
2. Problem with ekern regression test
Overall this test was successful (as you probably noticed since you did not mention it), but it output additional warning errors which do not happen on my OS X 10.9.5 computer. I have probably suppressed the errors by changing regular expressions \] into [[]. Here is the version of awk I am using in OSX 10.9.5 which might be different that yours:
$ awk --version
awk version 20070501In Fedora 20 linux I was getting the same warning messages as you were, and the respelling of the regular expressions fixed the problem on that platform.
3. Problem with infot regression test
The problem with the infot regression test was due to the input data for the test: the output data was a set of sorted lines, but all sort values were the same. This probably caused a different random order for different computers (I ran the test on OS X 10.9.5 and got the expected order, probably since I created the test on my computer :-). A new test input file replaces the old one:
**data
A
B
C
B
A
A
A
C
B
C
B
A
A
A
*-The expected output is
A 1.000
B 1.807
C 2.222The regression tests are all working for me now in OS X 10.9.5 and Fedora ~20 Linux:
TEST 01 for humsed: OK
TEST 01 for tonh: OK
TEST 01 for context: OK
TEST 01 for dur: OK
TEST 01 for assemble: OK
TEST 01 for solfa: OK
TEST 01 for recode: OK
TEST 01 for cbr: OK
TEST 01 for semits: OK
TEST 01 for proof: OK
TEST 01 for xdelta: OK
TEST 01 for trans: OK
TEST 01 for nf: OK
TEST 01 for infot: OK
TEST 01 for melac: OK
TEST 01 for yank: OK
TEST 01 for cocho: OK
TEST 01 for reihe: OK
TEST 01 for specc: OK
TEST 01 for mint: OK
TEST 01 for freq: OK
TEST 01 for patt: OK
TEST 01 for solfg: OK
TEST 01 for pattern: OK
TEST 01 for barks: OK
TEST 01 for pitch: OK
TEST 01 for text: OK
TEST 01 for hint: OK
TEST 01 for strophe: OK
TEST 01 for cents: OK
TEST 01 for urrhythm: OK
TEST 01 for rend: OK
TEST 01 for deg: OK
TEST 01 for vox: OK
TEST 01 for fields: OK
TEST 01 for degree: OK
TEST 01 for accent: OK
TEST 01 for num: OK
TEST 01 for pcset: OK
TEST 01 for rid: OK
TEST 02 for rid: OK
TEST 03 for rid: OK
TEST 04 for rid: OK
TEST 05 for rid: OK
TEST 06 for rid: OK
TEST 07 for rid: OK
TEST 08 for rid: OK
TEST 09 for rid: OK
TEST 10 for rid: OK
TEST 11 for rid: OK
TEST 12 for rid: OK
TEST 13 for rid: OK
TEST 14 for rid: OK
TEST 15 for rid: OK
TEST 16 for rid: OK
TEST 17 for rid: OK
TEST 18 for rid: OK
TEST 01 for thru: OK
TEST 01 for key: OK
TEST 01 for ydelta: OK
TEST 01 for correl: OK
TEST 01 for cleave: OK
TEST 01 for metpos: OK
TEST 01 for timebase: OK
TEST 01 for pf: OK
TEST 01 for pc: OK
TEST 01 for ditto: OK
TEST 01 for humdrum: OK
TEST 02 for humdrum: OK
TEST 03 for humdrum: OK
TEST 04 for humdrum: OK
TEST 05 for humdrum: OK
TEST 06 for humdrum: OK
TEST 07 for humdrum: OK
TEST 08 for humdrum: OK
TEST 09 for humdrum: OK
TEST 10 for humdrum: OK
TEST 11 for humdrum: OK
TEST 12 for humdrum: OK
TEST 13 for humdrum: OK
TEST 14 for humdrum: OK
TEST 15 for humdrum: OK
TEST 16 for humdrum: OK
TEST 17 for humdrum: OK
TEST 18 for humdrum: OK
TEST 19 for humdrum: OK
TEST 20 for humdrum: OK
TEST 21 for humdrum: OK
TEST 22 for humdrum: OK
TEST 23 for humdrum: OK
TEST 24 for humdrum: OK
TEST 25 for humdrum: OK
TEST 26 for humdrum: OK
TEST 27 for humdrum: OK
TEST 30 for humdrum: OK
TEST 31 for humdrum: OK
TEST 32 for humdrum: OK
TEST 33 for humdrum: OK
TEST 35 for humdrum: OK
TEST 36 for humdrum: OK
TEST 37 for humdrum: OK
TEST 38 for humdrum: OK
TEST 39 for humdrum: OK
TEST 01 for synco: OK
TEST 01 for scramble: OK
TEST 01 for iv: OK
TEST 01 for veritas: OK
TEST 01 for kern: OK
TEST 01 for ekern: OK
TEST 01 for extract: OK
TEST 01 for census: OK
MarcPerlman
I've been trying to install humdrum-tools on Mac OS 10.9.5.
The tools seem to install OK:
local $ which keycor /usr/local/humdrum-tools/humextra/bin/keycor local $
However, there are two (accent & infot) that fail the regression test:
[ ... ]
Are these known problems?
Thanks, Marc Perlman