cran-task-views / ctv

CRAN Task View Initiative
79 stars 13 forks source link

CRAN task view proposal: ColorPalettes #47

Closed dicook closed 11 months ago

dicook commented 1 year ago

The Graphics CTV was archived several years ago because it wasn't sufficiently maintained, and there were way too many packages listed. It needed to be broken into smaller subsets. This is a proposal for creating several new CTVs covering the vast range of graphics capabilities in R.

Scope

This CTV will provide a list of available colour palettes in R packages, and resources on choosing appropriate palettes.

Packages

Overlap

There is no overlap with current CTVs.

Maintainers

Di Cook and Emil Hvitfeldt

zeileis commented 1 year ago

Thanks, Di @dicook and Emil @EmilHvitfeldt, for this proposal. I think that a color-related task view would be a very useful addition but why feeling is that "color palettes" is maybe too narrow.

With packages like paletteer and pals we already cover a very wide range of palettes consisting of sets of hex codes. Hence my feeling is that we don't need a task view that lists every package which has extracted such sets of hex codes from some movies, paintings, photos, etc. Instead there might be more interest in packages that allow the creation of custom palettes, modifying existing ones, assessing their suitability in different contexts, combining them with different graphics packages, etc.

You might also get in touch with Olivier Eterradossi (olivier.eterradossi at mines-ales.fr, LinkedIn) who had expressed interest in setting up a color task view some years ago. Eventually it didn't come together but he might be willing to contribute to this initiative.

Another person who might have valuable inputs is Martijn Tennekes who recently set up cols4all and worked quite a bit on assessing different palettes.

Two other small comments:

rociojoo commented 1 year ago

Thanks @dicook and @EmilHvitfeldt. I didn't know there were so many color palette packages! I agree with @zeileis that a color TV would be more useful, and perhaps doable if you work with the people Achim mentioned. It depends of course on whether you'd be motivated to do so.

zeileis commented 11 months ago

Thanks again, Di @dicook and Emil @EmilHvitfeldt, for the initiative and your work so far. Given that there was no follow-up, I'm closing this issue now. If you are still interested in setting up a color-related task view we would be very happy to receive a new proposal. If so: