MC member votes no - holds application

creativecommons / commoners

Creative Commons Global Network website

https://network.creativecommons.org/

GNU General Public License v2.0

12 stars 18 forks source link

MC member votes no - holds application #396

Closed Juliabrungs closed 4 years ago

Juliabrungs commented 4 years ago

When one MC member has voted no, the application should be on hold until review by the MC and no other MC members should be able to vote on it.

hugosolar commented 4 years ago

@Juliabrungs I have a question regarding this issue what's happen when the MC approves or deny this review?

Juliabrungs commented 4 years ago

So the idea is that when an MC member votes 'no' the application automatically closes and is rejected and no other MC member can vote on it. I then send an email and the MC reviews the application. If they come to the conclusion that it is indeed a 'no' vote, the application gets rejected. If a majority thinks the application is fine, the 'no' vote is removed and the application is voted on by 5 members. Does that make sense?

hugosolar commented 4 years ago

So I'll follow these steps

If the applicant gets a 'no' vote the application can't be voted anymore and it gets marked on the Applications for appoval list
I'll reuse the same MC review form we're using when a user gets a 'no' vouch
If the MC resolves the issue as a 'Yes'
- the 'no' vote is removed and the applicant status is back to the voting stage
If the MC resolves the issue as a 'No'
- the Application is declined and the user is notified

Juliabrungs commented 4 years ago

Yes! That is it!