MineCraft-Voxelforge resource pack comparisons

[crispiebacon]

Left side is this pack, right is mc.

These images are for July 21, 2024

[DragonWrangler1]

Stone and sandstone are too close imo.

[crispiebacon]

You don't give me much of a chance to update stuff quickly do you ? I'll get to work on it in a minute.

[crispiebacon]

there. How's that ?

[DragonWrangler1]

sandstone's color isn't consistant with sand.

[crispiebacon]

There: better ?

[DragonWrangler1]

Ya. I guess so.

[crispiebacon]

bundles added.

[DragonWrangler1]

Nice. I'll add in a few.

[DragonWrangler1]

I've started using an online program to compare the images. (so far only done 2), but

Sand similarity to mc is about 27.89% and Dirt is about 33.11% very good job.

[DragonWrangler1]

Just a side note. If I find any images that are closer than 50% to the original, then I will be requesting them changed.

Edit: here's the website I'm using to see. https://www.imgonline.com.ua/eng/similarity-percent.php I'm having it set to black and white not being considered different.

[DragonWrangler1]

Snow is too close 56% similarity. Redstone block is also too close at 83% similarity. empty bundle is cutting it close at 78% difference. 2% remaining before it could be considered copyright infringment. same for filled except that one has 2.32%

Both podzol textures also too close.

Grass block side and snowy grass side way too close. Within 15% difference.

[DragonWrangler1]

Image similarity For between VoxelForge resource pack and MineCraft.

default_dirt.png --- dirt.png ========================================= 33.11% similarity. Meaning there is a 66.89% difference.
default_sand.png --- sand.png ========================================= 27.89% similarity. Meaning there is a 72.11% difference.
default_snow.png --- snow.png ========================================= 55.79% similarity. Meaning there is a 44.21% difference. WARNING: TOO CLOSE.
default_stone.png --- stone.png ======================================= 46.75% similarity. Meaning there is a 53.25% difference.
redstone_redstone_block.png --- redstone_block.png ==================== 83.32% similarity. Meaning there is a 16.68% difference. WARNING: WAY TOO CLOSE.
underwater_overlay.png --- underwater.png ============================= 28.56% similarity. Meaning there is a 71.44% difference.
vlf_bundles_bundle.png --- bundle.png ================================= 78.00% similarity. Meaning there is a 22.00% difference. WARNING: TOO CLOSE.
vlf_bundles_bundle.png --- bundle.png ================================= 77.68% similarity. Meaning there is a 22.32% difference. WARNING: TOO CLOSE.
vlf_core_coal_ore.png --- coal_ore.png ================================ 49.49% similarity. Meaning there is a 50.51% difference.
vlf_core_podzol_side.png --- podzol_side.png ========================== 53.55% similarity. Meaning there is a 46.45% difference. WARNING: TOO CLOSE.
vlf_core_podzol_top.png --- podzol_top.png ============================ 50.81% similarity. Meaning there is a 49.19% differnece. WARNING: TOO CLOSE.
vlf_core_grass_overlay.png --- grass_overlay.png ====================== 89.52% similarity. Meaning there is a 10.48% difference. WARNING: WAY TOO CLOSE.
vlf_core_grass_block_top.png --- grass_block_top.png ================== 33.71% similarity. Meaning there is a 66.29% difference.
vlf_core_grass_block_snowed.png --- grass_block_snow.png =============== 91.06% similarity. Meaning there is a 8.94% difference. Warning: WAY TOO CLOSE.
vlf_core_red_sand.png --- red_sand.png ================================ 29.03% similarity. Meaning there is a 70.97% difference.
vlf_core_red_sandstone_carved.png --- red_standstone_chiseled.png ===== 73.02% similarity. Meaning there is a 26.98% difference. WARNING: TOO CLOSE.
vlf_core_red_sandstone_top.png --- red_sandstone_top.png ============== 47.61% similarity. Meaning there is a 52.39% difference.
vlf_core_sandstone_carved.png --- sandstone_chiseled.png ============== 85.28% similarity. Meaning there is a 14.72% difference. WARNING: WAY TOO CLOSE.
vlf_core_sandstone_top.png --- sandstone_top.png ====================== 47.31% similarity. Meaning there is a 52.69% difference.
vlf_flowers_tall_grass.png --- shortgrass.png ========================= 85.13% similarity. Meaning there is a 14.87% difference. WARNING: WAY TOO CLOSE.
vlf_nether_soul_sand.png --- soul_sand.png ============================ 76.05% similarity. Meaning there is a 23.95% difference. WARNING: TOO CLOSE

[DragonWrangler1]

Anything under 50 is marked too close and anything under 20 is marked way too close. Only. 12 to fix though.

[crispiebacon]

Wow. Nice work, But. Uh. Soul Sand has a 76.05% similarily ?

[DragonWrangler1]

Ya. I don't fully agree with that analysis either. Just like I don't believe that bramaudi's iron golem texture from pixel imperfection resource pack is only 19% different from the original.