search

criticalmass-one / criticalmass-in

Main application for criticalmass.in
https://criticalmass.in/
32 stars 8 forks source link

Participant estimation #745

Open ossie opened 3 years ago

ossie commented 3 years ago

Current behaviour A second participant number estimation by the same user is counted as a new estimation and calculated into the average.

Expected behaviour The second estimation should be considered as a correction of the first one. e.g.: I estimated 50 and after counting the participants in a video I entered 62: Now the number, based on my estimation only, is 56.

maltehuebner commented 3 years ago

Thank you for addressing this issue.

I got many questions regarding participant estimation after the kidical mass last weekend. I guess there is a lot of work waiting for me as the estimation system is one of the oldest parts of the critical mass application.

At the moment, the system grabs all estimations assigned to a ride and calculates the average. This isn’t even kind of transparent, as it leads to rough estimates.

https://github.com/criticalmass-one/criticalmass-in/blob/master/src/Criticalmass/Statistic/RideEstimateCalculator/RideEstimateCalculator.php

I would prefer to add a list to the ride overview page where all estimates are presented in a table and the community can pick the most accurate. Additionally, it should be possible to add a coordinate to the estimate to see where the bikes were counted.