croneter / PlexKodiConnect

Plex integration in Kodi done right
GNU General Public License v2.0
1.16k stars 77 forks source link

"Force transcode Hi10p" causes audio to also transcode #1681

Open Tyestor opened 2 years ago

Tyestor commented 2 years ago

Help yourself

Describe the bug

"Force transcode hi10p" causes audio to also transcode. Audio transcodes no matter whether I select burn in subtitles or disable subtitles.

To Reproduce

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Go to PlexKodiConnect settings
  2. Enable "Force transcode hi10p"
  3. Play h264 10-bit file
  4. Go to Plex dashboard
  5. See audio transcoding unnecessarily

Expected behavior

With "Force transcode Hi10p" enabled, I expect H264 10-bit video to be transcoded down to H264 8-bit at as close to the original bitrate as possible, leaving audio untouched (direct play). I also expect to be able to burn in subtitles and have it not affect audio transcoding.

You need to attach a KODI LOG FILE!

kodi.log

Extra

My Android TV is capable of direct playing FLAC without issue. I cannot direct play H264 10-bit without serious frame drops.

h26410bit.txt

"Force transcode Hi10p" enabled with subs

plex-dash-1

"Force transcode Hi10p" enabled without subs

plex-dash-2

"Force transcode Hi10p" setting DISABLED

plex-dash-3

Tyestor commented 2 years ago

Tried with a different H264 10-bit file that had AAC audio instead and same result (can direct play this audio no problem as well).

h26410bit-mediainfo-2.txt

image

Tyestor commented 2 years ago

Playing the same episode via the Android Plex app:

image

This is expected as the support for ASS on Android in the official Plex app is crapola currently. Note the lack of audio transcoding.